It’s time for another mattress battle…this time with two of the titans of the online mattress industry squaring off. In one corner we have the ultra-popular Casper with its cool marketing, sleek design, and head turning price. In the other corner we have Loom and Leaf, spiritual child of established online mattress company Saatva, the L&L is packed with high-end materials, a traditional look, and a feel and build quality that is every bit as good as Tempur-pedic.
But there can only be one who will take home mattress glory…continue reading to find out who’s the victor between Loom and Leaf and Casper mattress!
In a bit of a hurry? Click here to skip to the review summary for the quick version.
Loom and Leaf Mattress Review
The Loom and Leaf mattress is a 12″ luxury foam mattress. It’s been designed to provide exceptional cooling, deep compression support, and balanced comfort. Perhaps the greatest distinction between L&L and Casper is simply that it’s not compressed in a box. The Loom and Leaf ships via full service in-home delivery. This means they will set the mattress up on your frame, take your old mattress away (if needed; for an extra fee), and can deliver your foundation also.
Loom and Leaf is built from 4 different layers of foam. It has a total thickness of 12″, which gives it a slightly larger profile than many other online mattresses (this also improves the deep compression support, more on that in a bit though).
Top layer (comfort + cooling) – the top layer is 2.0″ of conforming gel foam. Gel beads in the foam help to absorb heat from the sleeping surface, improving the cooling of the mattress at large. The gel is swirled into the foam during the formation process, this helps to ensure the gel penetrates the entirety of the foam for even distribution.
The gel swirl foam is nice, but what really makes the top layer incredible is the lamented medical-grade spinal cooling pad. The cooling pad is affixed to the top of the gel foam layer. This is the same type of cooling pad that is used in burn wards and hospitals, as such it has to perform under the most critical of circumstances and adds an impressive level of cooling to the mattress.
Second layer (contour) – this layer is 2.5″ of visco-elastic memory foam. This is a 5 pound foam that makes up much of the core of the mattress. Visco-elastic memory foam is similar in many respects to latex foam. It provides great comfort, cooling, bounce, and responsiveness.
Third layer (transitional support) – this is a 2.0″ transitional support layer that helps the foundational foams work with the above foam layers. Additionally, it helps to provide improved deep compression support. This allows the mattress to offer a consistent level of support for both large and small sleepers.
Bottom layer (foundation) – this is a 5.5″ high-density support foam. It acts as the foundational base for the mattress, providing shape and a good base layer.
The cover of the Loom & Leaf mattress is made from 100% organic cotton. Cotton gives the cover a classic look and makes it highly breathable (which helps keep the mattress cooler). Quilted within the cover is a thin piece of foam (5/8″). This foam combined with the cotton cover gives the mattress a traditional soft feel. When you immediately lie on the mattress you’ll feel the initial softness of the quilted cover as the foams begin to engage.
In addition, the cover is woven using natural thistle. Thistle acts as a natural organic flame retardant, as opposed to a chemically treated flame retardant or fire sock. It’s a very nice extra that I haven’t seen in any other mattress I’ve reviewed.
Aesthetically, the Loom and Leaf has a luxurious look and feel. The cover is trimmed with gold thread along the perimeter, which gives it a high-end look.
Firmness, Feel, & Comfort
The Loom and Leaf mattress has a medium firmness (called the Loom & Leaf Relaxed Firm) at a 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale (where 10 is the most firm). If you prefer a firmer feel, the Loom & Leaf is also available in a firmer option (called the Loom & Leaf Firm), at an 8 out of 10 on the firmness scale. Loom and Leaf has a luxury look and feel on par with Tempur-pedic. From the foam materials used, aesthetic style touches, and manufacturing quality, the mattress has a solid build quality that is evident from the first lie.
Many online mattress companies try to create a universal feel; a mattress that has an ideal balance of comfort, support, and cooling suitable for the vast majority of sleepers. Of all the companies trying to hit this universal feel mark I think the Loom & Leaf is among the best 2-3 that really hit the nail on the head. The L&L allows the sleeper to sink 1-1.5″ into the mattress, providing a balanced level of hug without feeling so deep that it creates heat retention issues or makes the sleeper feel “stuck”. Additionally, all of the foams within the Loom and Leaf are highly responsive. This means they quickly change and adapt to changes in your movements. This also helps to ensure continual and consistent contouring support, while avoiding the “stuck” quick-sand like feeling.
