Best Mattress Protectors

We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

Accidents happen, and one way to prevent them in the world of bedding is by using one of the best mattress protectors. With the right product, your bed will be safe from contaminants of all kinds. 

Our team at Sleepopolis specializes in informing our audience about the most high-quality, reliable products in the mattress industry. After testing numerous products and examining many different models, we compiled a list of 10 options to help you find the best mattress protector for your needs.

The Best Mattress Protectors

Our Methodology

Before we go more into depth about these mattress protectors, we’d like to share a bit about the process we used to select them. 

Here at Sleepopolis, we’ve reviewed hundreds of products in our mattress lab, running each one through tests depending on the product type. 

Since we wanted our roundup of the Best Mattress Protectors to truly represent the best of the best, we took the quality of materials and special features into account. All of these mattress protectors are high-caliber products using materials that last. Many are waterproof, some specialize in cooling, and others are eco-friendly. Each offers something different, but one thing’s the same: they’re products we believe in. Click here to learn more about our methodology.

Best Overall

Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector

When searching for the best mattress protector, you’ll need something that prevents the contaminants you want to avoid. Bonus points for comfort, cooling ability, and waterproofing. Luckily, the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector succeeds at all of this. You can rest assured that your mattress is protected, especially with its hypoallergenic design.

Why We Love This Protector

  • This luxury product uses soft fabric to give your mattress protector a silky feel.
  • Brooklyn Bedding incorporates a cooling material to assist with heat dissipation.
  • To make things even better, this protector is washable.

Price: $99–$149 with a 30-night trial and 3-year warranty. 

Our full review for the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector is coming soon!

Pair what we believe to be the best mattress protector with one of the best mattresses on the market.

Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector
Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector
Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector

The Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector surpasses our expectations for a comfortable, cooling, and waterproof protector.

Best Waterproof

Helix Waterproof Mattress Protector

There are a number of reasons why it’s better to have a waterproof mattress protector, but above all else, it’s best to be prepared. The Helix Waterproof Mattress Protector should fulfill all of your waterproofing needs. This product is marketed as completely waterproof and anti-microbial, so you shouldn’t have to worry about fluids, bacteria, and other contaminants dirtying your mattress.

Why We Love This Protector

  • It’s designed to promote airflow rather than trapping heat in your mattress like some protectors.
  • Helix constructed this protector to be soft and noiseless, so you don’t sacrifice comfort and quiet.
  • Helix offers free US shipping.

Price: $75–$99 with a 100-night trial and 1-year warranty. 

Our full review for the Helix Waterproof Mattress Protector is coming soon!

Helix Waterproof Mattress Protector
Helix Waterproof Mattress Protector
Helix Waterproof Mattress Protector

The Helix Waterproof Mattress Protector is marketed as completely waterproof and anti-microbial, so you shouldn’t have to worry about fluids, bacteria, and other contaminants dirtying your mattress.

Best for Kids

Saatva Mattress Protector

The Saatva Mattress Protector will have you covered for potty training, spilled juice, and everything in between. It has a waterproof barrier to combat all sorts of liquids. If your child likes to toss and turn while sleeping, don’t worry; the elastic bands attached to this protector prevent it from slipping.

Why We Love This Protector

  • Your child is safe from harmful chemicals; this protector includes organic cotton that’s Fair Trade Certified.
  • The breathable cotton cover should prevent your child from overheating at night.
  • It fits mattresses with deep pockets, up to 16” high.

Price: $95–$195 with a 45-night trial and 1-year limited warranty.

Our full review for the Saatva Mattress Protector is coming soon!

Consider purchasing one of the best mattresses for kids along with your brand new mattress protector.

Saatva Mattress Protector
Saatva Mattress Protector
Saatva Mattress Protector

The Saatva Mattress Protector has a waterproof barrier to combat all sorts of liquids. The elastic bands attached to this protector prevent it from slipping.

