We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

Brooklyn Signature Mattress Review

If you’ve stumbled upon this page, chances are you’re trying to figure out whether or not you want to buy the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress. This bed is bouncy, supportive, and powered by a well-known brand in the space… but is it right for you?

Well folks, that’s what we’re here to discover. I’ve fully assessed everything from the Signature Hybrid’s construction to its firmness level and pressure relief to help you decide if it meets your sleep needs.

Continue reading below for our full Brooklyn Bedding mattress review! If you’re short on time, feel free to hop on over to my
review summary.

Note: The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress is offered in a Soft, Medium, and Firm model. I’ll be reviewing the Medium model below. 

Save 20% with code SLEEPOPOLIS20
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

Resilient, latex-like foam offers sleepers of all styles great, pressure-relieving support!

Is the Brooklyn Signature a Good Mattress for You?

Family-owned Brooklyn Bedding got its start in 1995, but really hit its stride around 2008 when it began selling its first ever bed-in-a-box. Since then, the brand has grown into one of the most popular on the market, with a product line that includes six different mattresses as well as pillows, sheets, and foundations!

While we won’t be going into all these items, we will take a moment later on to compare the Brooklyn Signature to some other Brooklyn Bedding models. But before we do that, let’s see who the Signature Hybrid could work best for.

The Brooklyn Signature in the Sleepopolis studio.
The Brooklyn Signature in the Sleepopolis studio.

Who I recommend the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid for

  • Given the bed’s excellent bounce, I’d highly recommend it for combination sleepers who need to change positions in the night.
  • I also think it could be a great fit for couples. You shouldn’t be overly disturbed by a restless partner on this bed, and it has nice firm edge support.
  • Back sleepers who like an “on top of the bed” feel should also like this mattress.

Who I don’t recommend the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid for

  • I don’t think this bed is a good fit for side sleepers, who need a softer structure for pressure relief at the shoulders and hips. I’d recommend these sleepers take a look at our best mattress for side sleepers roundup to find a better option.
  • Additionally, those in search of gentler materials (like, say, memory foam), probably won’t find a lot to love in this mattress. I’d direct you to our best memory foam mattresses instead.
  • Strict stomach sleepers may need a firmer mattress. I’d recommend choosing the Firm model of the Signature Hybrid or checking out the Brooklyn Bedding Plank mattress.

How Firm is the Brooklyn Signature Mattress?

Now that you have a general idea of who this mattress could work for, let’s talk about how it feels. Before we get started, I want to remind you that firmness and feel are very subjective. How a mattress will feel to you depends on your body type and preferred sleeping position. To give you a better idea of how this bed feels I polled a range of coworkers to get an average score.

As a reminder, Brooklyn Bedding offers this mattress in several firmness options. I’m reviewing the Medium Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress. If you’re looking for a softer or firmer feel, you may want to opt for the Soft or Firm model of this bed.

The Brooklyn Signature on the mattress firmness scale.
The Brooklyn Signature on the mattress firmness scale.

We gave the mattress a 6.5 out of 10 on the mattress firmness scale. This means the mattress feels medium-firm. Personally, I thought the Signature Hybrid felt just a touch firmer than a true medium-firm mattress.

This mattress has a bouncy, innerspring feel. I felt lifted up and out of the bed. I like this feel for combination sleepers. No matter which positions you cycle through, you should feel supported by the Signature Hybrid. And it should be easy to roll over and switch positions throughout the night.

Side sleeping on Brooklyn Signature
Combination sleepers should like the Signature.
Save 20% with code SLEEPOPOLIS20
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

Resilient, latex-like foam offers sleepers of all styles great, pressure-relieving support!

Brooklyn Signature Mattress Performance

To give you a more objective look at this bed I put it through a few tests. Below, I’ll evaluate the Signature Hybrid’s ability to support different sleepers, pain relief capabilities, and suitability for couples.

Testing the Brooklyn Signature Mattress in Different Sleeping Positions

Different sleepers require different amounts of pressure relief and support. Read on below to see how the Brooklyn Signature performs for people of various body weights.

Is the Brooklyn Signature a Good Mattress for Light Sleepers (Under 130 lbs)?

