Deciding between the Casper and Puffy mattresses is a tricky task. They’re both bed-in-a-box models that provide a satisfying balance between pressure relief and support. They also happen to top a lot of “Best Of” lists, marking them as popular options for all different sorts of sleepers. But thankfully, figuring out which one is right for you is actually a lot simpler than you might think.
To help you get the clarity you deserve, I decided to create a Casper vs. Puffy comparison, which you can read in full below. We’ll go over the beds’ similarities, chat about their unique constructions, and round things out with my expert recommendations for who might like them most.
So, without further ado, let’s get into my Casper vs. Puffy comparison.
Before we discuss all the things that set these beds apart, let’s start with some of the characteristics they share. Below, I’m going to detail a few of these important similarities so that we can better contextualize their differences throughout the comparison.
All-Foam: One of the most obvious similarities between the Casper and Puffy mattresses we’re looking at today is that they’re both built entirely of foam. It’s worth noting, though, that they use foam materials in very different ways (but more on that later!)
Medium Firm Feel: I’d also say that both of these mattresses have a solid, medium firm feel, which should endear them to a wide range of sleepers and sleeping styles.
Back Sleepers: And when it comes to specific recommendations, I find that both the Casper and Puffy mattresses are good for back sleepers. We’ll explore this in full later on, but it is something that I wanted to shout out here.
What Are These Mattresses Made Of?
Now that we’ve got the similarities all well and sorted, it’s time to dive underneath the covers and see what these beds are made of! I’ll go over each bed’s unique construction below, but would also encourage you to check out my full of the Casper review or Puffy review for even more details.
Cover – Made from a knit polyester blend, the Casper cover is soft and cozy to the touch.
Comfort – The comfort layer is made of the brand’s special Airscape™ foam, which is gentle, bouncy, and cooling. It’s also quite breathable, thanks to the small perforations along its surface. This layer is intended to lift the sleeper up, thereby positioning them more “on top” of the bed than “in” it.
Contour – Next up, you’ll land on a layer of memory foam that’s been zoned for support. Traditional memory foam has a slow response to pressure, allowing the sleeper to sink in for deep pressure relief at the shoulders and hips. Casper’s memory foam has that same feel, but has been modified slightly with the zoned design, wherein there’s softer foam at the shoulders for a little give and firmer foam at the hips for a little lift.
Base – And finally the base, comprised here of high-density poly foam. This section gives the bed its stability and shape.
Cover – As we saw in the Casper, the Puffy cover is made of a polyester blend that’s soft and cozy to the touch.
Comfort – The Puffy mattress kicks things off with the brand’s Cooling Cloud™ foam, which has a very similar feel to memory foam. This means it’s got a slow response to pressure that encourages deep body-contouring and sinkage. Where the comfort layer in the Casper is designed to position the sleeper more “on top” of the bed, the memory foam here is meant to hug the sleeper. And while this tendency of memory foam’s can sometimes produce a bit of overheating at night, Puffy has mitigated this issue with a cooling gel infusion.
Transition – Beneath the memory foam layer, you’ll spy a transitional section of poly foam. This material has a quicker response to pressure than the memory foam above it, working to ease the sleeper into the firmer base below.
Base – As in the Casper, the base layer of the Puffy mattress is made up of high-density poly foam, which brings some nice stability to the overall structure.
Casper vs. Puffy
After taking a peek underneath the covers, I’d like to talk about some of the most important distinctions between these two beds.
In any mattress, the comfort layer is going to set the tone for the bed’s overall feel. In the Casper, the top layer of Airscape™ foam establishes a buoyant vibe in which the sleeper is likely to feel positioned more on top of the bed than in it. In the Puffy, the top layer of Cooling Cloud™ foam does the opposite; instead of lifting the sleeper up, it wraps them in a deep, cuddly embrace. Therefore, I think the Casper would probably work better for combo sleepers or folks who need to move around and change positions in the night. The Puffy, on the other hand, might be best for side sleepers or those in need of intense pressure relief at the shoulders, hips, or lower back.
Another design element that stuck out to me was the internal layer of zoned support in the Casper mattress. This section provides targeted relief to different parts of the body, which creates an overall more “balanced” vibe than we saw in the Puffy. If you struggle with aches pains, like sciatica pain, you may want to consider checking out the Casper mattress.
To continue this conversation, let’s take a closer look at exactly how these beds feel!
What Do These Mattresses Feel Like?
While knowing the material make-up of a mattress is all well and good, it’s important to also figure out how those materials make the bed feel. So, in this section, I’m going to do just that by focusing on feel factors like firmness, pressure relief, sinkage, and bounce.
It’s important to note, of course, that all feel factors are inherently subjective, and can change a lot depending on one’s body size, shape, and weight. Therefore, my reads of the Casper and Puffy mattresses may very well differ from your own. For reference, I’m 5’10”, 190lbs., and prefer to sleep on my stomach.
The Casper mattress gets a 7/10 on firmness scale from me. When compared to the industry standard of 6.5 for medium firmness, it seems this bed is just a touch above medium firm.
