We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

Best Mattress for the Money 2019

Buying a new mattress is a big decision. Not only are you going to be investing in something that you’ll (hopefully) have for years, but you’re also going to be dropping some pretty serious coin in the process. It can feel overwhelming, especially when faced with the soaring price tags of some of the splashier brands on the market.

But can I let you in on a little secret? You don’t have to break the bank to find a fantastic mattress. In fact, there are a plethora of affordable options available online that are just as luxurious, supportive, and sleep-changing as any of the pricier models you might come across in your search.

For me, the key is in asking the right questions and figuring out which models are going to give you the absolute most bang for your buck. Unsure of where to begin? No worries! I’ve compiled my favorite value mattresses by category below, so no matter the kind of bed you seek, you’re bound to see one that feels like the perfect fit.

Check out my picks below! And in case you’re wondering how in the world I selected these mattresses, I included a quick section detailing my methodology at the end of this write-up.

Best Mattress for the Money Top Picks

Naturally, these reflect my own preferences and biases (as of 2019), so just use this list as a starting point. Below are some of my best-valued mattresses on the market:

Best Memory Foam
Layla Mattress
Layla Mattress
Layla Mattress

A luxury memory foam mattress at a Layla price doesn't come around often! The mattress is flippable (two firmness options) and is copper infused, giving you the memory foam feel without sleeping hot.

Best for Side Sleepers
Nolah Mattress
Nolah Mattress
Nolah Mattress

The Nolah mattress is specifically designed for side sleepers, and delivers one heck of a sleeping experience for the price. The pressure relief per dollar on this mattress is off the charts.

Best Hybrid Mattress
Helix Midnight Mattress
Helix Midnight Mattress
Helix Midnight Mattress

The Helix Midnight comes in at the standard 10" version or the 14" LUXE version. Either way it uses a mix of quality foams and pocketed coils for a great mix of support and pressure relief. Enjoy $75 off the standard Helix mattress and $125 off the Helix Luxe mattress by using our exclusive discount codes!

Best for Back Pain
Birch Mattress
Birch Mattress
Birch Mattress

The Birch mattress uses natural materials like organic cotton and talalay latex to provide great comfort from an organic product! Use code SLEEPOPOLIS200 for $200 off the mattress.

Doesn't expire

Best for Heavy Sleepers
WinkBeds Plus Mattress
WinkBeds Plus Mattress
WinkBeds Plus Mattress

If you are a heavier sleeper (250 lbs or more) you should consider a mattress that takes that into consideration. If you're also thinking about value, enter the Winkbeds Plus. A well crafted and durable mattress, you won't find a mattress of this quality for heavier sleepers at a more reasonable price.

Best Innerspring
Saatva Mattress
Saatva Mattress
Saatva Mattress

The Saatva is really a luxury innerspring at an affordable price. The components in this mattress rival mattresses that are several times more expensive, providing a wonderful traditional innerspring feel. Note though the Saatva is available only online, it does not come delivered compressed in a box.

Best Cooling
Tuft and Needle Mattress
Tuft and Needle Mattress
Tuft and Needle Mattress

The Tuft & Needle mattress comes in at an incredibly affordable price, with some great cooling features built into their proprietary foam design. Also check out the Tuft & Needle mint for a more luxury mattress at a great value.

Best for Pressure Relief
Nectar Mattress
Nectar Mattress
Nectar Mattress

Nectar is one of the most popular mattresses online for a reason - it's an incredible memory foam mattress at a very affordable price. It's actually priced significantly below most of the other bed-in-a-box mattresses as well. Nectar is definitely worth a look if you're shopping on a budget but still want a high quality sleep experience!

Best Value
Allswell Mattress
Allswell Mattress
Allswell Mattress

The Allswell is a quality mattress coming in at a shockingly low price - a great option for sleepers in all positions, including stomach sleepers. Use code SLEEPOPOLIS15 to save 15% until June 30!

Top Value Mattress Picks Detailed

Read on for more details on these top picks, or click here for more info on how to spot a great mattress value.

Best Memory Foam Mattress

Layla mattress with the soft side up

Layla Mattress

Looking for a value memory foam mattress? Check out Layla. This isn’t the cheapest memory foam mattress on the market, but it has a construction that makes it stand out as an affordable luxury memory foam option in my mind.