Best Online

DreamCloud Mattress Protector

The DreamCloud Mattress Protector is a high-quality product that ships to your house in 2–5 business days with the push of a button. It sure beats running from store to store to find the best option! Plus, you can enjoy free shipping and free returns. Top it off with a generous sleep trial and warranty, and you’ve got yourself the best online mattress protector.

Why We Love This Protector

  • DreamCloud markets their protector as 100% waterproof.
  • It fits snugly on your mattress, so your mattress will stay clean and comfortable.
  • With unquilted material on the sides and the incorporation of breathable cotton, hot sleepers should be satisfied.

Price: $89–$109 with a 50-night trial and 5-year warranty. 

Our full review for the DreamCloud Mattress Protector is coming soon!

For more of the Internet’s finest sleep products, check out our roundup for the best online mattresses.

DreamCloud Mattress Protector
DreamCloud Mattress Protector
DreamCloud Mattress Protector

With unquilted material on the sides and the incorporation of breathable cotton, hot sleepers should be satisfied with the DreamCloud Mattress Protector. 

Nolah

Nolah Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Protector

Eco-conscious shoppers are bound to fall in love with the Nolah Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Protector. The materials are Forest Stewardship Council and Oeko-Tex 100 certified, so you won’t have to worry about harmful chemicals. Its cover is made of naturally antibacterial bamboo.

Why We Love This Protector

  • The bamboo in the soft cover is naturally cooling and moisture-wicking.
  • Its bamboo cover and TPU underlayer results in a waterproof surface to protect against accidental spills. We tested this in our mattress lab and found it’s waterproof, as advertised!
  • This protector is soft and stretchy, so it fits snugly to mattresses up to 15” tall.

Price: $99–$129 with a 120-night trial and 10-year warranty. 

Our full review for the Nolah Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Protector is coming soon!

Try pairing this eco-friendly protector with one of the best organic mattresses.

Nolah Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Protector
Nolah Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Protector
Nolah Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Protector

Eco-conscious shoppers are bound to fall in love with the Nolah Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Protector. The materials are Forest Stewardship Council and Oeko-Tex 100 certified, so you won’t have to worry about harmful chemicals.

Best for Stains

Bear Mattress Protector

With the Bear Mattress Protector’s strong waterproof barrier, you shouldn’t have to worry about even the toughest stains. We conducted two separate stain and spill tests on this product, and each time, there was zero sign of permanent color retention or staining after washing. While testing, we also found this protector to be waterproof, as advertised.

Why We Love This Protector

  • Its thicker top is great for protecting your bed against allergens and other contaminants.
  • We found this soft protector to be virtually silent, so you won’t have to worry about a plastic crinkling noise waking you up at night.
  • Despite its thicker material, this mattress protector is still breathable.

Price: $75–$125 with a 120-night trial and lifetime warranty. 

Read our full Bear Mattress Protector review.

Bear Mattress Protector
Bear Mattress Protector
Bear Mattress Protector

With the Bear Mattress Protector’s strong waterproof barrier, you shouldn’t have to worry about even the toughest stains.

Best Cooling

Layla Mattress Protector

Mattress protectors can be useful for many things, but the wrong materials can trap heat and become uncomfortable for hot sleepers. The Layla Cooling Mattress Protector is woven with fibers designed to keep you and your mattress cool. It also provides liquid protection, so this is an excellent option for waterproofing.

Why We Love This Protector

  • Layla’s signature hexagonal stitching provides luxury comfort.
  • This protector is machine-washable and dryable.
  • Elastic straps are attached to this protector, securing it to your mattress.

Price: $144–$204 with a 30-night trial and a 1-year warranty. 

Our full review for the Layla Cooling Mattress Protector is coming soon!

Hot sleepers can find even cooler possibilities with the best cooling mattress.

Layla Mattress Protector
Layla Mattress Protector
Layla Mattress Protector

The Layla Cooling Mattress Protector is woven with fibers designed to keep you and your mattress cool. It also provides liquid protection, so this is an excellent option for waterproofing.

