We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

Puffy vs Nectar Mattress Comparison

Puffy and Nectar are both memory foam mattresses that utilize the plush material for deep contouring relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back. But though these bed-in-a-box models use similar materials, their feels are entirely unique. So, which one is right for you? Well, I’m so glad you asked!

In this guide, we’re going to go over every inch of these mattresses so that you can answer that very question. We’ll dig into their similarities, discuss their differences, and wrap things up with a few expert pros and cons for each model. If you want to learn more about each of these beds you can check out my full Puffy mattress review and Nectar mattress review.

Sound like a plan? Then let’s dive on into my full Puffy vs. Nectar mattress comparison! If you’re short on time you can skip down to my review summary.

$399 in Free Gifts
Nectar

Holiday Savings Alert! Below is our exclusive Sleepopolis discount, which will usually get you the best deal on your new mattress. However, with this sale, you can save even more!

$440 of free accessories!
Puffy
  • Nice for side sleepers
  • Memory foam feel

Puffy vs Nectar: Similarities and Differences

Though both the Puffy and Nectar are memory foam mattresses, that doesn’t mean they’re built the same. In fact, they actually have pretty distinct construction profiles. So, let’s discuss a few of my biggest takeaways.

Main Similarities

  • Both mattresses have all-foam constructions and have layers of memory foam to provide some contouring and sinkage.
  • Both the Nectar and the Puffy come at similar and affordable price points
  • Though both mattresses have cooling features to help mitigate the heat trapping tendencies of memory foam, I wouldn’t say either one sleeps especially cool.
  • These mattresses don’t have the best edge support. If you’re looking for a bed with strong edge support I’d recommend a hybrid mattress or innerspring mattress

Main Differences

  • The Puffy is softer than the Nectar, though the Nectar provides a bit more sinkage. The Nectar has more memory foam than the Puffy so you’ll have a more classic memory foam contouring feel.
  • The Puffy has a more supportive feel and is a bit more responsive than the Nectar.
  • The Nectar absorbs motion better than the Puffy, which means you’ll feel less movement from one side of the bed on the other. 

Which is Better for You?

Depending on your height, body weight, and preferred sleeping position, one of these mattresses is likely to be best for you. Take a look at some of my recommendations below.

  • I think strict side sleepers and those who suffer from shoulder pain would be happier on the Nectar.
  • I think the Puffy would probably work best for back sleepers who want a bit of sink, but don’t want to feel totally enveloped by their mattress.
  • The Nectar is probably better for couples since it has great motion isolation, meaning you’re unlikely to be disturbed by your partner’s movements. 
  • I think combination sleepers would be happier on the Puffy, which has a more “on top” of the bed feel that should make switching positions easy.
  • I wouldn’t recommend either of these beds to heavier sleepers (those over 250 lbs). Instead I’d steer them to our best mattress for heavy people roundup.
  • I don’t think the Nectar or the Puffy is firm enough for stomach sleepers. I’d tell them to look at some of our best mattresses for stomach sleepers.

Puffy and Nectar Mattress Feel Comparison

Now that we’ve discussed some of the basics about each of these beds, let’s get into the good stuff — how these mattresses feel! Below, I’m going to do my best to paint a snapshot of each bed’s unique vibe by considering factors like firmness, pressure relief, motion transfer, sinkage, and more.

But before we do that, a small note to say that all feel factors are subjective and can change a lot depending on one’s body size, shape, and weight. Therefore, my reads of these mattresses could very well differ from your own. For reference, I’m 5’13”, weight 110 lbs., and prefer to sleep on my side.

Puffy

As I mentioned in its construction section, the Puffy is a medium firm mattress that I’d rank at a 6.5/10 on the firmness scale with 1 being the softest mattress in the world and 10 being the firmest. When compared to the industry standard of 6.5 for medium firmness, it seems this bed is right between soft and firm.

Though it’s true that memory foam is a soft material, not all memory foam mattresses are super gentle. The Puffy, for example, bolsters its memory foam top layer with sections of firm poly foam and high-density poly foam. These materials work to curb some of the memory foam’s natural sinkage and body-contouring, producing a feel that’s more medium firm than soft. I think both back and side sleepers could benefit from this vibe as it provides ample pressure relief and support.

