We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

Best Mattress Toppers

If you’re looking for a way to enhance the feel of your mattress without having to buy a new one, a mattress topper might be the accessory for you. They can adjust the firmness of your bed, regulate the temperature of your body, and even keep allergens at bay. If only there were an easy way to find the one that’s right for you…

Well you’re in luck because I rounded up my top five favorite mattress toppers and detailed my own methodology behind topper-shopping. And don’t worry, I picked something for every style of sleeper. So keep reading to learn which mattress topper is the best fit for your body, your bed, and your budget!

Best Memory Foam Topper
Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme
Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme
Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme

The TEMPUR-Topper Supreme is a great mattress topper with a great memory foam feel that offers impressive pressure relief!

Doesn't expire

Best Value Topper
Allswell Mattress Toppers
Allswell Mattress Toppers
Allswell Mattress Toppers

Sleepers who need a little extra comfort can look toward the memory foam feel of the Allswell mattress toppers for contouring pressure relief!

Best Cooling Topper
ViscoSoft Mattress Toppers
ViscoSoft Mattress Toppers
ViscoSoft Mattress Toppers

ViscoSoft has a few different mattress topper options that are great for those looking for a memory foam feel with the added benefit of sleeping cool!

Doesn't expire

Best Organic Topper
Birch Topper
Birch Topper
Birch Topper

The Birch topper uses natural materials like organic cotton and talalay latex to provide great comfort and is a Greenguard Gold certified product. It's a great way to get a bit more pressure relief and extend the life of your mattress!

Doesn't expire

Best Soft Topper
Layla Mattress Topper
Layla Mattress Topper
Layla Mattress Topper

A memory foam topper from Layla is a great way to extend the life of your current mattress!

How Do I Pick The Right Mattress Topper?

First thing’s first — what is a mattress topper? Simply put, a mattress topper is an accessory used to add extra comfort layers to your mattress, and fine-tune the firmness of your bed. They are typically 1-4 inches deep, come in a variety of materials, and can even regulate your body temperature. But with all the toppers available on the market… how do you know which one is best for you?

Well, before we get into my roundup, let’s talk about some key features to focus on as you shop for the perfect topper.

Materials

Firstly, you’ll want to choose the materials that provide the best pressure relief and support for your go-to sleeping position. Think of your topper as a mini mattress — the materials and construction will determine how it feels.

If you sleep on a firm mattress and want to enhance its plushness, a soft foam topper might be your best bet. Or if you sleep on a memory foam mattress and want to add more bounce to your bed, a latex topper might be just the thing.

Most toppers (including the ones in this roundup) are made from either memory foam or latex foam, which offer distinctly different feels. And though we will dive more into these differences in the roundup, let’s take a quick look at a side-by-side comparison of these materials.

Latex offers:

  • A bouncier, quicker response to pressure
  • A softer firmness
  • Lighter density

Memory foam offers:

  • A deep sink into the material
  • A slow response to pressure
  • Thicker density

Keep in mind, though, that firmness and feel varies across materials and brands. So let’s take a look at those factors next.

Firmness

Typically, bedding brands categorize toppers as soft, medium, or firm. But it’s important to note that the firmness of your topper is meant to complement the firmness of your mattress, not change it entirely.

For example, if you’re kicking yourself for buying a bed that’s slightly too firm, try a soft topper and see if that balances the feel to your liking. Just keep in mind that toppers are not meant to dramatically change the firmness of your bed. Instead, think of them as a way to enhance the comfort of the mattress that supports you.

Depth

Mattress toppers range in thickness, with most measuring between 1-4 inches deep. Take some time to determine how much depth you want to add to your mattress, and remember that a thicker topper will probably provide more pressure relief (and be pricier, too).

Heavier sleepers and/or side sleepers may find that a deep topper (3-4 inches) relieves more pressure at sensitive areas like the hips and shoulders. Meanwhile, those only looking to add a thin layer of comfort might be better off with the 1-2 inch options.

Thermoregulation

Now let’s talk about one of my favorite features — thermoregulation. Some toppers are designed to regulate your body temperature, which can be particularly beneficial for those who sleep hot. Brands often use phase change material, copper, graphite, and gel infusions to make a mattress sleep cool.

Keep in mind that not all mattress toppers are made with thermoregulating properties, and it may take a little searching to find one that meets your personal temp preferences (but don’t worry, I’ve listed some in this roundup!)

More: Don’t want a topper but still want to sleep cool? Check out my roundup of the best sheets for hot sleepers!

Cover Fabric

Because toppers are designed to go beneath your fitted sheet, many do not come with cover fabrics. That said, you may decide that you prefer a cover fabric because they can protect your topper and help keep it clean (and some covers are cooling!)

Ultimately, deciding whether or not you want a cover fabric is all about personal preference. But keep in mind that they can make wash care a bit simpler, but also tend to up the price of the topper.

Price

If you’ve spent any time looking for a mattress topper, you’ve probably figured out that they’re kind of pricey (with most ranging from $100-$500). But it’s important to remember that quality costs, and I’d be suspicious of any mattress topper under $50.

