Nectar and Tuft & Needle are two of the most popular bed-in-a-box mattresses in the game. Where the former employs a thick layer of memory foam up top to create some satisfying pressure relief, the latter utilizes a straightforward two-layer foam design to ensure comfort at a value price.
Both of these mattresses promise a well-rounded sleeping experience from opposite sides of the all-foam spectrum. But which mattress hits the nail on the head just right? There’s only one way to find out…
Continue reading below for our full Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle mattress comparison or click this link to skip to the summary for the quick version if you’re in a rush.
Nectar vs Tuft & Needle: Similarities and Differences
As you’ll see, there are quite a few similarities between both of these all-foam mattresses, as well as a few differences that we’ll be sure to cover. For more in-depth analysis, check out the full [Nectar mattress review](insert new Nectar review) and the full Tuft & Needle mattress review.
- First and foremost, both the Nectar and the Tuft & Needle mattress have a firmness score of 7, placing them in the category of medium-firm. As you’ll see once I get into the materials, some of the foams are very similar, which likely resulted in the same firmness scores.
- The medium-firmness of each mattress makes both of them ideal for back sleepers.
- Regarding temperature regulation, both beds sleep cool, although it’s worth noting that Tuft & Needle will likely be a bit cooler, thanks to the infusion of graphite in its top layer.
- While the Tuft & Needle isn’t the best fit for side sleepers, the contouring of the Nectar’s gel memory foam might work for heavy side sleepers. Lighter side sleepers may want to look for something softer, though.
- Despite the same level of firmness and similarities in some of the materials, the structures of the beds are a bit different—the Nectar has three layers while the Tuft & Needle only has two.
- The Nectar has much better motion transfer results than the Tuft & Needle, meaning it’s probably the better fit for anyone who shares their bed with a partner or pet.
Which is Better for You?
Now that we’ve talked about the similarities and differences, let’s quickly sum up who each bed might be good for:
- If you’re a back sleeper both of these beds have a firmness level that will likely be a good match.
- If you’re a heavy side sleeper you’ll probably want to opt for the Nectar over the Tuft & Needle. However, light side sleepers may need something softer than either of these beds can offer.
- If you sleep with a partner or pet you’ll probably want to go with the Nectar.
- If you’re a stomach sleeper allow me to direct you to our Best Mattresses for Stomach Sleepers list.
Nectar vs Tuft & Needle Mattress Feel Comparison
It’s time to go into greater depth about how each mattress feels. Keep in mind that people come in all shapes, sizes, and sleeping positions, so this section is always going to be somewhat subjective. But I’ll do my best to touch on topics such as contouring, firmness level, and more.
As we noted, the Nectar scored a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale, placing it in the category of medium-firm. That being said, its gel memory foam provides an “in” the bed feel, with the foam layers below it preventing one from sinking too far into the mattress. That’s why it’s still a good fit for back sleepers or folks experiencing back pain. However, combination sleepers will likely find it too difficult to switch positions on this bed, as they’ll really sink into its memory foam layer. In short, it’s a nice mixture of firmness and that classic memory foam feel.
For an all-foam mattress, the Nectar Original has considerable edge support, making it a decent option for couples or anyone who sleeps with a pet.
Tuft & Needle
The Tuft & Needle is also surprisingly firm, scoring a 7 out of 10 on its firmness level, just like the Nectar.
In regards to sleeping positions, the top layer of foam works to fill in the lumbar region. Coupled with the high-density poly foam base, there’s a lot of support and pressure relief here for back sleepers. Side sleepers, on the other hand, may experience a lot of jamming when they turn over. Similarly, the top layer of foam may cause stomach sleepers’ hips to sync out of alignment with their shoulders.
Additionally, the Tuft & Needle offers a good deal of edge support, but only an average score on motion transfer. So you might feel your partner tossing and turning at night.
Comparing Nectar and Tuft & Needle Prices
Pricing is important when purchasing any new mattress, but with these two beds, there isn’t too much of a difference. In fact, they both frequently make our Best Mattresses Under $1,000 list. Take a look at the pricing chart below to see which is the best fit for you, and be sure to use our Nectar coupon codes or Tuft & Needle coupon codes to get the best bang for your buck when selecting an online mattress.
Prices listed will be before discount or offer for each size.
|Size||Nectar||Tuft & Needle|
Comparing Nectar and Tuft & Needle Mattress Materials
Let’s pull back the sheets so we can get a better idea of what both of these beds are made of.
The Nectar Original mattress is Nectar’s flagship bed—an all foam mattress that toggles between contouring and a medium-firm feel.
- Cover – First, you’ll encounter a quilted cover of polyester and nylon—a lightweight material conducive to airflow. This helps the mattress sleep cool.
- Comfort Layer – Next comes a thick layer of gel memory foam. Like the comfort layer of any good memory foam mattress, this envelops the sleeper in a cozy hug, but because of the thickness, there’s a slow response time that ensures you won’t sink too far into the mattress.