Best for Allergies

Purple Mattress Protector

The Purple Mattress Protector is able to keep all sorts of allergens and contaminants from getting to your mattress. This product hugs mattresses tightly and is backed by 100% polyurethane. The elastic bands strapped to your mattress and five-sided protection add to our confidence that the Purple Mattress Protector is a wonderful option for allergy sufferers.

Why We Love This Protector

  • With a thin design, this protector should work well for hot sleepers.
  • While testing, we found liquids didn’t penetrate the Purple Mattress Protector.
  • The elasticity and strong build should make this product a durable option.

Price: $79–$158 with a 30-night trial and 10-year warranty. 

Read our full Purple Mattress Protector review.

Purple Mattress Protector
Purple Mattress Protector
Purple Mattress Protector

Most Comfortable

Lucid Cotton Terry Mattress Protector

The wrong mattress protector can feel and sound plasticky to the point where it disrupts your rest. This shouldn’t be a concern for the Lucid Cotton Terry Mattress Protector; it’s constructed into two parts. One of these parts is designed for comfort; the cotton terry top provides a bit of cushioning to your mattress protector. The other is designed to keep contaminants out of your mattress.

Why We Love This Protector

  • After both of our liquid spill tests, the Lucid Mattress Protector looks as good as new after one wash cycle.
  • The polyurethane material used to protect your mattress is breathable.
  • This protector is priced under $25 for a Queen before sales or discounts. This is an excellent value!

Price: $18–$26 with a 365-night trial. 

Read our full Lucid Cotton Terry Mattress Protector review.

To elevate your comfort to the highest level, use this protector with one of the most comfortable mattresses.

Lucid Cotton Terry Mattress Protector
Lucid Cotton Terry Mattress Protector
Lucid Cotton Terry Mattress Protector

The Lucid Cotton Terry Mattress Protector is constructed into two parts. One of these parts is designed for comfort; the cotton terry top provides a bit of cushioning to your mattress protector. The other is designed to keep contaminants out of your mattress.

Best for Deep Mattresses

Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector

The Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress fits Twin-size beds to California King. Even more impressive is its ability to secure onto mattresses up to 18” deep. The ultra-deep pockets ensure fuller coverage for taller mattresses, so they’re better protected from contaminants. Note that while this feature is unique and helpful for deep pockets, it may not work if you desire a super-snug fit for a standard mattress.

Why We Love This Protector

  • The Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector is machine washable.
  • After our spill tests, no signs of color retention or staining were observed upon the first wash cycle.
  • It’s one of the most cooling protectors we’ve tested in our lab.

Price: $71–$107 with a 30-night trial and 30-day warranty. 

Read our full Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector review.

Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector
Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector
Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress Protector

The Nest Bedding Cooling Mattress has ultra-deep pockets that ensure fuller coverage for taller mattresses, so they’re better protected from contaminants.

Mattress Protector vs Pad vs Topper

The difference between protectors, pads, and toppers is a bit tricky, because these accessories can overlap in a few ways. Toppers change a mattress’ firmness and make a surface softer or firmer. Pads are thinner than toppers, but are still used for smaller changes in firmness. They can have protective features, resembling that of a mattress protector. Mattress protectors, on the other hand, aren’t used as comfort layers but as defensive layers. These accessories protect your mattress from spills, allergens, dust mites, bed bugs, and other contaminants. 

Types of Mattress Protectors

Fitted 

These protectors are often five-sided and include pocketed corners to tuck under your mattress. This works similarly to a fitted sheet.

Elastic 

These protectors are often five-sided and include elastic straps that securely fit around your mattress. It prevents the protector from slipping around on the mattress. 

Encasement-style

These are uniquely six-sided, so all of your mattress is protected. You can secure these to your mattress with a zipper. Because it’s six-sided, it provides ultimate mattress protection. Unfortunately, this does make it more difficult to remove for washing.

