The original Nectar and original Casper mattresses are two of the most popular bed-in-a-box options on the market today. And while they’re both considered to be high-quality products built with serious Zzz’s in mind, they’re actually pretty dissimilar. So, which one is right for you? Well, I’m so glad you asked!
In this comparison, I’m going to analyze all the major similarities and differences between the original Nectar and Casper mattresses. From their unique builds to their distinct feels, we’re going to cover every last thing so you can figure out which of these beds was tailor-made for you.
Short on time? Then you can hop to my summary at the end of this page.
Nectar vs Casper: Which is Better for You?
Who Should Buy Casper
- Back sleepers who prefer a more “on top of the bed” feel might like the Casper mattress.
- Combination sleepers might enjoy the Casper’s responsive feel, which should make it easy to change positions at night.
- If you struggle with back pain the Casper is the best choice for you. Its zoned support system should help you keep your spine straight at night, which can help prevent or relieve back pain.
Who Should Buy Nectar
- Side sleepers should like the Nectar, it’s one of the best memory foam mattresses on the market right now and will offer plenty of relief around sensitive pressure points.
- Couples should opt for the Nectar. It does a great job isolating motion transfer, which means you won’t feel disturbed by a restless bedmate on this mattress.
- Back sleepers who prefer a “hug-like” feel might enjoy the Nectar mattress.
Nectar vs Casper: Similarities and Differences
Next, I want to describe the most important similarities and differences between these two beds.
- The Nectar and Casper are both foam bed-in-a-box mattresses. While these beds use foam in different ways, both are going to feel much gentler than a hybrid mattress or innerspring mattress.
- Both mattresses are great options for anyone looking for a mattress for shoulder pain. They both offer great pressure relief in the shoulder area.
- These beds fall into a similar price range, and both are fairly affordable.
- Neither bed will offer quite enough support for heavy sleepers (over 250 lbs). I’d recommend these folks check out one of our best mattresses for heavy people instead.
- The Nectar mattress uses more memory foam than the Casper mattress, so it’s ideal for sleepers looking for a slow-moving bed that offers plenty of sinkage.
- The Casper offers zoned support, which means it’s firmer at the hips and softer at the shoulders. This is ideal for sleepers who struggle with back pain.
- The Casper might sleep a little cooler than the Nectar because it’s made with less memory foam.
Nectar and Casper Mattress Feel Comparison
In this section, I’m going to do my best to give you a sense of how these beds feel. To do this, I’m going to focus on factors like firmness, pressure relief, bounce, and sinkage.
But before we get into that, a small note to say that all of these feel factors are inherently subjective and could change depending on one’s body size, shape, and weight. Therefore, my read of these beds could very well differ from your own! For reference, I’m 5’10”, weigh around 190 lbs, and prefer to sleep on my stomach.
I gave the Nectar’s initial feel a 7 out of 10 firmness scale (where 1 is super soft and 10 is ultra-firm). This marks it as just above the industry standard of 6.5 for medium firmness. However, like most traditional memory foam mattresses, the Nectar gets softer the longer you lie on it. Over time, its foams will start to conform to your body and give this bed more of a medium-soft to medium-firm feel.
Once you sink into your Nectar it should have a plush, pressure-relieving feel. While this could be great for side or back sleepers who struggle with joint pain, it’s not likely to work for strict stomach sleepers. These folks typically prefer a firmer structure that helps them achieve a neutral spinal alignment. In general, I’d recommend the Nectar to any memory foam lovers looking for a cushioning feel.
I also gave the Casper a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. However, unlike the Nectar, this bed does not soften up as you lie on it. So I’d call the Casper a firm mattress. The Casper has more of a “balanced” feel than the Nectar. You should feel much more “on top of” than “stuck in” this bed.
I’d recommend this feel to combination sleepers and back sleepers. Combo sleepers should find it easy to move around and change positions on this bed. And back sleepers should like the balance of pressure relief and support the Casper offers. Strict side sleepers, however, may find that the bed doesn’t provide the deep pressure relief they need at the shoulders and hips.
