If you’re on the hunt for a new comforter but not sure where to start, you’ve come to the right place. In this review, I rounded up my top six favorite comforters (all of which I’ve personally tested) to help guide you in your search. So keep reading to learn all about these bedding essentials, and get some insight into my own tips and tricks for picking the perfect comforter!
Best Natural Down |
||
Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter
 |
Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter
The Brooklinen comforter use natural down and is great for those looking for a really fluffy feel. Enjoy 10% off your order with code SLEEPOPOLIS10! |
|
Best Duvet |
||
Casper Humidity Fighting Duvet
 |
Casper Humidity Fighting Duvet
The Casper Duvet is covered in a soft and breathable cotton shell, which I found to offer good airflow through the fabric! |
Doesn't expire |
Best for Hot Sleepers |
||
Buffy Breeze Comforter
 |
Buffy Breeze Comforter
One of the most popular names in online bedding is the new Buffy Breeze comforter. It's made from eco-friendly plant based and recycled materials and has a great cooling feel. Use code SLEEP to save $20 on your purchase! |
Doesn't expire |
Best Eco-Friendly |
||
Buffy Cloud
|
Buffy Cloud
One of the most popular names in online bedding is the new Buffy comforter. It's made from eco-friendly plant based and recycled materials and has a great cooling feel. Use code SLEEP to save $20 on your purchase! |
Doesn't expire |
Best Budget-Friendly |
||
Linenspa All-Season Comforter
 |
Linenspa All-Season Comforter
The Linenspa All-Season Comforter is a quality choice for those looking for a value comforter option. |
Doesn't expire |
Best for Cool Weather |
||
Snowe Down Comforter
 |
Snowe Down Comforter
The Snowe Comforter is amply stuffed with ethically sourced down and great for cold weather use. Save 10% on orders of $100 or more with the code SLEEPOPOLIS10! |
How Do I Pick The Right Comforter?
Finding the right comforter is all about matching materials to your own unique sleep needs. Some comforters are crafted to keep you warm, while others are cool and breathable. Some are light and feathery, while others are thick and cushiony. With so many options available, it can be tough to know which comforter is right for you.
So before we get into my top picks, let’s take a look at my personal methodology behind finding the right comforter. Of course, a lot comes down to personal preference, but there are some key factors to keep in mind while you shop.
- Style – Comforters come in a variety of styles, many of which feature printed patterns or bright colors. In fact, comforters can often be purchased as part of a “bed-in-a-bag” ensemble wherein matching pillowcases and sheets are included. If you’re looking to break away from plain white bedding, take some time to decide what you want your comforter to look like. This will narrow your search, as some brands only offer comforters in solid white.
- Cover Fabric – When it comes to temperature regulation, your comforter’s cover fabric plays a major role. Sleepers who run cold should aim for insulating fabrics like fleece, flannel, microfiber, or cotton sateen. Meanwhile, those looking to sleep cool are better suited to breathable materials like Tencel, cotton percale, or anything bamboo-based. Additionally, those with sensitive skin or allergies might want to prioritize fabrics that are hypoallergenic and OEKO-Tex certified.
- Internal Fill – One of the most important things to pay attention to is the comforter’s internal fill. From polyester to natural down, comforters can be stuffed with many different materials and it’s best to research the one you’re looking at before you make your purchase. Perhaps the most popular comforters (and the majority in this roundup) are filled with either real down or down-alternative. And while they sound similar, these materials differ quite a bit in feel and price (much more on this later!)
- Fill Power – If you’re shopping specifically for a real down comforter, pay attention to the term “fill power.” Fill power is used to measure the loft of a down product and goes a long way in determining how fluffy and warm it will be. Fill power typically ranges from 300-900, and if you’re in the market for a lofty, insulating comforter, I suggest a fill power of 600 or higher.
- Price – The price of a comforter depends upon the materials used to make it. Keep in mind that real down tends to be more expensive than down-alternative, and cost can fluctuate according to the popularity of the bedding brand itself. That said, I suggest you always take note of trial periods and return policies, as these things can ease the purchasing pressure a bit. Not to mention, a generous trial/return policy inspires confidence in the consumer and lets you know that the company proudly stands by its product.
Okay sleepers, with this methodology in mind, let’s dive into the roundup of my top six favorite comforters!
Best Natural Down
Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter
If you’re looking for a fluffy comforter made from real down, the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter is a great choice.
This comforter is covered in 100% cotton sateen, which feels silky and smooth to the touch. Additionally, sateen woven cotton has a natural luster to it which might appeal to those who prefer a subtle sheen to a matte appearance.
