It’s a battle of titans in today’s mattress comparison. In one corner, we have Saatva, one of the early founders of the online mattress industry, they have been selling hybrid / coil-on-coil luxury mattresses for 4 years. In the other corner, we have Casper. Over the last 2 years Casper has become one of the largest and most popular online mattress companies. But which mattress is truly king of sleep? Continue reading to find out who reigns victorious in our Saatva vs. Casper mattress review.
Don’t have time to read the entire comparison? Skip to the review summary for the quick version.
Saatva Mattress Review
Separating themselves from most mattresses, Saatva takes a different approach, constructing a mattress that is built on 2 layers of steel coils. With a thickness of 14.5″ (11.5″ thickness available as well), this coil-on-coil hybrid system assists in improving comfort, support, and longevity.
- Cover & Euro-Style Pillow Top – Built with an organic cotton cover, the top layer is both breathable and soft. A euro-style pillow top is stuffed within the cover, adding great comfort and softness, without sacrificing the clean tight aesthetic.
- Memory Foam – Immediately below the cover is a thin layer of memory foam. This layer provides additional lumbar support.
- Comfort Layer (foam encased contour coils) – A 4″ layer of individually foam encased coils serves as the comfort and contouring support layer. These foam encased coils contour and evenly support the curves of your body. There are 884 individually foam encased coils in the Queen size mattress.
- Edge Support System (encased in foam) – Completely encased with foam, this layer sits between the top and bottom layer of coils and along the edge of the mattress. This edge support layer reinforces the edges of the mattress, improving performance for both sitting and sleeping.
- Foundation Layer (hourglass steel coils) – The bottom layer support base consists of traditional hourglass shaped steel coils. These coils serve as a foundational layer, delivering great support and shape for the mattress. Within the queen size, a total of 416 coils provide 7″ of thickness.
Constructed from 100% organic cotton, this cover is exceptionally well made. It is highly breathable, has a cool feel, and is also soft. This is very similar to the cover Saatva uses on their luxury 100% foam mattress, the Loom & Leaf.
The pillow top adds a great softness and comfort to the mattress. Compared to traditional style pillow tops, euro-style is structured in a different way. Euro-style is inserted underneath the organic cotton cover and seamlessly aligns to the edge of the mattress, giving it a more aesthetically appealing look. The euro-style design is in contrast to the traditional pillow top, which are sewn to the top of mattress itself; traditional pillow tops give the appearance of a large pillow resting on top of your mattress.
This euro-style pillow top design creates softness and comfort from the combination of 1.25″ soft foam in the cover + 1 oz Darcon + 3/4″ Fiber fill. While traditional style pillow tops tend to lose their structure and softness over time, euro-style’s construction has improved durability.
Firmness, Feel, & Support
The Saatva has taken a different approach towards firmness. Instead of the traditional “one-firmness-fits-all” method, they have decided to offer 3 different levels. Ranging from levels 3-8 on the firmness scale (1= least firm, 10= most firm). The softest Saatva, the Plush soft, is a 3 out of 10. The medium feel Saatva, the Luxury Firm, is a 6 out of 10. And lastly, the most hard Saatva, the Saatva Firm, is an 8 out of 10.
At first lie on the mattress, you will feel the instantaneous softness and comfort from the euro-style pillow top. The coil-on-coil layers offers great support as well. The coil-on-coil design allows all sleeper types, positions, and sizes to be well supported, while the comfort top layers helps to alleviate pressure points. With regards to the material construction, Saatva does a good job of merging organic and healthy materials within each level of their mattress. The cover is constructed from 100% organic cotton. Instead of a fire sock or chemical based flame retardant, Saatva uses natural thistle as the fire barrier. Additionally, the steel coils are all recycled. Is it 100% organic? No, but I do like and appreciate that Saatva is taking steps to create a little more healthy and environmentally responsible product.
NEED MORE? Read the full Saatva mattress review
Although Saatva offers multiple thickness levels (11.5″ and 14.5″), the two mattresses have the same feel and price point. The different heights are simply there if you have an aesthetic preference for a thicker or thinner mattress. Prices only vary depending on the size of the mattress, not the thickness level.
- Shipping – 7-15 days, $99 delivery fee
- Warranty – 15 years- First 2 years = full replacement; Years 3-15 = Repairs dependent on defects
- Trial Period – 75 days
- Returns – 100% money back if you decide the Saatva’s not the right choice for you
Casper Mattress Review
The Casper is a 10″ all foam mattress built from 3 different layers of foam.
- Top Layer (latex foam) – built from 1.5” of latex foam, this layer provides the bounce, cooling, and comfort for the mattress.
- Middle Layer (memory foam) – 1.5” of memory foam allow this layer to deliver support and pressure relief. Placed below the latex foam layer, it helps to prevent heat retention issues that could potentially occur with memory foam.
- Bottom Layer (support foam) – 7” support foam layer acts as a foundational base and provides shape for the mattress.