The material construction of the Loom and Leaf is equally impressive..organic cotton, plant-based foams, natural thistle flame retardant, good memory foam poundage, spinal cooling gel, and 6.5″ of comfort foam. The Loom and Leaf has really gone above and beyond with their material selection. No corners are cut. They use the best materials and it delivers an exceptional mattress.
In terms of support the Loom and Leaf does a very good job. This especially extends to deep compression support. This is particularly important if you’re a heavier sleeper (really anything over 180 pounds). The L&L does a good job of maintaining consistent support even under heavier pressures. The thicker mattress profile helps to maintain this level of support even for heavier sleepers.
- Warranty – 15 years
- Shipping – 7-15 days, $99, delivered via full service in-home delivery (two men will come and setup the mattress in your home and take your old mattress away; extra fee to take your old mattress away), mattress is not compressed
- No Tax
- Trial Period – 120 days
- Refunds – 100% money back within the trial period, very easy to process if you decide you don’t like it
- Made in the USA
- Smell – very little smell, what little there is dissipates after a day
- Organic, Green, & Natural – made with plant-based foams, organic cotton cover, natural thistle as the flame retardant
Casper Mattress Review
The Casper is a 10″ all foam hybrid mattress. Hybrid mattresses use different layers of foam (or other materials) to achieve an optimal level of comfort, support, and cooling.
The Casper is built from 3 different layers of foam.
Top layer (comfort) – the top layer is 1.5″ of latex foam. Latex foam is designed to offer great comfort, bounce, and cooling. Latex is one of the most established and widely used materials in many modern mattresses today. Casper uses a Dunlop latex, which is among the most durable of the latex family.
Middle layer (support ) – the middle layer is 1.5″ of memory foam. Memory foam provides support and pressure relief for the mattress. It’s placement below the latex foam helps to eliminate any potential heat retention issues.
Bottom layer (foundation) – the bottom layer of the Casper is 6.5″ of high-density support foam. This is a basic foam that acts as a foundational base for the mattress.
The Casper is a classic hybrid designed foam mattress. Hybrid mattresses utilize different layers of foam (or other materials) to maximize certain benefits, while minimizing other negative attributes. In Casper’s case they have chosen to layer latex on top of memory foam. Keeping the latex layer on top ensures the sleeping surface stays cool, has a nice bounce, and a good general comfortableness.
Additionally, by placing the memory foam in the middle of the mattress the Casper is able to have good support and pressure relief, but also reduce any heat retention issues that could otherwise arise from the memory foam (memory foams have a tendency to sleep hotter than other foams).
Casper’s cover is a two-toned design. The white piece of fabric on top is imported from Belgium. It has a soft feel, good stretch, and is quite porous (note the knit in the image below). The porousness helps the cover and mattress breath better, by allowing for easier airflow.
Be very careful when moving the Casper though. While the white fabric on top is great for cooling, it’s not great for durability. Last time I was moving the mattress my Casper’s cover got caught on a small obstruction and pulled several threads out. The grey piece of fabric that runs along the permitted is much sturdier though, which does help to reinforce the edges against possible damage there.
Aesthetically, the Casper has a modern look to it. The two-tone grey and white design gives it a nice contrast that looks sharp in any room.
Firmness, Feel, & Comfort
Casper strikes a medium firmness at a 6-7 out of 10 on the firmness scale (where 10 is the most firm). I give Casper a bit of a firmness range due to anecdotal evidence I’ve received from many of my readers. Lighter sleepers (less than 180 pounds) seem to experience the Casper in a slightly softer feel, at a 6 out of 10. This is in contrast to heavier sleepers (180 pounds or more), which experience a firmer feel, closer to that 7 out of 10. I believe this is due to the Casper’s 3″ of comfort foam. Heavier sleepers put increased pressure on these foams, which allow the sleeper to sink into the deeper layers of the mattress, which have a firmer feel.
With regards to overall support, I think the Casper does a pretty good job. For sleepers that are an average weight, you’re perfect. However, for heavier sleepers the deep compression support is a bit lacking. This is simply due to sinking deeper into the foams, beyond the more comfortable and supportive layers.
Casper does a good job keeping the mattress cool. The hybrid design with the latex layer on top and an extra porous fabric atop the cover helps to maintain a cooler sleeping surface.
When lying on the Casper in a normal sleeping position you’ll experience 1-1.5″ of sinkage. Despite the fairly balanced depth of sinkage, the hug feels more pronounced. The top latex layer is quite soft, which allows the mattress to substantially hug and envelope the sleeper. It’s still quite responsive, so I wouldn’t say this envelopment causes me to feel “stuck”. It’s an interesting phenomenon. The top layer of latex is quite soft, which allows the deeper hug, while at the same time providing slightly less in terms of body contour. IE, you sink into the layers, but they don’t as sharply contour like 100% memory foam would.