As far as what’s inside this comforter, it’s ideal for the down-lovers out there. It’s filled with ethically sourced down clusters… and only the clusters. Many down comforters are filled with a combination of clusters and feathers, but it’s important to note that clusters are softer, fluffier, and more insulating as compared to feathers (they’re also less likely to poke through the fabric!)
This comforter features a fill power of 700 which, as I mentioned, is on the high end of the spectrum. Sleepers looking for comforter that’s extra fluffy should give this one a try. Additionally, the down is treated with a textile manufacturing technology called Ultra Fresh Antibacterial Additives, which is used to make it hypoallergenic and resistant to mold and mildew.
Want to know more about Brooklinen down products? Check out my review of the Brooklinen Natural Down Pillow!
Perfect for: The sleeper who just can’t say no to a fluffy natural down comforter!
Pricing: $299-$399, which is about average for a down comforter of this fill power. What’s great about this brand, though, is it offers a lifetime warranty on all its products!
The Brooklinen comforter use natural down and is great for those looking for a really fluffy feel. Enjoy 10% off your order with code SLEEPOPOLIS10!
Best Duvet
Casper Humidity Fighting Duvet
Yes, this is technically a duvet and not a comforter, but I’m including it anyway because it brings some unique benefits to the game.
Firstly, it’s covered in a soft and breathable cotton shell, which I found to offer good airflow through the fabric. It’s filled with ethically sourced down, and features sewn-in chambers that keep the down in place and prevent it from concentrating into one area. Similar to the Brooklinen comforter we just looked at, it’s got a fluffy cloud-like feel that’s characteristic of real down, and features a high fill power of 750.
More: Check out my guide to understanding the difference between a comforter and a duvet!
What’s unique about this duvet, though, is the layer of merino wool that sits directly beneath the cotton shell. Now you might be thinking, “Yikes, wool is way too warming for a hot sleeper like me.” But the wool is actually the reason this comforter is called “humidity fighting.”
Wool is thermoregulating, which means it adapts to your body’s temperature and can serve to regulate your warmth throughout the night. Essentially, it draws heat away from your body when you get too hot, and serves as an excellent insulator when you get chilly. Additionally, wool is naturally moisture-wicking, which might be particularly beneficial to those prone to night sweats.
Want to know more about Casper products? We’ve reviewed Casper sheets, mattresses, and pillows!
Perfect for: The sleeper looking for a temperature regulating down duvet!
Price: $350-$450, which is on the pricey side, but Casper offers a generous trial period of 100 nights. So if you don’t love it, just send it back within that time frame for a full refund.
The Casper Duvet is covered in a soft and breathable cotton shell, which I found to offer good airflow through the fabric!
Best for Hot Sleepers
Buffy Breeze Comforter
Now let’s take a look at two comforters from Buffy — both the Breeze and the Cloud.
Let’s start with the Buffy Breeze, which I’ve dubbed as best for hot sleepers. From the internal fill to the outer shell, this entire comforter is made from lyocell. Lyocell is a natural material made from eucalyptus wood pulp that some of you may already know by the trademark name, Tencel.
So… Why eucalyptus? Well, it’s known for its anti-inflammatory properties which can cool and soothe the skin, and the primary purpose of this comforter is to keep sleepers cool. Additionally, the Buffy Breeze has a low loft in order to promote breathability and prevent you from warming up throughout the night.
On a personal note, I can tell you that I’m a year-round hot sleeper and the Buffy Breeze is my go-to comforter. The cover fabric is uniquely soft and cooling, and the internal fill feels like a lightweight down-alternative. If you’re looking for a comforter that’ll keep you cozy and cool, this might be the best fit for you.
Want to know every last detail about this comforter? Check out my full review of the Buffy Breeze.
Perfect for: Hot sleepers looking for a lightweight cooling comforter!
Price: $180-$260 which, in my opinion, is a great value for a cooling, plant-based comforter. Keep in mind that Buffy offers a unique trial period wherein you’re not charged until after your 7-day trial period is up.
One of the most popular names in online bedding is the new Buffy Breeze comforter. It's made from eco-friendly plant based and recycled materials and has a great cooling feel. Use code SLEEP to save $20 on your purchase!
Best Eco-Friendly
Buffy Cloud
Now let’s talk about the brand’s original comforter, the Buffy Cloud.
It’s covered in the same material as the Breeze, but it’s filled with a down-alternative eco-fiber spun from recycled plastic bottles. So, between the cover and the internal fill, the Cloud is made entirely from recycled and plant-based materials which makes it ideal for folks looking to sleep green.
While both Buffy comforters offer a soft, down-alternative feel, the Cloud is fluffier and has a higher loft. Eco-friendly sleepers looking for a down-alternative comforter to keep them warm should definitely look into the Cloud!