The mattress is flippable, giving you two firmness options, and the memory foam is infused with copper to help you sleep cool. 

Learn more in my full Layla mattress review.

Two other best memory foam mattress options for the money are Bear mattress and Novosbed.

Save $110 on your order!
Layla Mattress
Layla Mattress

A flippable design makes the Layla mattress a truly customizable bedroom accessory. Get $110 off your purchase using code SLEEPOPOLIS.

Best for Side Sleepers

The Nolah Signature Mattress

Nolah Mattress

Built with the brand’s gentle Air Foam, the Nolah mattress is a super soft bed designed with side sleepers in mind. As these lateral recumbent dreamers sink into the plush, three-foam structure, they’re likely to experience a ton of pressure relief and sinkage as the materials contour to their shoulders and hips.

Another big plus of Air Foam is that it features a lot of the same body-contouring principles of memory foam without the heat retention, ensuring that you’ll sleep cool throughout the night.

Price: $949 for a Queen.

Helpful Links: Read more about the Nolah mattress at my full review.

Nolah Mattress
Nolah Mattress

A soft, supportive construction makes the Nolah mattress especially good for side sleepers. Enjoy $135 off your purchase now! 

Best Hybrid Mattress

A queen size version of the Helix Midnight mattress on the bed frame from Article furniture

Helix Midnight

If you are unfamiliar with hybrid mattresses they use a mix of foam and pocketed coils to provide support and pressure relief. In the case of the Helix Midnight there is a thick layer of memory foam on top that allows sleepers to sink in for a great contouring feel that I really like for side sleepers. The pocketed coils below provide some nice support as well as great bounce so you won’t feel stuck while changing positions. So the Helix Midnight makes this list as because of its ability to provide great comfort with support thanks to its hybrid build.

Head over to my full Helix mattress review for more information.

Save $125!
Helix Midnight Mattress
Helix Midnight Mattress

If you're a side sleeper looking for a hybrid mattress, the Helix Midnight offers a great mix of support and pressure relief! Enjoy $75 off the standard Helix mattress and $125 off the Helix Luxe mattress by using our exclusive discount codes!

Best Mattress for Back Pain

Resting on the Birch mattress

Birch

The Birch is a latex hybrid that uses natural materials to provide comfort. The talalay latex comfort layer and organic cotton cover combine to make an organic mattress that has a ton of bounce, so combo sleepers won’t feel stuck when changing positions.

Another benefit of the durable latex and pocketed coil structure is the strong support the Birch provides for back and stomach sleepers. This bed does a great job of keeping your hips from sinking into the mattress, aligning your spine in a good position throughout the night so you don’t wake up with aches and pains in your lower back in the morning.

Learn more in my full review of the Birch mattress

Birch Mattress
Birch Mattress

The Birch mattress uses natural materials like organic cotton and talalay latex to provide great comfort from an organic product, in fact all Birch products are Greenguard Gold certified! Use code SLEEPOPOLIS200 for $200 off the mattress.

Best for Heavy Sleepers

The WinkBed Mattress

Winkbeds Plus Mattress

Heavier sleepers on the prowl for a bargain should check out the WinkBeds Plus. Outfitted with high-density poly foam, bouncy latex, and pocketed coils, this mattress is built with optimized support in mind. While obviously anyone (regardless of size) can buy this bed, the brand did specifically design it for heavier folks who tend to sink straight through other mattresses.

To that end, the bed also features a layer of foam edge support, which wraps around the mattress to maximize its usable surface area. All these materials combined create an incredibly durable structure that should last for a long time.

Price: $1,799 for a Queen.

Helpful Links: Check out my full review of the WinkBeds Plus.

Save $200!
WinkBeds Plus Mattress
WinkBeds Plus Mattress

The WinkBeds Plus was designed to be bouncy, cooling, and particularly supportive for heavier sleepers! Save $200 on your order with our exclusive discount code SLEEPOPOLIS200!

Best Innerspring

Saatva Mattress

The Saatva evokes the feel of a classic innerspring with its coil-on-coil construction. This means it’s bouncy, supportive, and firm, scoring about a 7.5/10 on the firmness scale. In my opinion, the coils used here are super solid, making for a durable structure that’s likely to last long after you purchase it.