To ease the purchasing pressure a bit, aim for brands that offer generous trial periods and/or warranties.A trial period gives you time to decide if the topper is the right fit and, if not, just send it back for a refund. Similarly, a warranty inspires confidence in the consumer by letting you know that the company proudly stands by its product.

Top 5 Best Mattress Toppers

Okay sleepers, I know I’ve just hit you with a lot of information but trust me — these guidelines will make your shopping experience quicker and more efficient. But now (drumroll please), it’s time to look at my top five favorite mattress toppers!

Best Memory Foam Topper

The TEMPUR-Topper Supreme can add a soft memory foam feel to your mattress!

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme

First up on my list is the TEMPUR Topper Supreme from industry veteran Tempur-Pedic.

Covered in a knit polyester blend, this topper feels soft and cozy to the touch. Polyester is also a moisture-wicking material, which can help you (and your topper) stay fresh and dry. And remember — a cover fabric is a great way to protect your topper and keep it clean. But the real comfort lies beneath the cover fabric…

This topper is made from Tempur-Pedic’s proprietary TEMPUR material which, in my opinion, sets the standard for memory foam. It’s dense, durable, and offers that super slow response to pressure that many foam fans enjoy. Not to mention, it’s three inches deep! Heavier sleepers or those looking for an extra-thick topper should definitely give this one a try.

My favorite thing about this topper is that it’s surprisingly cozy by itself! Don’t get me wrong — it’s designed to go on top of your mattress. But the folks at Tempur-Pedic say that its thick construction and medium firm feel make it a great substitute for a mattress when you’re camping or have an overnight guest, and I couldn’t agree more.

Perfect for: Memory foam loyalists looking for a thick, medium-firm topper.

Pricing: $240-$360, which is about average for a durable memory foam topper like this. Keep in mind, though, that this topper is backed by a 25-year warranty, which is the highest I’ve ever seen in a mattress topper. 

Think this bad boy is the topper you’ve been waiting for? Be sure to check out my full review of the TEMPUR Topper Supreme!

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme
Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme

The TEMPUR-Topper Supreme is a great mattress topper with a great memory foam feel that offers impressive pressure relief!

Best Value Topper

Enjoying some nice pressure relief from the graphite infused topper!

Allswell Mattress Toppers

If you love the feel of memory foam (but you’re not trying to break the bank), allow me to introduce the Allswell Home Graphite Topper. 

Like the topper we just looked at, the Allswell is made from memory foam, has a deep 3-inch profile, and offers a medium firm feel. It doesn’t come with a cover fabric, but it does have a special ingredient infused into the foam — graphite. 

Graphite can serve to draw heat away from your body and make for a cooler, cozier snooze, and I’m pleased to report that this topper did just that! Memory foam has a reputation for trapping heat, and this topper is purposefully designed to prevent that from happening. 

For me, one of the biggest draws to this topper is it’s impressively affordable price point. In my experience, high-quality memory foam toppers like this usually start at $100, but this one ranges from $79-$135. Hot sleepers who love the way memory foam conforms to pressure (but don’t want to buy outside the budget) should take this topper for a test run. 

Perfect for: Shoppers looking for a budget-friendly memory foam topper that sleeps cool.

Pricing: $79-$135 which, as I said, is a great value for a thick memory foam topper like this! And if you don’t love it, you’ve got 30 days to return it for a full refund. 

Want to compare this topper to the brand’s other models? Check out my full review of Allswell Home mattress toppers!

Allswell Mattress Toppers
Allswell Mattress Toppers

Sleepers who need a little extra comfort can look toward the memory foam feel of the Allswell mattress toppers for contouring pressure relief!

Best Cooling Topper

The Cooling Copper topper is thicker and cooler to the touch!

ViscoSoft Cooling Copper Topper

Some of you might now be thinking, “Graphite sounds interesting and all, but I need a topper that’s icy-cool to the touch.” Say no more — I’ve got just the thing. 

The Cooling Copper Topper from ViscoSoft is designed specifically for those who run extra hot. It’s made from copper-infused memory foam which, similar to graphite, can draw heat away from your body… But the real cooling power comes from the cover fabric!

This topper is covered in phase change material, a textile crafted to feel cool and soothing on the skin. Phase change material is frequently featured in the world of cooling sleep accessories because it’s designed to feel cool no matter how many times you wash it. In my opinion, its ability to dissipate heat is unrivaled.

Combine the PCM cover with copper-infused foam, and you’re looking at one very cool topper. Additionally, it’s 4 inches deep, which makes it the thickest on this list. It’s got a medium level of firmness which lends itself well to all sleeping positions but, in my opinion, its tall profile is ideal for side sleepers looking for deep pressure relief.

Perfect for: Sleepers looking for a memory foam topper that’s extra thick and cooling!

Pricing: $219-$350, which is about average for a cooling memory foam topper of this depth. Keep in mind that it comes with a generous 60-day trial and a 5-year warranty.

For the full scoop on this topper, be sure to check out my review of the ViscoSoft mattress toppers!