Comparing What it’s Like to Sleep on the Nectar and the Casper
To give you an even better idea of what these beds feel like, I tested them in all of the main sleeping positions. Take a look below to see how they felt.
Back — The Nectar felt really comfortable on my back. I could feel its foams contouring to my lower back and providing some nice pressure relief.
Side — Initially I thought the Nectar would feel too firm on my side. But after lying on it for a few minutes, I sunk into its top foams and felt some great pressure relief. I think this bed is a great fit for side sleepers.
Stomach — The Nectar felt too soft on my stomach, I could feel my hips sinking into the bed and creating a bend in my back. In my opinion, neither the Casper or the Nectar is supportive enough for strict stomach sleepers. I’d advise these folks to check out our best mattresses for stomach sleepers to find a better fit.
Body Weight — This bed will likely feel firmer the lighter you are and softer the heavier you are. In general, I’d steer heavier people (above 250 lbs) towards a firmer mattress that offers coil support. One of our best innerspring mattresses might do the trick.
Back — The Casper’s zoned support system really shone when I was on my back. I could feel my hips being lifted up and out of the bed, providing plenty of support in my lumbar region.
Side — I found the Casper a bit too firm when I was on my side. But if you alternate between your side and another position at night, I think this bed could work for you. It definitely offered a bit of pressure relief in the shoulder area.
Stomach — Like the Nectar, the Casper is a bit too soft for strict stomach sleepers. But lighter combination sleepers who only spend part of the night on their stomachs might like this bed.
Body Weight — The Casper will likely feel firmer to lighter people and softer to heavier people. Personally, I’d recommend this bed mainly for average-weight sleepers. Lighter people might prefer a softer feel, and heavier sleepers likely need more support.
Comparing Nectar and Casper Prices
Of course, your decision might come down to the price difference between these two beds. For a full pricing comparison, check out the table below. And be sure to check out our Casper mattress coupon or the Nectar mattress coupon page to get a deal on the new mattress of your choice.
Prices listed are before discount or offer for each size.
Comparing Nectar and Casper Mattress Materials
Next, let’s take a peek under the covers of these all-foam beds to see what they’re made of. I’ll be giving a brief rundown of each bed’s construction below,
Cover — The Nectar’s Tencel cover is quilted with a bit of memory foam that does a great job conforming to your curves and offering initial pressure relief. This cooling cover also helps encourage airflow throughout the mattress. The bottom of the Nectar is made with grip fabric to ensure it doesn’t slip or slide on your bed frame.
Comfort Layer — Beneath the quilted cover, you’ll land on a layer of gel-infused memory foam. This cooling gel memory foam has a slow response to pressure, so you’re likely to sink into it for deep pressure relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back.
Transition Layer — Next up is an adaptive transition layer that is a little more responsive than the memory foam layer above it. This layer should prevent you from feeling swallowed by your bed.
Base Layer — And finally, we land on a layer of high-density poly foam. This dense material provides the bed with its stability and shape.
Cover — The Casper’s cover is made from a knit polyester blend, so it has a soft and cozy feel.
Comfort Layer — Beneath the cover, you’ll find a layer of AirScape foam. This is an open-cell foam with a pretty similar feel to latex foam in that it’s bouncy, responsive, and naturally cooling. The Casper Original’s comfort layer is very different from the Nectar’s, as it works to position the sleeper more “on top” of the bed than “in” it.
Contour Layer — Next up is a zoned layer of memory foam. This layer makes space for sleepers to sink in for extra relief at the shoulders, but provides extra support at the hips.
Base Layer — Last up is a base layer made of the same high-density poly foam we saw in the Nectar. It provides overall support and durability to this bed.
Well folks, we’re almost done! After going over these beds’ unique constructions and feels, it’s time to make the final comparisons and figure out which one is right for you. Take a look below to see what I like best about each of these online mattresses.
Nectar Best Features
- If you’re a fan of memory foam, you’re bound to love the Nectar mattress. All its top layers are built with plenty of this pressure-relieving material.