Nectar

In contrast to the Puffy, I’d put the Nectar on the slightly firmer side of things at a 7/10 on the firmness scale. However, I’d like to note that since I’m a lighter sleeper, I experienced this bed as a bit firmer than a larger sleeper would, since they’re likely to sink into the Nectar’s memory foam more deeply.

Why the difference? Well, the Nectar features five inches of plush memory foam in its construction, which produces a soft feel. While everyone interacts with memory foam differently (some sink straight through the material while others take a bit longer to do so), almost all sleepers will experience the material as quite gentle. For that reason, most folks will feel more “in” the Nectar than “on top” of it. In my opinion, this sinky vibe could work especially well for strict side sleepers or anyone who struggles with joint pain. Stomach and combo sleepers, however, may find the bed just a touch too soft for their needs.

$399 in Free Gifts
Nectar

Holiday Savings Alert! Below is our exclusive Sleepopolis discount, which will usually get you the best deal on your new mattress. However, with this sale, you can save even more!

$440 of free accessories!
Puffy
  • Nice for side sleepers
  • Memory foam feel

Comparing Puffy and Nectar Prices

When choosing between the Puffy and Nectar mattresses, your decision might just come down to price. So, let’s take a gander at how much these two beds cost side-by-side in our pricing chart. And if you do decide to buy a new mattress, remember that you can always use our special Puffy coupon  and Nectar coupon codes to save big on your purchase!

Prices listed will be before discount or offer for each size.

PuffyNectar
Twin$795$798
Twin XL$825$868
Full$995$1,098
Queen$1,150$1,198
King$1,350$1,498
California King$1,350$1,498

Comparing Puffy and Nectar Mattress Materials

Now let’s figure out what’s inside each of these beds. Though they are both all-foam mattresses and have memory foam layers, their overall constructions are different. Below, I’m going to walk you through their distinct constructions.

Puffy

Cover – The Puffy mattress cover is made of a polyester blend that’s soft and cozy to the touch and is stain-resistant.

Comfort Layer – Beneath the cover, you’ll land on a layer of the brand’s Cooling Cloud™ memory foam, which has a slow response to pressure for contouring relief at pressure points at the shoulders, hips, and lower back. This material is designed to cradle the sleeper as they press into the structure, so could be a good fit for folks who deal with joint pain. And while memory foam has a slight reputation for overheating at night, Puffy tries to mitigate this issue by infusing its foam with a cooling gel.

Puffy
The Puffy Mattress in the Sleepopolis studio.

Transition Layer – Next up, you’ll spy a thin layer of poly foam. This material has a quicker response to pressure than the memory foam above it, so helps to curb some of that layer’s sinkage and transition the sleeper into the firmer base below.

Base Layer- The base layer of the Puffy mattress is made up of high-density poly foam, a support foam which brings some stability to the overall structure.

Puffy 2019 Construction
The materials used in the layers of the Puffy Mattress

Nectar

Cover – The Nectar cover is made of Tencel, an eco-friendly material that’s breathable and cool.

Comfort Layer- As in the Puffy, the first layer here is one of gel memory foam. This material has a slow response to pressure, providing plenty of space for the sleeper to sink in for deep pressure relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back. And as we discussed above, the gel infusion helps to counteract memory foam’s tendency to absorb and trap body heat.

Nectar Update Overhead
The Nectar mattress in the Sleepopolis studio

Transition Layer- Under the first layer of memory foam lies a section of firm transition foam. With a slightly quicker response to pressure than the foam above it, this layer works to ease the sleeper into the firmer base below.

Base Layer – Again, we spot a support layer of high-density poly foam. This firm material gives the bed its stability and shape, working to support the softer foams above it.

Nectar Construction
The materials in the layers of the Nectar mattress

$399 in Free Gifts
Nectar

Holiday Savings Alert! Below is our exclusive Sleepopolis discount, which will usually get you the best deal on your new mattress. However, with this sale, you can save even more!

$440 of free accessories!
Puffy
  • Nice for side sleepers
  • Memory foam feel

Puffy vs Nectar: Best Qualities

Well folks, we’ve officially arrived at the end of this guide, which means it’s time to wrap things up with a few final thoughts (and recommendations!) from me.

First and foremost, I think the Nectar is going to be the best bet for folks after deep pressure relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back. While both mattresses use memory foam to alleviate tension at these sensitive spots, the Nectar does a slightly better job of cushioning these joints. In general, I’d say that this model could be a real winner for strict side sleepers or folks looking to find a mattress for fibromyalgia or arthritis.