ViscoSoft Mattress Toppers
ViscoSoft Mattress Toppers

ViscoSoft has a few different mattress topper options that are great for those looking for a memory foam feel with the added benefit of sleeping cool!

Best Organic Topper

The Birch topper uses natural materials

Birch Topper

Now let’s take a look at the only topper in this roundup that’s not made from memory foam — the Birch Living Topper. 

Yes, toppers are often made from memory foam because of its ability to conform to pressure, but some sleepers prefer a bouncier feel… And that’s where latex comes in! This topper gets its springy support from Talalay latex, a sustainable material known for its quick response to pressure. 

Folks looking to rest on top of the topper rather than deeply sink into it might find that this is the right choice. But there’s more going on inside this topper than just latex, and it might particularly appeal to eco-friendly sleepers

Firstly, it’s covered in organic cotton (which means no synthetic pesticides were used to make it), and filled with ethically sourced wool. Although wool is known for its ability to keep sleeper warm, it’s actually thermoregulating! This means it dissipates heat when you get too warm, and serves as an excellent insulator when the cold rolls in. 

The layer of wool is 1.5 inches as well, making this topper 3 inches deep. It’s got a soft-but-buoyant feel that I think sleepers of all styles can enjoy! 

Perfect for: Eco-friendly folks looking for a topper made exclusively from organic, sustainable materials! 

Pricing:  $250-500, which is on the pricey side. However, it’s important to note that costs associated with growing and harvesting natural materials often contributes to a higher price tag. Additionally, this topper comes with a long, 100-night trial period.

If you think this is the eco-friendly topper you’ve been searching for, you should definitely check out my full review of the Birch Living Topper!

Birch Topper
Birch Topper

The Birch topper uses natural materials like organic cotton and talalay latex to provide great comfort and is a Greenguard Gold certified product. It's a great way to get a bit more pressure relief and extend the life of your mattress!

Best Soft Topper

The Layla topper’s straps keep it from sliding off the mattress.

Layla Mattress Topper

And last but not least is the Layla topper, ideal for folks looking to add just a dash of softness to their mattress. 

The cover fabric of this topper is made from copper-infused stretch-knit cotton, which feels cool and cozy on the skin (remember, copper draws heat away from the body). And inside the cover is 2 inches of copper-infused memory foam. 

The foam itself ranks a soft-medium on the firmness scale but, to me, it feels closer to soft. Not to mention, it’s only 2 inches deep which puts it on the thinner end of the spectrum. Sleepers looking to enhance the feel of their mattress with a subtle layer of plush memory foam are likely to be most compatible with Layla.

Additionally, the cover fabric is removable and machine washable which might make this topper easier to care for. It also features four corner straps that affix to the mattress to make sure your topper stays securely in place. Personally, I tested this topper on a firm mattress and was pretty impressed by how it balanced the feel. 

Perfect for: Sleepers looking to add a little plush comfort to a firm mattress!

Pricing: $200-$400, depending on the size you choose. Keep in mind that the Layla Topper comes with a 5-year warranty, and a super long trial period of 120 nights!

Want to know more about the Layla Topper? Be sure to check out my full review and, while you’re at it, check out the Layla Mattress too!

Layla Mattress Topper
Layla Mattress Topper

A memory foam topper from Layla is a great way to extend the life of your current mattress!

Final Thoughts

Okay shoppers, now that you know exactly what to look for in a mattress topper and have taken a close look at my personal favorites, you’re ready to start searching. But before you go, allow me to leave you with a few final words of wisdom.

  • Wash Care – It’s important to remember that most mattress toppers are spot-clean only. If you feel nervous about damaging or dirtying your topper, I suggest you aim for one that comes with a removable, washable cover fabric. This will just provide an extra layer of protection for your fancy new sleep accessory!
  • Memory Foam VS Latex – The majority of mattress toppers are made from either memory foam or latex; and as we’ve seen here, they are pretty dissimilar. Take some time to determine which material you prefer, and get more familiar with each one by reading my guide to memory foam VS latex.
  • Compare Prices – Getting the best bang for your buck usually means doing a little extra research. So before you settle on a topper, compare prices across several different brands. Additionally, I always suggest aiming for companies that offer trial periods. Being able to try before you buy gives you the chance to really get a feel for your topper, and then decide if it’s the right fit for you.

Well, that’s all she wrote! Best of luck on your topper-shopping journey, and don’t forget to subscribe to our YouTube channel and follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram for the answers to all your sleep needs.

The following two tabs change content below.
Avatar
Sarah is the Senior Writer and bedding expert at Sleepopolis. Every week, she personally tests and reviews new pillows, sheet sets, and other sleep accessories. She accompanies every video review with a meticulously detailed article to ensure her audience has all the pertinent info they need for the best shopping experience possible. Perhaps that’s why her fans have dubbed her “the most thorough pillow reviewer on the Internet.” Having tested everything from sleep trackers to mattress toppers, Sarah's expertise runs deep and is always expanding. She received her degree in Creative Writing from Brooklyn College and spends her free time doing stand-up, making pasta, and hanging with her cats.
Avatar

Latest posts by Sarah Riccio (see all)