Select Page

Tuft and Needle vs. Casper Mattress Review

Sleepopolis is supported by readers. Product links on Sleepopolis are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something Sleepopolis makes a little bit of money. Need more info? See how it all works here.

Casper and Tuft and Needle are two of the most popular factory direct mattress start-ups of 2014. They are both shaking things up in a big way with their direct-to-consumer model. No more fancy stores with rows of beds, no more beds with remote controls, but most importantly, no more mattress middle men.

Thinking about buying a Casper or Tuft & Needle? Do your homework! Check out these 4 mattress companies that Sleepopolis loves.

Read on for our head-to-head Casper vs. Tuft & Needle Review.

Casper or Tuft and Needle Mattress?

Looking for the quick summary version? Jump to our comparison summary at the bottom to find out which mattress is best for you.


Foam Layers

The Tuft & Needle and Casper have both taken a fairly unique approach to their foam construction.

Casper is a hybrid mattress. The top layer is 1.5 inches of latex foam. The middle layer is 1.5 inches of memory foam. And the bottom layer is a 7 inch support foam base. This type of a hybrid mattress is aimed at getting the best of both worlds of latex foam and memory foam.

Casper mattress layers (top to bottom) - 1.5" layer of latex foam, 1.5" layer of memory foam, 6.5" layer of support foam

Casper mattress layers (top to bottom) – 1.5″ layer of latex foam, 1.5″ layer of memory foam, 6.5″ layer of support foam

Having the latex foam layer on top helps the Casper mattress sleep cool, while still being highly supportive with the memory foam beneath it (more on the feel down below).

The Tuft & Needle’s construction is more minimized. T&N only uses 2 layers. The top layer acts as both the comfort and support layer. It is 3 inches of custom polyurethane foam developed for and by Tuft & Needle. The base of the Tuft & Needle is 7 inches of support foam also.

Tuft & Needle foam mattress layers (top to bottom): 3" polyurethane comfort foam, 7" polyurethane support foam

Tuft & Needle foam mattress layers (top to bottom): 3″ polyurethane comfort foam, 7″ polyurethane support foam

Tuft & Needle’s foam is a highly developed foam designed to provide great comfort, support, and dissipate heat.


Both the Casper & Tuft & Needle have fairly similar covers. Both covers are fairly simple, white, a bit stretchy, and have a next textured feel. Both are also average thickness and soft.

Close up shot of the Casper mattress cover

Close up shot of the Casper mattress cover

Close up shot of the Tuft and Needle mattress cover

Close up shot of the Tuft and Needle mattress cover

From a functionality standpoint, I don’t see any major differences between the cover. It really comes down to which you prefer aesthetically.

Firmness, Comfort, & Support

Comparing firmness, the Tuft & Needle is just marginally firmer than Casper. I would rate the Tuft & Needle at a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale (where 10 is the firmest), whereas the Casper is a 6 out of 10.

Despite their relative similarity in firmness, the feel of each mattress is quite different.

Casper’s softness translates through a more pronounced “hug” like feeling. When you lie into the Casper you’ll feel a bit more sinkage as the latex layer conforms to your body.

Casper mattress on a King size platform bed

Casper mattress on a King size platform bed

The Tuft & Needle on the other hand keeps you a bit more buoyant on top of the mattress. It does not have a hug like sensation. It’s soft, yes, but you will not feel yourself sink enough to have a pronounced “hug” around your body.

Tuft and Needle mattress, King size on slat bed

Tuft and Needle mattress, King size on slat bed

Both the Casper & the Tuft & Needle have good support no matter what your sleep position is. During my sleep tests of each of these mattresses I never felt like either lacked in the support area.


In a side-by-side price comparison, Tuft & Needle simply crushes it on price. If you’re looking for a well-made foam mattress at the lowest dollar amount, you aren’t going to find better than Tuft & Needle.

SizeTuft & NeedleCasper
Twin XL$375$600
California King$750$950

For more on pricing and specific options head over here: Casper Mattress Prices and Tuft and Needle Prices.

Tuft & Needle vs Casper Side-by-Side Comparison

Sometimes the best way to decide the right option is to simply lay out all the cards on the table and see what’s most important to you. Both Casper and Tuft & Needle are exceptional mattresses, but your specific needs, priorities, and preferences will vary, likely making one a little bit better.

Below is a complete list of all the major comparison points of Casper vs. Tuft & Needle.

 Tuft & NeedleCasper
Foam Layers3" high-performance polyfoam, 7" support foam1.5" latex foam, 1.5" memory foam, 7" support foam
CoverAll white, simple, soft and stretchy2-tone, white and grey, soft and stretchy
Firmness7 out of 106 out of 10
SupportVery goodVery good
Motion TransferVery minimalVery minimal
Warranty10 Years10 Years
Trial Period100 Days100 Days
ShippingFree, 1-5 daysFree, 1-5 days
ReturnsThey will pick up / disposeThey will pick up / dispose

So, should you buy a Casper or Tuft & Needle?

Both Casper and Tuft & Needle have

  • A similar cover (functionally speaking)
  • Similar motion transfer
  • Similar support
  • Similar 10 year warranty
  • Similar shipping
  • The same trial period
  • Similar return / refund policy

The mattress that’s right for you ultimately hinges on your sleep preferences and priorities. The biggest differentiating factors between Casper and Tuft & Needle are the ones that will likely determine which mattress is the better choice for you. I have listed those critical decision points below.

You should buy the Casper mattress if:

  • You prefer a medium firmness – Casper has a 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale (where 10 is the most firm). This places is more towards neutral firmness and gives it a very balanced feel. Something similar to what you’d find in a nice hotel mattress.
  • You prefer a mattress that hugs you – Casper’s softer feel gives it a more pronounced hug and sinkage. This allows the mattress to better contour to your body to provide support, softness, and a nice feel.

Click here to Shop for the Casper.

You should buy the Tuft & Needle mattress if:

  • You prefer a slightly firm firmness – Tuft & Needle has a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale (where 10 is the most firm). This gives it a slightly firm feel and is noticeably firmer than the Casper.
  • You prefer very little hug – the Tuft & Needle mattress has very little hug and sinkage. The T&N has been designed to allow the sleeper to sleep more on top of the foams as opposed to sinking into the mattress and having the mattress more deeply contour to your shape.

Click here to Shop for the Tuft & Needle.

Share This

Join the Club!

Join club Sleepopolis for exclusive giveaways, important updates, and more fun stuff.

You have Successfully Subscribed!