- Strict side sleepers could find a lot to love in the Nectar mattress. As they press into the structure, they’re likely to experience plenty of deep pressure relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back.
- Couples might appreciate the great motion isolation the Nectar offers. You’re unlikely to feel disturbed by a restless partner on this bed.
Sleepers will sink deep into the Nectar mattress for some soothing pressure relief, something that side sleepers will particularly appreciate! Click here to get $399 of free accessories with every mattress purchase!
Casper Best Features
- The Casper could be a great fit for those who struggle with back pain thanks to its zoned support layer, which helps to set the spine in a neutral line.
- Combination sleepers should enjoy the responsiveness of the Capser mattress, which makes it easy to move around and change positions at night.
- Hot sleepers should appreciate that the Casper sleeps cool for a foam mattress.
The memory foam, latex, and heavy-duty poly foam work together to offer sleepers a beautifully balanced feel!
Comparing Company Policies
- Sleep Trial Period — 365 Nights
- Shipping — Free
- Warranty — Lifetime
- Sleep Trial Period — 100 Nights
- Shipping — Free
- Warranty — 10 Years
Comparing Nectar and Casper Customer Service
I’ve also rated each company’s customer service team based on my personal experiences with each. Possible ratings include Poor, Satisfactory, Great, and Stellar.
Nectar Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating
Stellar: I was immediately paired with a thoughtful agent, and he even offered to get on the phone with me to help place my order.
Casper Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating
Stellar: I was immediately paired with a helpful agent who answered all my questions about Casper’s warranty thoroughly and transparently.
Comparing Other Models from Nectar and Casper
Though we’ve been focusing exclusively on the original Nectar and Casper mattresses, they aren’t the only beds these brands sell. So, to contextualize our comparison a little bit more, let’s take a peek at some of Nectar and Casper’s other models.
- The Nectar Premier is a super soft memory foam mattress ideal for anyone who likes a plush feel.
- I would recommend the Premier for strict side sleepers looking for lots of pressure relief. It has thicker layers of memory foam than the original Nectar, so it offers even more cushion.
- The Nectar Premier sleeps cooler than the original Nectar thanks to Phase Change Material in its top layer.
- For more on this bed, check out my full Nectar Premier mattress review.
Nectar Premier Copper
- The Premier Copper is a medium-firm memory foam mattress that feels just a little gentler than the original Nectar.
- The Premier Copper is the most cooling Nectar mattress available.
- The Nectar Premier Copper is more expensive than the original Nectar.
- Learn more in the full Nectar Premier Copper mattress review.
- The Casper Hybrid is exactly like the original Casper, but it uses a pocketed coil support system instead of a high-density foam base.
- Combination sleepers might like the bouncy feel of this hybrid bed.
- The Casper Hybrid is more expensive than the original Casper mattress.
- Learn more in the full Casper Hybrid mattress review.
Casper Nova Hybrid
- The Nova is a soft hybrid mattress.
- This Casper bed sleeps cooler than the original Casper mattress.
- Like the original Casper, the Nova features zoned support.
- Find out more in the full Casper Nova Hybrid mattress review.
Casper Wave Hybrid
- This is Casper’s luxury hybrid option, so it’s more expensive than the other Caspers.
- The Wave Hybrid is a great option for heavy people who struggle with joint pain.
- Combination sleepers should enjoy this hybrid’s responsive feel.
- Interested? Head over to the Casper Wave Hybrid mattress review.
Other Common Nectar and Casper Comparisons
Still not sure which of these beds to choose? Take a look at a few other common comparisons before you decide!
- Nectar vs DreamCloud
- Nectar vs Tuft & Needle
- Nectar vs Purple
- Nectar vs Leesa
- Nectar vs Layla
- Nectar vs GhostBed
- Casper vs Helix
- Casper vs Leesa
- Casper vs WinkBeds
- Casper vs Purple
- Casper vs DreamCloud
- Casper vs Endy
- Casper vs Lull
- Casper vs Puffy
- Casper vs Layla
- Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding
- Casper vs Saatva
- Casper vs GhostBed