  • Light Back Sleepers – I also think this feel could work quite well for light back sleepers. It offers a nice balance of pressure and support for these folks.
  • Light Side Sleepers – These sleepers might need a bed that offers more relief around their pressure points. If you’re looking for a plush feel, I’d recommend opting for the Soft model of this bed or checking out one of our best soft mattresses instead.
  • Light Stomach Sleepers – Lightweight stomach sleepers should feel comfortable on the Signature. It will offer enough support to keep their hips lifted up in line with their shoulders.

Is the Brooklyn Signature a Good Mattress for Average Weight Sleepers (130 – 250 lbs)?

  • Average Weight Back Sleepers – These sleepers should feel comfortable and supported, plus be able to move around on this bed with ease.
  • Average Weight Side Sleepers – Side sleepers will likely feel too much pressure around the shoulders and hips on this mattress. I’d recommend they opt for the soft model.
  • Average Weight Stomach Sleepers – The firm lift of this mattress should keep your spine in a fairly healthy alignment here, but your hips may sink into it a little bit. I’d recommend opting for the firm model of this mattress to be safe.

Is the Brooklyn Signature a Good Mattress for Heavy Sleepers (over 250 lbs)?

  • Heavy Back Sleepers – These sleepers should get a good mix of support and pressure relief on this bed, which might feel softer to them than it does to other sleepers.
  • Heavy Side Sleepers – Heavy side sleepers could also like this mattress, and should get a bit more sinkage around the shoulders and hips than other sleepers.
  • Heavy Stomach Sleepers – This mattress is not supportive enough for heavy stomach sleepers. I’d recommend they check out the Brooklyn Titan Luxe Hybrid mattress instead.

Brooklyn Signature Mattress Pain Relief Performance

Another important component of a bed’s feel is its ability to relieve pain. To measure pain relief, I test for pressure relief, which is a measure of how well a mattress alleviates tension at sensitive spots like the shoulders, hips, and lower back.

To see how well the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid relieves pressure I stretched out on a pressure map. This nifty device tracks my movements as I roll around the mattress, recording the force my body exerts across different positions. It creates a map that shows low pressure areas in blue to green and high pressure areas in yellow to red.

The Brooklyn Signature's pressure map results.
The Brooklyn Signature’s pressure map results.

Back Pain — Based on the blue on this pressure map, I think the Signature could be a nice choice for sleepers with back pain. It should promote a healthy sleep posture, which is key to avoiding pain.

Shoulder Pain — Though the pressure map indicated low pressure in the shoulder area, I don’t think this bed is a good fit for sleepers with shoulder pain. Based on my experience on this bed, its firm feel could cause some stiffness to build up in the shoulder area.

Hip Pain — The concentrated green spots around my hips when I’m on my side tell me this mattress would not be a good fit for sleepers with hip pain. I’d recommend one of our best mattresses for hip pain instead.

Brooklyn Signature Mattress Performance for Couples

Couples need a mattress that’s good for sex, features good motion isolation, has good edge support, and sleeps cool. Read on below to see how the Brooklyn Signature performs in those areas, and to learn more about why they’re important.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer is a measure of how much movement travels from one side of the mattress to the other. This is an important factor for all sleepers to consider, but is even more important for anyone who shares a bed with a partner or pet.

To measure motion transfer, I dropped a 10 lb steel ball from heights of 4 inches, 8 inches and 12 inches and measured the disturbance it caused: the bigger the lines, the bigger the disturbance.

The Brooklyn Signature's motion transfer results.
The Brooklyn Signature’s motion transfer results.

These are pretty great motion transfer results, which tells me you shouldn’t be too disturbed by movement on this bed. Though the mattress is certainly bouncy, the top layers of foam do a good job of dampening a lot of the disturbance on its surface. Verdict? You won’t feel overly disturbed by a restless partner on this mattress.

Sex

The best mattresses for couples are normally responsive enough to make moving around during sex easy. The Signature’s bouncy feel definitely makes it easy to more around, which makes me think this could be a great mattress for sex.

Cooling

Couples overheat more quickly than solo sleepers, so often prefer cooling beds. The Brooklyn Hybrid’s hybrid construction encourages a lot of airflow, so I think this bed is a nice cooling pick for hot sleepers.