I decided to give the bed a 7/10 because of its balanced foam feel. Since the mattress employs so many different types of foam, no one material dominates the vibe — you get both lift and give, both pressure relief and support. For this reason, I think the Casper could be a great fit for a wide range of sleepers, but particularly those who struggle with back pain. I think the Casper does a great job of setting the spine in an even line from the shoulders to the hips, so could work wonders for those with achy joints.
As I mentioned up top, the Puffy is also medium firm, but perhaps just a smidge softer than the Casper. For that reason, I give it a 6.5/10 on the firmness scale.
The Puffy is slightly softer than the Casper because of its top layer of memory foam, which, again, produces some lovely body-contouring and sinkage. However, I think it’s worth acknowledging that the transitional layer of poly foam does a lot to curb this sinkage, which is why I scored the Puffy as medium firm as opposed to soft. Back and side sleepers could benefit from this feel as it provides both ample pressure relief and support.
Now that we’ve gone over the specifics of the original Casper and Puffy mattresses, it’s time to turn our attention to a few of the other models these brands sell. Below, I’ll give you a brief overview of these mattresses to color and contextualize our Casper vs. Puffy comparison!
In addition to the all-foam Casper we’ve been exploring in this comparison, the brand also sells a variety of different hybrid mattress models. A hybrid mattress is one that combines foam layers with either coils or springs, so tends to be bouncier, firmer, and more supportive than beds made entirely of foam. The three beds we’ll dissect here are the Casper Hybrid, Casper Nova Hybrid, and Casper Wave Hybrid.
- Casper Hybrid: The Casper Hybrid is exactly like the all-foam Casper, except it has a base layer of pocketed coils instead of high-density poly foam. This makes for a bouncier structure that could work well for combo and back sleepers.
- Casper Nova Hybrid: I’d say the Casper Nova Hybrid is probably the softest bed in the Casper line. It also happens to sleep a bit cooler than the other models, so could be a fantastic option for hot sleepers.
- Casper Wave Hybrid: Casper calls the Casper Wave Hybrid its most luxurious bed, and I agree! It’s got multiple layers of zoned support as well as plush foams for body-contouring and pressure relief. I think this bed could be well-suited to a wide range of sleepers, but particularly heavier folks or those after a true luxury vibe.
- The Puffy Lux is a super soft option for folks who want an ultra-cuddly sleeping experience.
- While many people may enjoy the deep contouring of this mattress, I think it would probably be best-suited for side sleepers or anyone else who struggles with aches and pains in the night.
- The Lux is also quite breathable, so could be a great cooling option for those who overheat while they sleep.
- For more on this bed, take a peek at my full Puffy Lux mattress review.
- The Puffy Royal is a luxury mattress that features a dynamic, 5-layer construction of memory foam, poly foam, and high-density poly foam.
- As opposed to the Original Puffy and the Lux, the Royal has more of a medium firm feel, so could endear itself to back and side sleepers.
- If you like the idea of an all-foam mattress, but don’t want to feel stuck in the bed, this could be a solid option for you.
- Get all the details you need at my full Puffy Royal mattress review.
Which is Better: Casper vs Puffy
Well y’all, we’ve almost made it to the end of this comparison! After digging into these beds’ constructions and comparing their feels, it’s time to wrap things up with a few final observations and recommendations.
First and foremost, if you’re a sleeper in need of major support at the lower back, I’d suggest going with the Casper mattress. Not only does this bed have a pleasantly balanced feel, but it’s also got an internal layer of zoned support to help set the spine in a neutral line all the way from the shoulders to the hips. This could be satisfying for all sorts of sleepers, but especially those who struggle with back pain at night. The Casper is also bouncier than the Puffy, so could be a nice fit for combo sleepers.
When it comes to the Puffy mattress, I think it’s probably best-suited for side sleepers or those who deal with joint pain. Though both the Casper and Puffy feature memory foam in their constructions, I would only really describe the Puffy as a memory foam mattress, meaning it’s plush, pressure-relieving, and designed to leave you feeling more “in” the bed than “on top” of it. If you’re looking for a cuddly hug from your mattress while you sleep, the Puffy could very well be the one for you!
To get even more specific about my recommendations, I’m going to wrap things up with some of my favorite aspects of each mattress.
- I think the Casper mattress could be a great fit for those who struggle with back pain. Not only does it have a cozy, balanced feel, but its interior layer of zoned support helps to lift and set the spine in a healthy, neutral alignment.
- The balanced foam feel of the mattress should also endear it to a wider range of sleepers than the Puffy would. So, if you’re someone who hasn’t exactly figured out how you sleep, you’ll likely enjoy the Casper.
The memory foam, latex, and heavy-duty poly foam work together to offer sleepers a beautifully balanced feel!
- If you want a cozy memory foam feel, you can’t go wrong with the Puffy. This mattress embodies all the awesome aspects of the material, namely its sinkage, pressure relief, and body-contouring.
- In fact, anyone who struggles with joint pain at the shoulders and hips could find a lot to love in the deep pressure relief of this bed.
The Puffy is an all-foam mattress that lives up to its name with soft, pressure relieving comfort!
- Trial Period – 100 Nights
- Shipping – Free
- Warranty – 10 Year
- Trial Period – 101 Nights
- Shipping – Free
- Warranty – Lifetime
Puffy and Casper Mattress Sizes And Prices