P.S. Regardless of which Buffy comforter you choose, they both come with a lavender-infused sleep mask!
Think this one is more up your alley? Check out my full review of the Buffy Cloud to get the full scoop!
Perfect for: Eco-friendly folks looking for a fluffy down-alternative comforter.
Price: $130-$200 which, again, is a pretty good value. And remember — you have 7 nights to sleep with your Buffy comforters, for free, and then you decide whether you want to pay for them.
One of the most popular names in online bedding is the new Buffy comforter. It's made from eco-friendly plant based and recycled materials and has a great cooling feel. Use code SLEEP to save $20 on your purchase!
Best Budget-Friendly
Linenspa All-Season Comforter
By now, you may have noticed that comforters aren’t the least expensive sleep accessories on the market. But if you look hard enough, you can find one that’s perfect for shoppers on a budget.
Cue the Linenspa All-Season Comforter! It’s filled with a cushy down-alternative called polyfiber, and it offers a medium loft that’s suitable for all seasons. The cover fabric is made from 100% microfiber, which has a distinctly suede-like feel characteristic of this material.
Personally, I like this comforter because it’s cozy, fluffy, and features gridded stitching for balanced distribution of internal fill. Not to mention, it’s got eight loops on the corners and sides for those who want to dress this comforter with a cover.
But perhaps one of the biggest draws to the Linenspa comforter is it’s very reasonable price point. It comes in a wide variety of sizes from Twin to California King, and ranges in price from $30-$80. Sleepers looking for a classic comforter without the extra frills (or the extra cost) are likely to be most compatible with this one!
Perfect for: Sleepers looking for a classic comforter essential that’s easy on the budget!
Price: $30-$80 which, as I said, is a great value for this cozy down-alternative comforter.
The Linenspa All-Season Comforter is a quality choice for those looking for a value comforter option.
Best for Cool Weather
Snowe Down Comforter
Last (but certainly not least) is the All-Season Down Comforter from Snowe Home.
First let me say that I’ve tested several Snowe products and have always been super impressed by the quality of each one. So when I tested this comforter, I wasn’t surprised by how luxuriously fluffy and durable it feels. But the thing that really stands out about this comforter is how warm it is!
It’s amply stuffed with ethically sourced down, and features a high fill power of 750. Remember — a fill power of over 600 means your down comforter is going to be especially lofty, fluffy, and insulating. For me, this is the kind of cloud-like comforter that’s perfect for wintertime, but I think sleepers who run cold would enjoy it year-round.
The cover fabric is made from 330 thread count cotton sateen, which feels silky-smooth on the skin and offers a subtly lustrous appearance. And while I do think this particular comforter is best for cool weather, it is offered in a “lightweight” option which has 40% less fill. So if you love the materials used to make this comforter but you sleep hot, I’d go with the lightweight model.
Looking for some Snowe Home sheets to go with this comforter? Check out my full review of Snowe’s percale and sateen sheet sets!
Perfect for: Down-lovers who sleep cool or are searching for the perfect wintertime comforter!
Price: $228-$268, which is a pretty good value for a lofty down comforter like this. Additionally, sleepers can enjoy a long trial period of 90 days.
The Snowe Comforter is amply stuffed with ethically sourced down and great for cold weather use. Save 10% on orders of $100 or more with the code SLEEPOPOLIS10!
Final Thoughts
Okay sleepers, you’ve learned what to look for when you’re shopping for a new comforter and taken a close look at my personal favorites. All that’s left to do now is take advantage of some of those trial periods and decide which is best for you! But before we wrap up, allow me to leave you with a few pro tips:
- Down VS Down-Alternative – Sleepers are generally looking for a comforter that’s fluffy and cozy, which is why most comforters are filled with either real down or down-alternative. Both have a plush and comfy feel, but real down tends to feel fluffier than an alternative. Take some time to determine which material might be best for you, and keep in mind that real down is warmer and more insulating (and usually more expensive).
- Wash Care – Wash care varies from product to product and totally depends upon the materials used to make it. If I were you, I’d check the exact care instructions before making your purchase. It would be a shame to buy a new comforter only to find out that it requires more maintenance than you’re willing to give.
- Compare Prices – To make sure you’re getting the absolute best bang for your buck, be sure to compare prices across bedding brands. But keep in mind that higher quality materials tend to come at a higher cost, so if you happen upon a down comforter that costs less than $100, make sure that it’s filled with real down. Advertising can be a bit misleading and it’s important to read through the “materials description” to ensure you’re getting what you want.
Well that’s all she wrote! But don’t forget to like and subscribe to our YouTube channel and follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram for the answers to all your sleep needs. Happy shopping, everybody.