Casper and Layla are two popular bed-in-a-box mattress brands that make very different beds. The Casper original is a gentle foam bed that offers a balance of pressure relief and support, while the original Layla is a flippable memory foam mattress that offers plush sinkage. Wondering which of these beds is the best mattress for you?
Read on to find out! I’m going to compare these beds’ similarities, differences, and special properties in this mattress comparison. By the end, you’ll know which is best for your needs.
Layla vs Casper: Which is Better for You?
As I mentioned above, the Layla is a flippable memory foam mattress and the Casper is a blended foam mattress. The Layla features a soft side and a firm side, while the Casper only comes in one firmness level.
These two constructions mean these beds feel quite different, and are best suited to different sleepers. Take a look below to see my initial recommendations on who should buy which bed. And check out the full Layla mattress review or full Casper mattress review for more in-depth info.
Who Should Buy Layla
- Side sleepers will like the soft side of the Layla, which offers plenty of sinkage around sensitive pressure points like the shoulders and hops.
- Couples might like this memory foam bed, which features great motion isolation. This means you’re unlikely to feel disturbed by a restless partner on the Layla.
- Back sleepers who aren’t sure if they’d prefer a soft or firm mattress could like the Layla. This flippable mattress features a soft and a firm side, so you can test both firmness options before choosing one you like.
Who Should Buy Casper
- Sleepers who struggle with back pain might appreciate the zoned support in the Casper. This mattress is softer at the shoulders and firmer at the hips to provide the right balance of pressure relief and support.
- Back sleepers who like a medium-firm to firm feel could like the Casper.
- Hot sleepers might prefer the Casper, which sleeps a little cooler than the Layla.
Casper vs Layla: Similarities and Differences
The Casper and the Layla are pretty different mattresses, but they do have a few things in common. Take a look below to learn more about their major similarities and differences.
- The Layla and the Casper are both all-foam mattresses.
- Both the Layla and the Casper include memory foam, though the Layla uses much more memory foam than the Casper.
- The Casper and the Layla are in a similar price range.
- The Layla is flippable, the Casper is not.
- The Casper is firmer than the soft side of the Layla and softer than the firm side of the Layla.
- You’ll feel more “on top of” the responsive Casper, and more “hugged by” the slow-moving Layla.
Layla and Casper Mattress Feel Comparison
Next, let’s get into detail about how these beds feel! Keep in mind that feel is subjective, and depends on your body type and preferred sleeping position. When I evaluate a mattress, I have a few coworkers test it with me as well. The feels I describe below are an aggregate of our experiences on these beds.
I’ll start out by talking about the soft side of the flippable Layla mattress. This side of the Layla definitely felt soft. I gave it a 5.5 out of 10 on the mattress firmness scale. The industry standard for medium firmness is a 6.5 out of 10, so the Layla is definitely a truly soft bed. I felt a lot of sinkage in every sleeping position on this mattress, which is a great sign for folks who like a traditional memory foam feel.
The firm side of the Layla got a 7.5 out of 10 on the mattress firmness scale. Which means it felt like a truly firm mattress. I felt a bit more “on top of” this side of the mattress (which features a thinner layer of memory foam), but still felt a bit of body-contouring.
The Casper got a 7 out of 10 rating on the mattress firmness scale. This means it’s just a bit firmer than medium-firm. This mattress felt a bit more balanced than the Layla. I didn’t sink into it as far, and found it easier to roll around and change positions. This responsiveness might be a nice feature for combination sleepers.
I also appreciated the feel of the Casper’s high-quality zoned support layer. This layer is split into different firmness levels to feel softer around the shoulders and firmer around the lower back and hips. This is a great feature for anyone who needs some extra lumbar support, but doesn’t want to sacrifice pressure relief in the shoulder area. It’s also a nice perk for anyone who struggles with lower back pain, because it promotes a healthy spinal alignment.
Comparing What it’s Like to Sleep on the Layla and the Casper
Next, I’ll go into detail about what these beds feel like in each of the main sleeping positions.
Back — Both sides of the Layla should feel comfortable to back sleepers. If you like plenty of sinkage, go with the soft side. If you prefer a bit more support, the firmer side should work well for your needs.
Side — I’d recommend the soft side of the Layla to strict side sleepers. This side of the Layla offers great sinkage and body-contouring, which most side sleepers appreciate. This side of the bed should relieve pressure around sensitive joints for side sleepers.
Stomach — I don’t think either side of the Layla is suitable for stomach sleepers. These folks need to avoid sinkage and keep their hips in line with their shoulders. Too much body-contouring creates a bend in their backs that can lead to pain over time. I’d recommend strict stomach sleepers look at one of our best innerspring mattresses to find a better fit for their needs.
Body Weight — The Layla will likely feel firmer to lighter people, who won’t sink through its memory foam layers as quickly. These folks will most likely want to stick to the softer side of this mattress. On the other hand, heavy people (over 250 lbs) probably won’t get the support they need from the Layla. I’d recommend they opt for one of our best mattresses for heavy people instead.
Back — Back sleepers should feel really comfortable on the Casper! It offers just the right blend of pressure relief and support for these folks, and is one of my favorite mattresses for back sleeping.
Side — Strict side sleepers might find the Casper a bit too firm. But, since it’s softer around the shoulder area, combination sleepers who only spend part of the night on their sides might be comfortable on this bed.
Stomach — Combination sleepers who spend only part of the night on their stomachs could like the Casper. But strict stomach sleepers will need something firmer to prevent their hips from sinking into the bed. I’d recommend one of our best mattresses for stomach sleepers instead.