Additional value comes with Saatva’s awesome 15-year warranty, which basically extends the life of your bed beyond what other brands can offer. It’s a fantastic deal and one you should definitely consider if you like the buoyant lift of a traditional innerspring mattress.

Price: $1,099 for a Queen.

Helpful Links: Learn more by reading my full Saatva review.

Save $75
Saatva Mattress
Saatva Mattress

The Saatva mattress combines a luxurious pillow-top layer with two sections of coils for that classic innerspring feel. Save $75 with the Sleepopolis discount!

Best Cooling Mattress

Tuft & Needle

The Tuft & Needle is a no-frills option ideal for those on a budget. Featuring a straightforward, two-layer design, this mattress is surprisingly firm and bouncy, deriving most of its comfort from the brand’s buoyant proprietary foam.

I especially like the T&N for its cooling capabilities, which come from a breathable cover and airy top layer of foam. This combination of materials helps to safeguard against overheating and keep things nice and regulated throughout the night.

Price: $575 for a Queen.

Helpful Links: Scope out my full review of the Tuft & Needle Mattress and see my comparison between the Original T&N and the T&N Mint.

Check Prices Here
Tuft and Needle Mattress
Tuft and Needle Mattress

The Tuft & Needle mattress comes in at an incredibly affordable price, with some great cooling features built into their proprietary foam design. Also check out the Tuft & Needle mint for a more luxury mattress at a great value.

Best Mattress for Pressure Relief

Nectar

Built with a thick top section of memory foam, the Nectar mattress is a great value option for those in search of deep body contouring and pressure relief. Side sleepers in particular could find a lot to love in this mattress as it actively works to alleviate tension at the shoulders, hips, and lower back.

However, it’s Nectar’s trial period and warranty that landed it a spot on this list. Not only can you try out the Nectar mattress for a full year (a rarity in the bed-in-a-box market), but you can also rest easy knowing it’s comfort is guaranteed for life. Now if that doesn’t spell value, I’m not sure what does.

Price: $699 for a Queen.

Helpful links: Read my full review of the Nectar mattress. You can also check out my Nectar vs. Purple and Nectar vs Tuft & Needle comparisons.

Click for Current Offer
Nectar Mattress
Nectar Mattress

Nectar is one of the most popular mattresses online for a reason - it's an incredible memory foam mattress at a very affordable price. It's actually priced significantly below most of the other bed-in-a-box mattresses as well. Nectar is definitely worth a look if you're shopping on a budget but still want a high quality sleep experience!

Best Value Mattress

Allswell Mattress

If you’re on a budget but in desperate need of a new mattress then I think the Allswell should definitely be on your list. It uses a nice quilted cover to provide some cushiony pressure relief on top of the mattress and combines that with pocketed coils for surprising bounce and support.

Now all of that comfort is great, but what if you can’t afford it? No need to worry about that, the Allswell is one of the least expensive mattresses out there, coming in at a price range of $245 for the twin size version and going up to $420 for the king size mattress!

To get more on the Allswell mattress, take a peek at my full review

Allswell Mattress
Allswell Mattress

Sleepers who want some serious bounce from their mattress will love the buoyant support of the Allswell Mattress!

Methodology

Now that we’ve covered all the mattresses, I want to highlight a few things I look for when deciding if a bed is a true value buy:

  • Warranty – Does the mattress have a solid warranty? If so, you’re likely to get more miles out of it, which extends your purchase far beyond checkout.
  • Quality of Materials – Mattresses built with high-quality materials are going to last longer than those designed with cheaper ones. That’s why it’s crucial to consider whether investing in a slightly more expensive bed is actually going to be more cost-effective in the long run.
  • Value by Category – It’s important to remember that “value” doesn’t always mean “inexpensive.” Sometimes a $2,500 luxury bed has great value when compared to other models in its category. Similarly, a $250 mattress may be a total dud when sized up to other “budget” brands. It’s all about assessing the materials used, the design elements at play, and the rest of the competitors in the space.

What Kind of Mattress Type is the Best Value?

While there isn’t a definitive answer to this, there are a few things that are good to know about each mattress type.

Coil/spring mattresses are the most traditional and feature layers of steel coils that help to provide support to the body. Sometimes, these coils can even be wrapped in foam for added comfort and pressure relief. While innerspring mattresses are typically the least expensive, they can also cause the most restless nights if the coil count is too low or the quality of steel used is poor. Additionally, you’ll need to replace your innerspring mattress every eight years.