Providing the best of both worlds from latex and memory foam, this foam mattress allows you to keep cool during the night. Memory foam has a reputation of “sleeping hot,” but by placing the latex layer on top of the memory foam, the mattress is able to breathe in addition to offering good support and body contouring provided by the memory foam.
The Casper cover is modest, but well constructed. The 2-tone design is a nice change of pace vs. the typical all white mattress covers. The white fabric on top is 100% polyester. It’s soft and quite porous. The extra porous weave helps to improve breathability and surface cooling on the mattress. The white fabric on top is sourced in the USA and woven in South Carolina. The grey side panels come from Belgium.
Firmness, Feel, & Support
With regards to firmness, the Casper mattress is medium. Based off of my sleep tests, I would rate the Casper at about a 6-7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. This mattress is designed to have a “universal comfort” feel to meet the needs of most sleepers. If you’re a heavier sleeper, you will likely find that the Casper sleeps a bit closer to a 7 on the firmness scale. This is because heavier sleepers will sink deeper into the mattress, down to the denser and harder layers. You’ll begin to see this if you’re over 200 pounds, but especially anyone 250+ will experience this more acutely.
With a nice degree of softness, Casper generates a fairly distinct hug around your body. While lying normally at a weight of 140lbs, I found that the mattress sinks about 1-1.5 inches. While the Casper does have a pronounced hug, it is not pronounced in the way that memory foam normally is. A memory foam mattress will hug and more sharply contour to the sleeper’s shape. Casper’s top layer of latex allows the sleeper to sink at a similar level, creating a bit of a light underlying bounce feel, but it doesn’t create an overly enveloped memory hug. The latex offers great response, bounce, and a hug that doesn’t trap sleepers like more traditional memory foams sometimes can. Support on the Casper is average.
NEED MORE: Read the full Casper review
- Shipping – free, 1-5 days, compressed in a box
- Warranty – 10 years
- Trail Period – 100 Days
- Returns – 100% money back if the Casper isn’t the right mattress choice for you
Below is our complete side-by-side mattress comparison of the Saatva vs. Casper mattress
|Foam Layers||1.5" latex foam, 1.5" memory foam, 7.0" support foam||1.25" soft foam, 1" memory foam, 4" foam encased coils, 7" hourglass shaped coils|
|Height||10"||11.5" & 14.5"|
|Cover||Soft, decent thickness, good stretch, good cooling||100% organic cotton, soft, highly breathable|
|Firmness||6-7 out of 10||3 out of 10|
6 out of 10
8 out of 10
|Support||Very good||Very good|
|Motion Transfer||Very minimal||Very minimal|
|Price - Queen||$850||$899|
|Price - King||$950||$1,299|
|Warranty||10 years||15 years|
|Trial Period||100 nights||75 nights|
|Shipping||Free, 1-5 days, compressed in a box||$99, 7-15 days, white-glove delivery service|
|Refunds & Returns||Yes||Yes|
Should you buy the Saatva or Casper Mattress?
Saatva and Casper each have their pros and cons. However, after sleeping on both mattresses for several months, I found the Saatva to be the better overall mattress in my opinion.
I would recommend the Saatva mattress to anyone who falls into the following categories:
- You want the option of a soft, medium, or hard firmness mattress – the Saatva mattress offers three firmness levels. Their plush soft, which is about 3 out of 10 on the firmness scale (10 being the most firm), their luxury firm, which is about a 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale, and their firm, which is about a 8 out of 10 on the firmness scale.
- You want all around better support – Saatva has tremendous support throughout the entire mattress. Their 5 layer coil-on-coil design helps to maintain great shape and contour in the long run. Regardless of what sleeping position you prefer, the Saatva molds to your body due to the coil-on-coil design, individually wrap coils, and euro-style pillow top.
- You want more bounce – the Saatva mattress offers great bounce that goes hand in hand with..ahem, bedroom exercise. Sex on the Saatva was remarkably enjoyable due to the elevated amount of bounce the coil-on-coil design offers.
- You want more edge support – the Saatva is structurally created with excellent edge support. The coil-on-coil design already gives it improved edge support vs. most foam mattresses. This is further enhanced by the edge support system that reinforces all 4 edges of the mattress, improving both sleeping and sitting positions.
If the Saatva doesn’t feel like the right mattress choice at the time, or it’s a little too expensive, the Casper can still serve as a good mattress.
I would recommend the Casper to anyone who falls into the following categories:
- You want a medium firmness level – ranging from a 6-7 out of 10 in the firmness scale, the Casper feels softer for lighter people and slightly firmer for heavier sleepers.
- You prefer a mattress with a noticeable hug – topped with a soft layer of latex, the Casper exhibits a more notable hug. The Casper allows sleepers to sink into the foam, improving feel, but doesn’t trap sleepers the way some memory foam mattresses can.
- You want to take the less expensive route – ranging from $500-$950 the Casper is the slightly less expensive option.