In terms of the Puffy, it’s probably most well-suited to back and combination sleepers, particularly those who switch between their side and another position in the night. It’s got a nice medium firmness to it, which makes it a slightly more solid option than the Nectar. Long story short, if you like the idea of memory foam, but don’t want to feel too “stuck” in your bed, the Nectar could be an excellent choice for you.

To get even more specific about my recommendations, let’s summarize a few of my favorite aspects of each mattress.

Puffy Best Features

  • If you like the idea of a medium firm, memory foam feel, look no further than the Puffy mattress!
  • While this vibe could work for a wide range of sleepers, I’d most readily recommend it to back and combination sleepers.

Nectar Best Features

  • Those in search of deep pressure relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back can’t go wrong with the Nectar mattress.
  • I think the Nectar is a great mattress for side sleepers who will get some nice sinkage and contouring from its memory foam feel. However, I’d recommend lighter side sleepers go with a mattress they will sink into more.
  • In particular, I’d suggest that joint pain sufferers consider this snuggly memory foam option.

Comparing Company Policies

Puffy Policies

  • Trial Period – 101-night sleep trial
  • Shipping – Free shipping
  • Mattress Warranty – Lifetime warranty

Nectar Policies

  • Trial Period – 365-night sleep trial
  • Shipping – Free shipping
  • Mattress Warranty – Lifetime warranty 

Comparing Puffy and Nectar Customer Service 

Here at Sleepopolis we like to test out each company’s customer service. I either use the customer service chat function on their website or I call them. Each company can receive one of four ratings: Stellar, Great, Satisfactory, and Poor

Puffy Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating

Great: My question was answered kindly after a few minutes, however I did disagree with the answer the agent gave me. 

Nectar Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating

Stellar: The Nectar customer service agents replied to me immediately and answered my question in detail and with a polite attitude.

Comparing Other Models from Nectar and Puffy

Though we’ve only been discussing the original Puffy and Nectar mattresses, it’s important to note that both brands also sell other beds. So, let’s explore some of those snuggly options below!

Puffy vs Puffy Lux

  • The Puffy Lux is an even softer version of the original Puffy mattress, so could be great for those after a deep, cuddly sleep.
  • For that reason, I mostly recommend this bed for strict side sleepers in need of intense relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back.
  • I’d also add that the Lux is pretty breathable, so could be a nice cooling option for hot sleepers.
  • For more on this bed, take a peek at my full Puffy Lux mattress review.

Puffy vs Puffy Royal

  • As the name suggests, the Puffy Royal is the brand’s luxury model, built as it is with a dynamic, 5-layer construction of memory foam, poly foam, and high-density poly foam.
  • I’d say the Royal has more of a “medium firm” vibe, so could work just as well for back sleepers as it does for side sleepers.
  • If you’re into the idea of an all-foam mattress, but don’t want to feel too “stuck” in your bed, the Royal could be a nice option for you.
  • Get all the details you need at my full Puffy Royal mattress review.

Nectar vs Nectar Premier

  • The Nectar Premier is a more luxurious model than the original Nectar. This supremely soft mattress is built with five layers of foam for a feel that’s deeply pressure-relieving.
  • I’d recommend this mattress for side sleepers after a plush feel that’ll provide plenty of support to the shoulders, hips, and lower back.
  • A small caveat? The Nectar Premier is more expensive than the original Nectar mattress, which could be a dealbreaker for some shoppers.

$399 in Free Gifts
Nectar

Holiday Savings Alert! Below is our exclusive Sleepopolis discount, which will usually get you the best deal on your new mattress. However, with this sale, you can save even more!

$440 of free accessories!
Puffy
  • Nice for side sleepers
  • Memory foam feel

Other Common Puffy and Nectar Comparisons

Puffy

Nectar

The following two tabs change content below.
Avatar

Zoe Ettinger

I'm Zoë, the Editor here at Sleepopolis. I write and edit mattress reviews, and star in mattress review videos. I like to take an honest approach to my reviews to tell you whether or not a product will fit your specific needs. Personally, I'm a side sleeper. I prefer a softer hybrid mattress that lets me sink in. If you have any specific questions feel free to reach out to me at [email protected]
Avatar

Latest posts by Zoe Ettinger (see all)