- Warranty – 10 years
- Shipping – free, 1-5 days, comes compressed in a box
- No Tax
- Trial Period – 100 days
- Refunds – 100% money back guarantee within the trial period, very easy to process a refund
- Made in the USA – mostly sourced from the US also, some of the fabrics come from Belgium
- Smell – strong smell for about a week
The following is a comprehensive comparison of the major features, construction specs, service, and other attributes of the Loom and Leaf vs. Casper mattresses.
|Casper||Loom & Leaf|
|Foam Layers||1.5" latex foam, 1.5" memory foam, 7" support foam||Spinal cooling gel, 2" gel foam, 2.5" visco-elastic memory foam, 2" transition loft pad, 5.5" support foam|
|Cover||Soft, decent thickness, good stretch||100% organic cotton, quilted, thin foam layer for softness|
|Firmness||6-7 out of 10||6 or 8 out of 10 (2 firmness options available)|
|Motion Transfer||Very minimal||Very minimal|
|Price - Queen||$850||$1,099|
|Price - King||$950||$1,399|
|Warranty||10 years||15 years|
|Trial Period||100 days||75 days|
|Shipping||Free, 1-5 days, compressed in a box||$99, 7-15 days, white glove delivery service, not compressed|
|Refunds & Returns||Yes||Yes|
Should you buy a Loom and Leaf or a Casper mattress?
Both Casper and Loom and Leaf have their pros and cons. However, after several months of sleeping on both of these mattresses I feel like the Loom and Leaf is simply a better mattress.
I would recommend the Loom & Leaf mattress to anyone who falls into the following categories:
- You want a medium or hard firmness mattress – the Loom & Leaf is available in two firmness levels, their Luxury Firm, which is a 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale (where 10 is the most firm) and their Firm, which is an 8 out of 10 on the firmness scale. The medium Luxury Firm mattress offers a wonderful balance of comfort and support, while the hard Firm mattress offers much stronger push-back and stiff support. If you aren’t sure what level of firmness you need I recommend going with the medium. The vast majority of sleepers want and need something in the 5-7 out of 10 range.
- You want a balanced hug and feel – the Loom and Leaf has a moderate level of sinkage and hug. It’s not so deep that you feel stuck and enveloped, and it’s not so light that you feel excessive push-back.
- You want good body contouring – the Loom and Leaf does a good job of providing full body contouring for the sleeper while still remaining highly responsive (IE, the foams quickly change as you move and change positions).
- You want exceptional cooling – L&L combines breathable organic cotton, gel infused foams, open cell foam structure, and a spinal cooling gel to deliver some of the best cooling I’ve experienced in any mattress (I’ve only tested one mattress that performed slightly better).
- You want natural materials – Loom and Leaf uses natural thistle as the flame retardant (as opposed to a traditional fire sock or chemical FR treatment), organic cotton in the cover, and plant-based foams. Granted, it’s not 100% natural from top to bottom, but Loom and Leaf has taken some very sizable steps towards creating a more healthy and hygienic mattress.
All things considered, I feel that Loom and Leaf has really knocked this one out of the park. You spend a little more money, but you get an impressive mattress.
For more information on the Loom and Leaf visit LoomandLeaf.com.
If for whatever reason you think the Loom and Leaf isn’t right for you or it’s out of your budget range the Casper can still be a good mattress. I really love the Loom and Leaf, but I don’t want to discredit the Casper. By all accounts, the Casper is still a very good mattress and can meet the needs of many sleepers.
I would recommend the Casper to anyone who falls into the following categories:
- You want a medium firmness – the Casper’s firmness ranges from 6-7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. If you’re a smaller person, it’ll be slightly softer. If you’re heavier, you’ll experience a slightly firmer feel.
- You want a mattress with a pronounced hug – the soft top layer of the latex in the Casper provides a more pronounced hug. The body contour is not as sharp as you would get with a 100% memory foam mattress, but the overall sinkage / hug is more dramatic.
- You want a less expensive option – the Casper is a bit cheaper than the Loom and Leaf. The price difference for the Twin is $149. The price difference for the Queen is $149. The price difference for the King is $249. Additionally, you can save another $99 on shipping with the Casper (which has free shipping).
For more information on the Casper visit Casper on Amazon.