Edge Support

Another important feature for couples is a mattress’s edge support. Edge support is a measure of whether or not you can sleep all the way on the side of your bed without it collapsing under your weight. The Signature Hybrid had high-quality edge support. I felt very stable on this side of this mattress. This tells me that couples and heavier people will be able to use their entire mattress surface without it sagging at the sides.

What is the Brooklyn Signature Mattress Made of?

The 11-inch Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is built with sturdy CertiPUR-US® Certified foams and pocketed coils.This combination of bouncy foam materials and coils creates a buoyant structure, one that could be especially well-suited for those in need of a little extra support.

Cover — Made of a poly/cotton blend, the cover is soft and breathable with a cozy feel. It’s also quilted with a bit of memory foam, so should provide the sleeper with some immediate pressure relief.

Comfort Layer — The comfort layer is made of the brand’s patented TitanFlex foam, which combines the body-contouring feel of memory foam with the responsiveness of latex foam. This hyper-elastic foam helios lift you up and out of the mattress. It also sleeps fairly cool.

Transition Layer — Up next, you’ll find a layer of Energex foam. This firmer section helps ease the sleeper onto the pocketed coil support system below and adds some additional compression support. I’ll note here that the Signature Hybrid’s Firm option includes high-density memory foam instead of Energex foam in this layer.

Support Layer — The bulk of this bed’s durability and shape comes from its ascension coil system. These individually wrapped coils bring some fantastic bounce to the structure and encourage a ton of breathability, which could help with temperature regulation throughout the night.

Base Layer — Rounding out the mattress is a layer of high-density foam. This support foam is there to give the coils something to bounce off.

Brooklyn Signature layers
A look inside the Brooklyn Signature.

Brooklyn Signature Unboxing and Off-Gassing

Like any bed-in-a-box mattress, the Brooklyn Signature has a 24-48 off-gassing and decompression period after it’s unboxed. The bed might release a slight chemical odor during this time, so I recommend keeping your new mattress in a ventilated room.

My Final Thoughts about the Brooklyn Signature Mattress

Well, we’ve officially arrived at the end of my review. While I can’t decide if the Brooklyn Signature mattress is right for you, I can offer a few final thoughts to help you decide for yourself.

Save 20% with code SLEEPOPOLIS20
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

Resilient, latex-like foam offers sleepers of all styles great, pressure-relieving support!

My favorite things about the Brooklyn Signature mattress

I appreciate that the Brooklyn Signature mattress isolates motion well, has strong edge support, and sleeps fairly cool. All these features, plus its medium-firm comfort level, mean this bed is a great choice for couples. In fact, it’s actually on our best mattresses for couples list this year!

I also like that this mattress offers an “on-top-of-the-bed” feel. I think it’s a great choice for combination sleepers who need a mattress that makes it easy to change positions at night. I’d highly recommend considering the Signature Hybrid if you switch positions frequently throughout the night.

Back sleeping on the Brooklyn Signature
Back and combination sleepers should like the “on the bed feel” the Signature mattress offers.

And finally, I think this mattress is very budget-friendly. If you use our Brooklyn Bedding Mattress coupon you can almost always score a new Signature Hybrid for under $1,000. In fact, this bed has actually made our yearly best mattress under $1,000 list several times.

My Brooklyn Signature mattress complaints

All that said, I don’t think the Brooklyn Signature mattress is perfect! If you’re someone looking for a more luxurious mattress with some bells and whistles, this bed is not for you. This is a no-frills hybrid mattress. If you’re looking for a basic, high-quality bed you should like the Signature, but it doesn’t offer any advanced cooling or pressure-relief tech.

I’ll also note that a few customers complained that their mattress boxes were banged-up upon arrival. That’s a standard risk of purchasing any bed-in-a-box mattress, you never know how gently it will be treated while in-transit. But damage to the shipping box shouldn’t affect your new bed, so I wouldn’t be overly concerned about this.

How Much Does the Brooklyn Signature Cost?

Price point is a huge factor in choosing a new mattress. Take a look below to see pricing and sizing information. And remember that you can save on your purchase with our Brooklyn Bedding Mattress coupon!