Memory foam mattresses are another popular option, especially for those in need of deep pressure relief. These beds are comprised of layers of memory foam that adapt in real time to the curves of your body while you sleep. They’re typically more expensive than innerspring mattresses, though some folks find the added layers of pressure-relieving foam are well worth the price. A good memory foam mattress should last you about 10 years.

Latex foam mattresses are similar to memory foam mattresses in that they’re both made up of foam layers. Unlike memory foam, latex has a quick response to pressure, resulting in a bouncy material designed to keep the sleeper positioned on top of the bed. Latex also happens to sleep a little cooler than memory foam. With this added boots of temperature regulation and lift, you can expect to pay more for a latex bed than a memory foam one; however, it’s important to keep in mind that latex mattresses typically last for up to 12 years.

And finally, hybrid mattresses fall somewhere between memory foam, latex, and innerspring. These beds can make great value buys because they essentially combine all the great elements of the aforementioned mattress types (the pressure relief of memory foam, the bounce of latex, the support of innerspring) into one convenient package. A good hybrid mattress will last you about 10 years.

Pillow-top mattresses can come in many different styles. They are characterized by the plush pillow-top cushion sewn into the top of the mattress and can be applied to innerspring, memory foam, latex, or hybrid mattresses. When considering value, keep in mind that choosing a pillow-top mattress can mean a slightly lower than average life span. The pillow-top portion (especially traditional pillow-tops) tend to be the first to go in terms of long-range performance. The soft, plush top layer can be supportive and comfortable, but when shopping for the best mattress for your money, that shorter lifespan is definitely something to think about.

Do I Have to Buy a Box Spring?

Do I even really need a box spring?” When trying to save money on a new mattress purchase, this question inevitably comes up. After all, the value of a bed greatly increases if you don’t have to immediately purchase a heavy box spring to go with it. In general, box springs are mostly used to provide some extra height and stability to your bed. To know for sure if you need one, make sure to check the warranty — if it’s not required, you may be able to save a few bucks by ditching the platform all together.

SO_BestFortheMoneyGraphics_Boxspring

While you may not need a box spring, you will want some type of foundation. Box springs, wood foundations, minimal metal wire frames, platform beds, steel slat frames, wood slat frames, or adjustable bases can all get the job done equally well. If you do opt for a slat frame, make sure you find one with rigid slats that are no more than 3 to 4 inches apart. These will provide the best support.

How Can I Make My Mattress Last?

One quick way to add instant value to your mattress is to take care of it. From day one, use a high-quality mattress protector. Not only does this safeguard against spills and stains, it can also wards off bed bugs, dust mites, sweat, dirt, and other allergens that might try and make their way into your mattress. Make a point to wash your protector as often as you wash your sheets (at least every one to two weeks, ideally).

SO_BestFortheMoneyGraphics_MattressProtector

Additionally, you’ll want to make sure to spot clean your mattress regularly. Sprinkle it with baking soda and vacuum it for quick odor elimination. Consider bleach or enzymatic cleaners for the harder-to-clean areas. Proper maintenance of your mattress will ensure that you are getting the most for your money and it will last you for years to come.

Final Thoughts

That about does it for this round-up! At the end of the day, “value” is what you make of it, so figure out what’s most important to you in a mattress and go from there — price, like pressure relief, quality of materials, firmness, and support is just one of many factors to consider when making your purchase.

And remember, the longevity of your mattress is ultimately in your hands, so take care of your new bed and it’ll be sure to take care of you right back.

The following two tabs change content below.
Logan Block
Logan is the content director of Sleepopolis, which means he not only reviews new mattresses every week, but also curates all the comparisons, best of pages, and video guides on the site. He takes a straightforward, honest approach to his reviews and endeavors to give viewers an objective look at each new product he tries out. Logan has perfected his method by personally testing over 200 different mattresses, so he’s not only able to discern the overall vibe of a specific bed, but to contextualize its feel within the bed-in-a-box market as a whole. When he’s not hopping on a new bed or working with our editorial team to whip up an engaging sleep education guide, you can find him reading books on world history, walking his dog Pepper, or searching for the best cheeseburger in New York City.
Logan Block

Latest posts by Logan Block (see all)