- Transition Layer – The anti-sinkage is aided by the next layer of soft conventional foam, which has an adaptive response and provides additional cushioning and support.
- Base Layer – Finally, the base layer is made of high-density foam that establishes a foundational durability. This bottom support layer also has a mattress cover to prevent slippage on the bed frame.
Tuft & Needle
The Original Tuft & Needle is a 10-inch mattress with a no-frills design of just two foam layers.
- Cover – The simple polyester cover is thin and light, promoting easy air flow throughout the bed.
- Comfort Layer – Underneath the cover, you’ll find three inches of Tuft & Needle’s patented Adaptive foam, meaning there’s a good deal of mobility and bounce. This is also where the cooling tech comes in, courtesy of a cooling gel and graphite that works to absorb and dissipate body heat.
- Base – Uniquely, the base of the Tuft & Needle makes up most of the bed with its seven inches of high-density poly foam. While sturdy and supportive in its open-cell design (once again adding to the breathability), the fact that there are only two layers might cause heavier sleepers to sink into the bed.
We’ve gone over a lot today, so now the big question: which mattress should you buy? Due to the similarity of these beds, you really can’t go wrong. But let me take a minute to outline some features that might help you decide which bed might be best for your specific needs.
Nectar Best Features
- While both the Nectar and the Tuft & Needle should appeal to back sleepers, the Nectar does provide more sinkage and contouring for anyone who wants firmness while still getting that classic memory foam feel.
- This might sound small, but Nectar has a 365-day sleep trial period that, when compared to Tuft & Needle’s 100 days, might be a good fit for more cautious or hesitant buyers.
- Because the Nectar has higher motion isolation, it will likely be the better option for anyone who sleeps with someone else in the bed.
Tuft & Needle Best Features
- Back sleepers who like a buoyant feel, “on top” of the bed feel are likely to prefer the Tuft & Needle, especially if they’re not sharing their bed with anyone else.
- If temperature is an important concern, both of these beds sleep cool. But the Tuft & Needle scores a little higher in this department because of that graphite infusion on the top layer.
- The same goes for firmness. Once again, both of these beds have an identical firmness score, but the Tuft & Needle offers less contouring and more support on the lumbar region due to its lack of a transition layer and extra-thick layer of high-density poly foam.
Comparing Company Policies
- Trial Period – 365-night trial
- Shipping – Free shipping
- Mattress Warranty – Lifetime warranty
Tuft & Needle Policies
- Trial Period – 100-night trial
- Shipping – Free shipping
- Mattress Warranty – 10-year warranty
Comparing Nectar and Tuft & Needle Customer Service
Let’s take a moment to look at each brand’s customer service team. I’ll give them a score of Stellar, Great, Satisfactory, or Poor based on my interaction with each team.
Nectar Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating
- Stellar: Nectar has an informative and easily navigable customer service page, bolstered by a comprehensive list of FAQs. They also list out the various ways you can get in touch with them, including email, phone, and chat, as well as which hours of the week all of those methods are available. I contacted them via chat during business hours and was able to quickly resolve my issue.
Tuft & Needle Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating
- Stellar: Tuft & Needle has a variety of customer service options listed on their support page, including an FAQ, a contact form, and a support number that’s open seven days a week until 5 p.m. Pacific Time. I called the number and was able to get in touch with someone right away who was able to resolve my issue.
Comparing Other Models from Nectar and Tuft & Needle
- A plus counterpart to the Original firm mattress, the Nectar Lush’s layers of memory foam comprise a mix of gel memory foam, Energex foam, and high-density poly foam.
- At a 5.5 on the firmness scale, the Nectar Lush has a great deal of contouring and pain relief for side sleepers.
- Intrigued? Check out the full Nectar Lush mattress review for more info.
Tuft & Needle Mint
The Tuft & Needle Mint mattress is the brand’s luxury take on the Original. Here are some of the key differences:
- Unlike the Original, the Mint does have a transition layer of poly foam, which means it provides more contouring and just a bit more edge support.
- The added poly foam also adds more softness that should be appealing to side sleepers who prefer extra support for their shoulders and hips.
- This probably goes without saying, but because it’s essentially the luxury version of the Tuft & Needle Original, it’s significantly more expensive.
- If the Tuft & Needle Mint sounds like it might be a good fit for you, you can read the full review here.
Tuft & Needle Hybrid Mattress
The Tuft & Needle Hybrid mattress throws an innerspring network of pocketed coils into the mix for a design meant to be pressure-relieving, supportive, and cool.
- The Hybrid’s added bounciness makes the mattress a good fit for combo sleepers or anyone who tends to change positions during the night.
- The added support should also be a better fit for couples, making the Hybrid a more worthy opponent in this area than the Original.
- Like most hybrid beds, Tuft & Needle’s is a lot more expensive than the original.
- Click here to check out the full review of the Tuft & Needle Hybrid Mattress.