Down pillows have a cult following in the bedding world. Many people who love this style of pillow can’t fathom the thought of sleeping on anything else. No matter whether you fall into that camp or you’re in the market for your first-ever down pillow, it’s important to do your research, because they can range pretty widely in terms of quality.
To zero in on the best down pillows for your needs, it helps to think about a few factors including your budget, your preferences when it comes to materials (both in terms of pillow fillings and shells), your sleep style (which can influence whether you want a flat or puffy pillow), and so on. Also consider whether it’s important to you to purchase a pillow that’s made from responsibly sourced down. Then, check out our roundup to kick off your search with some stellar options.
Continental Bedding Premium 100% Down Pillows
- The pillow is filled with 550 fill power, 100% white goose down and wrapped in a 400 thread count, 100% Egyptian cotton shell.
- The pillows are sold in a set of two. So even though they have a high price tag, you’re getting more value than a similar price tag for an individual pillow.
- The pillows are soft, fluffy, and lightweight.
- They’re made in the USA and Responsible Down Standard certified.
- The pillows are on the thinner side, so they might not appeal to folks who like a plump, overstuffed pillow.
- The price tag on these puppies is not for the faint of heart!
Responsible Down Certified fill and a 100% Egyptian cotton shell set apart the Continental Bedding Premium 100% Down Pillows. The soft, lightweight pillows are made in the USA.
puredown Natural Goose Down Feather White Pillow Inserts
- The pillows have a 100% cotton shell and are stuffed with 85% goose feather and 15% goose down.
- The double-layered cotton shell and interior polyester layers help protect you from feather pricks.
- The pillows come in a pack of two for a relatively budget-friendly price.
- The pillows are Responsible Down Standard certified.
- Because the pillows are vacuum-packed for shipping, you’ll need to give them 24+ hours to expand before first using them. This time might also be necessary for odors to off-gas.
- The pillows are fairly soft and lightweight. While this might appeal to some people, others will find them to be too flat or not firm enough.
High-quality materials and Responsible Down Standard certification distinguish the puredown Natural Goose Down Feather White Pillow Inserts. The pillows feature multiple layers of fabric around the fill to help protect against feather pricks.
Best Flat Pillow
DOWNLITE Extra Soft Down Pillow
- The pillow is designed specifically for stomach sleepers and is flat to help support healthy neck alignment.
- It’s filled with 525 to 550 fill power white duck down and has a 250 thread count cotton cover, which creates a soft feel.
- It’s machine-washable and dryer-friendly.
- The pillow is assembled in the USA (from imported materials).
- Some users have shared the pillow might shed feathers over time.
- The pillow might have a bit of a smell when it first arrives.
Stomach sleepers should love the DOWNLITE Extra Soft Down Pillow, which has a flat design to promote healthy neck alignment in this position. The pillow is filled with 525 to 550 fill power white duck down and wrapped in a cotton cover.
Best Well-Stuffed Pillow
East Coast Bedding European White Goose Down Pillow
- The pillow is made from high-quality materials including a 400 thread count, 100% cotton shell in a sateen weave and 800 fill power white goose down.
- It’s well-stuffed and does a good job of retaining its shape.
- You can purchase the pillows individually or as a two-pack; the two-pack gives you a slight price break.
- The pillow is made in the USA.
- These are not budget-friendly pillows, and they won’t be accessible for all budgets.
- Because the pillow is well-stuffed, it might be a little puffy for some people’s preferences (especially if you’re a stomach sleeper).
High-quality materials and plenty of stuffing will make the East Coast Bedding European White Goose Down Pillow appeal to anyone who likes their pillow on the puffy side. The pillows are made in the USA and can be purchased individually or as a two-pack.
JA COMFORTS Duck Feather and Down Bed Pillows
- The pillows come in a pack of two, and the pack costs less than many individual down pillows.
- They’re filled with 95% grey duck feather and 5% grey duck down and wrapped in a 100% cotton cover.
- The feathers and down are swaddled in four layers of fabric; this and double-line stitching help protect against leakage.
- They’re machine-washable and dryer-friendly.
- You might have to fluff the pillows regularly to get them to maintain their loft.
- These pillows are relatively soft/flat, so if you like a firm or overstuffed pillow you’ll want to look elsewhere.
You’ll be hard-pressed to find a pack of decent down pillows for a lower price than what you get with the JA COMFORTS Duck Feather and Down Bed Pillows. They’re filled with 95% feathers and 5% down and wrapped in a 100% cotton cover.
How We Picked
There’s a lot of diversity in the world of down pillows. For instance, these pillows can vary a lot based on the materials used in their shells and fillings, the way the down is sourced, the pillows’ loft, and so on. To filter through all the options out there, we focused on the following factors.
Down pillows are generally pricier than other pillows, and they can range widely in price from around $30 for two pillows to nearly $200 for one. That’s a huge range! We included pillows from both sides of the spectrum (and in between), so you can choose according to your budget.
When it comes to pillows, “feel” can refer to both hand feel and what it feels like to lay your head on the pillow. For instance, some shells are soft to the touch, while others are less so. Some pillows are flat, others are super puffy, and still others are somewhere in between. We included pillows that represent the full spectrum of options, so you can tailor your choice to your personal preferences.
Down pillows can be filled with goose down, duck down, goose feathers, duck feathers, or a combination thereof. Meanwhile, their shells can be made from cotton, polyester, or other materials. The materials used in a down pillow will affect its hand feel, loft, and so on. We included a variety of options so you can choose what suits you best.
Whenever possible, we looked for options that are Responsible Down Standard certified, which helps ensure that down is sourced ethically from the animals who supply it. While every option on this list doesn’t meet this standard, our top choices do.
Sleepopolis Buying Tips
Ready to land the best down pillow for your needs? Consider the following:
- Is ethical sourcing important to you? Then look for options that are Responsible Down Standard certified. This is a quick way to rule out a lot of contenders.
- What are your preferences for materials? Do you want an Egyptian cotton shell, or does the shell’s material not matter to you? Are you comfortable with a combination of feathers and down, or do you prefer one or the other? Do you care whether a pillow is filled with goose or duck down? Answering these questions is an effective way to whittle down your choices.
- What’s your budget? Because down pillows can range wildly in price, clarifying your budget can help shrink the list of options. You should be able to find a decent pillow for anywhere from around $30 to around $200.
For lovers of down pillows, nothing else will suffice. To find the best one for you, think about your budget alongside your preferences when it comes to materials, loft, ethics, and so on. Then get yourself a great pillowcase and prepare to enjoy the sleep of your dreams!
Logan is the content director of Sleepopolis, which means he not only reviews new mattresses every week, but also curates all the comparisons, best of pages, and video guides on the site. He takes a straightforward, honest approach to his reviews and endeavors to give viewers an objective look at each new product he tries out. Logan has perfected his method by personally testing over 200 different mattresses, so he’s not only able to discern the overall vibe of a specific bed, but to contextualize its feel within the bed-in-a-box market as a whole.