Prices listed will be before discount or offer on each size. Additional sizes can be found online.

Save 20% with code SLEEPOPOLIS20
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

Resilient, latex-like foam offers sleepers of all styles great, pressure-relieving support!


SizeDimensionsPrice
Twin38” x 75” x 11"$599
Twin XL38” x 80” x 11"$749
Full53” x 75” x 11"$899
Queen60” x 80” x 11"$1,124
King76” x 80” x 11"$1,374
California King72” x 84” x 11"$1,374

Brooklyn Signature Mattress Policies and FAQs

How does the Brooklyn Signature mattress ship?

The Brooklyn Signature mattress ships for free and will arrive compressed in a box. You should allow a few hours for off-gassing and decompression before sleeping on your new mattress.

Does the Brooklyn Signature mattress come with a sleep trial period?

Yes, all Brooklyn Bedding mattresses come with a 120-night sleep trial. Brooklyn Bedding does ask that you try your new mattress for at least 30 days before starting a return.

Does the Brooklyn Signature come with a mattress warranty?

Yes, the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid mattress is covered by a 10-year warranty.

Do I need to use a box spring with the Brooklyn Signature mattress?

No, the Signature Hybrid is designed to be compatible with any hard, flat surface. A solid foundation or platform bed frame are the best fits for this mattress.

Where is the Brooklyn Signature mattress made?

All Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are made in the USA. The company has its own factory in Phoenix, Arizona.

Brooklyn Signature Mattress Vs

So, we know how the Brooklyn Signature performs, but how does it compare to other mattresses on the market? To find out, we’ll be sizing it up against two popular brands: Helix and Tuft & Needle.

Brooklyn Signature Mattress vs Helix Midnight Mattress

  • The Helix Midnight is a memory-foam hybrid mattress. It offers a bit more pressure-relief than the Brooklyn Signature.
  • The Midnight is also a medium-firm mattress that offers good support.
  • Like the Brooklyn Signature, the Midnight is a nice option for couples.
  • Learn more in the full Helix Midnight mattress review.

Brooklyn Signature Mattress vs Tuft & Needle Mattress

Other Models from Brooklyn Bedding

So, we’ve seen how the Brooklyn Signature fares against other mattress brands, but how does it hold up against other Brooklyn Bedding mattresses? To find out, we’re going to compare it to the Brooklyn Aurora and Brooklyn Bloom Hybrid beds.

Brooklyn Signature Mattress vs Brooklyn Aurora Mattress

Brooklyn Signature Mattress vs Brooklyn Bloom Hybrid Mattress

  • The Bloom is built with all-natural materials, which could be a real selling point for the eco-friendly sleepers out there.
  • This mattress also sleeps super cool, thanks to moisture-wicking wool in the cover and naturally cooling latex foam in the comfort layer.
  • The Bloom has a much bouncier feel than the Signature thanks to its latex construction.
  • Read more in the full Brooklyn Bedding Bloom Hybrid mattress review.
Save 20% with code SLEEPOPOLIS20
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

Resilient, latex-like foam offers sleepers of all styles great, pressure-relieving support!

Our Review Process

Our Sleepopolis reviewers personally test each mattress. We start by unboxing the mattress to figure out how difficult (or easy) it is to get the mattress from the box to the bed. Then, we spend time laying on the bed in different positions, taking time to assess it on our backs, stomachs, and sides. Next, we perform our Sleepopolis tests, using specialized tools to measure qualities like motion transfer, bounce, and pressure relief. Our last step is to open up the mattress and take a look at each layer. These steps allow us to give our final verdict on the mattress. Jump back to our mattress picks.

Still not sure if the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid is the new mattress of your dreams? Take a look at how we rated it below for some extra help deciding.

Brooklyn Signature Mattress
  • Materials
  • Comfort
  • Support
  • Value
  • Cooling
  • Edge Support
  • Trial
  • Warranty
4.1
Avatar

Madison Schaper

Madison is the Staff Writer at Sleepopolis. She reviews new mattresses every week to help readers decide which mattress is best for their needs. When she's not testing out a bed or trying to fit in at least nine hours of sleep you can find her exploring a new park, reading short stories, or checking out a local brewery.