Body Weight — Like the Layla, the Casper may feel firmer to lighter sleepers and softer to heavier sleepers. Personally, I don’t think the Casper offers enough support for heavier sleepers either. These folks often do best on a hybrid mattress that uses innerspring support to provide some additional durability. If this is something you’re looking for, I recommend taking a look at our picks for the best hybrid mattresses of 2021.
Comparing Layla and Casper Prices
Cost is a big factor when choosing a new mattress. Take a look below to find pricing and sizing information for the Casper and the Layla. And be sure to visit our Casper mattress coupon and Layla mattress coupon pages to snag a deal on these beds!
Prices listed are before discount or offer on each size.
Comparing Layla and Casper Mattress Materials
Next up, I’m going to describe the constructions of the Layla and the Casper to give you an even better idea of what these beds are like.
Note: I’ll be describing the Layla with the soft side facing up.
Cover — The Layla’s mattress cover is made of a breathable thermo-gel fabric to help encourage airflow.
Soft Comfort Layer — Right below the cover is a 3-inch layer of copper-infused memory foam. This layer is soft and contours around the body for a pressure-relieving feel. The copper infusion helps to prevent the bed from trapping body heat like a traditional memory foam mattress would.
Transition Layer — A layer of Layla’s Max Airflow support foam helps ease the sleeper down onto the firmer support layer below.
Support Layer — A firm high-density poly foam support core provides structure and lift to the rest of the bed.
Firm Comfort Layer — With the soft side up, the bottom layer of the Layla is 1-inch of copper-infused memory foam. Sleepers won’t feel this layer in this configuration, but when the mattress is flipped, it provides pressure relief while retaining more firmness than the soft comfort layer.
Cover — The cover on the Casper is a breathable polyester blend that is easily removable by zipper.
Comfort Layer — Under the cover is a top layer of Airscape foam. This open-cell foam was designed to feel like latex, which is naturally cooling and has a faster response to pressure than memory foam. This is why you’ll feel more “on top of” the Casper than the Layla.
Transition Layer — Next up is a memory foam layer that’s separated into three different support zones. Each zone has a different firmness level, creating a zoned support system that’s ideal for sleepers in need of a little extra lumbar support.
Base Layer — Like the Layla, the Casper uses a common type of heavy duty poly foam to shape the mattress and provide foundational support.
Layla vs Casper: Best Qualities
We are finally at the end of our Layla vs Casper mattress comparison! Which one is your personal winner? Only you can say, but I will sum up everything here to make your decision easier.
Layla Best Features
- Strict side sleepers should enjoy the pressure relief on the softer side of the Layla.
- Anyone who loves the classic memory foam feel of sinking into the mattress will appreciate the copious amount of memory foam in the Layla!
- This flippable bed is a great option for sleepers who aren’t sure what firmness level they’re looking for.
Casper Best Features
- Combination sleepers should love the responsiveness of this mattress, which makes it easy to change positions throughout the night.
- Sleepers with back pain will find a lot to love in the Casper’s zoned support system, which offers extra lift where they need it most.
- Back sleepers should enjoy the gentle, balanced foam feel of the Casper mattress, which hits the sweet spot between pressure relief and support.
Comparing Company Policies
- Trial Period – 120-night trial
- Shipping – Free shipping
- Mattress Warranty – Lifetime warranty
- Trial Period — 100-night trial
- Shipping — Free shipping
- Mattress Warranty — 10-year warranty
Comparing Layla and Casper Customer Service
I rate each brand I review’s customer service team. Each team can receive a Stellar, Great, Satisfactory, or Poor score. I base my rating on my personal experiences interacting with each team.
Layla Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating
Great: I gave Layla a great rating because they clearly display their contact information and answer Zendesk questions thoroughly within the business day. But they don’t have a live chat feature, something many other mattress brands offer.
Casper Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating
Stellar: I gave Casper a stellar rating because they offer an easy-to-find live chat feature. My question was answered thoroughly almost immediately, which I really appreciated.
Comparing Other Models from Layla and Casper
It’s always a good idea to compare a mattress you’re considering to a few other models from the same company. Below, I’ll compare the original Casper and original Layla to a few other models from each brand.
- This is Casper’s budget model, so it’s more affordable than the original Casper and the Layla.
- The Element has a firmer feel than the original Casper.
- Poly foam and memory foam provide a good balance between pressure relief and support, which makes this mattress good for strict back sleepers and combo sleepers.
- Get the details in my full Casper Element mattress review!
- The Hybrid is basically the original Casper with a layer of coils, which makes it bouncier than the original Casper and the Layla.
- Combination sleepers should love the Hybrid because its bounce makes it easy to change sleeping positions.
- The Casper Hybrid is more expensive than the original Casper.
- Learn more in my full Casper Hybrid mattress review!
Casper Wave Hybrid
- The Wave Hybrid is bouncier than its all-foam counterpart.
- The softer profile of the Wave Hybrid means that most side sleepers should like how it feels.
- The Casper Wave Hybrid is more expensive than the original Casper.
- Check out my full Casper Wave Hybrid mattress review!
- The Layla Hybrid is also flippable.
- It includes pocketed coil support for a more responsive feel.
- Like the original Layla, this mattress is a nice option for couples.
- Find out more in my full Layla Hybrid mattress review.
Other Common Layla and Casper Comparisons
Want to learn more about these mattress brands? Check out a few other common comparisons below.
- Casper vs Helix
- Casper vs Leesa
- Casper vs WinkBeds
- Casper vs Purple
- Casper vs DreamCloud
- Casper vs Endy
- Casper vs Nectar
- Casper vs Lull
- Casper vs Puffy
- Casper vs Brooklyn Bedding
- Casper vs Saatva
- Casper vs GhostBed