Mattress Protector Considerations

Materials

Cotton, polyester, down, and polyurethane are some of the most commonly found materials in mattress protectors. Some are used for thinner comfort layers, which decreases the plasticky noise that some mattress protectors have. For waterproofing, polyurethane is extremely popular. 

Waterproof

Consider whether waterproofing is an important aspect for you. If you have children, sleep with a pet, or just want extra protection for any circumstance, then a waterproof protector is a wise investment. Many of the models in this roundup are built to prevent liquids from penetrating the mattress protector, and consequently your mattress.

Read: How to Clean Urine Out of a Mattress

Cooling Ability

If you’re a particularly hot sleeper, a breathable or cooling mattress protector is something you’ll want to search for. Sometimes, accessory materials found in toppers, pads, and even protectors can trap additional heat. Look for thinner mattress protectors or models marketing breathable and cooling features! Cotton, bamboo, latex, and polyurethane are all known to be cooling materials.

Dimensions

Size of Mattress Protector

Consider what size bed you’re using your mattress protector for. Often, companies make protectors able to fit Twins to California Kings. However, some companies make protectors for cribs or even RV mattresses.

Depth of Mattress Protector

You’ll also want to check the height of your mattress to make sure that the mattress protector fits it properly. If you have a particularly tall mattress, look for a deep pocketed protector that provides full coverage. 

Overall Fit

Make sure to find a mattress protector that fits snugly to your mattress. Elastic straps and fitted mattress protectors might use a stretchy material to help with this. A product that hugs the mattress well makes it less likely that contaminants will penetrate the surface. 

Read: Mattress Sizes and Bed Dimensions

Mattress Protector Benefits

Protection From Contaminants

Whether you’re looking to protect your bed from dust mites, bed bugs, allergens, dirt, spills, stains, or other contaminants, a mattress protector has your back. Often, certain mattress protectors excel at shielding your bed for particular circumstances. For instance, many protectors are made specifically for waterproofing, while others specialize in bed bug defense.

Helps Allergies

If you’re waking up feeling stuffy from allergies, try investing in a mattress protector. It’s almost too easy for allergens to collect on a mattress, but it’s extremely difficult to deep-clean a bed and remove them. A mattress protector is easy to put on and take off, and it’s far easier to wash. It’s not too late if your mattress already has allergens, though; a mattress protector creates a barrier between you and the mattress, separating you from allergens.

Tip: Wash your mattress protector at least once a month during allergy season to avoid allergy symptoms. 

Prevents Bed Bugs

Encasement-style protectors in particular are especially effective at protecting against bed bugs, because these protectors encompass the entire mattress. A zipper secures these protectors and makes the protector impenetrable. Some mattress protectors are constructed specifically for combating bed bugs. These might be worth looking into if you’re contending with infestations.

Read: How to Get Rid of Bed Bugs in 3 Easy Steps

Increases Mattress Durability

With less dirt and spillage collecting on a mattress overtime, its lifespan is prolonged. This is incredibly cost effective. Instead of investing in a new mattress because it has too many new stains, you can simply replace the mattress protector (far cheaper than shelling out $1,000+ on a mattress). 

Read: Best Mattresses That Won’t Sag

Mattress Protector Disadvantages

Noise and Discomfort

Many mattress protectors have plasticky material that causes a rustling sound when you move on the mattress. Luckily, many companies create a soft padding on their protectors to prevent this. That said, some models don’t take preventative measures when it comes to noise, so be on the lookout.

How to Care for Your Mattress Protector

How Often to Wash

We recommend washing your mattress protector every two months to clean off the contaminants it collects overtime. If you have allergy issues (or if it’s peak allergy season), it’s worth washing twice a month or as often as needed for your comfort. 

How to Wash

Fortunately, most mattress protectors are machine-washable. However, it’s always a good idea to check with the manufacturer if you’re not 100% sure. The manufacturer can also specify whether the protector should be washed with cold or warm water, and if the mattress protector is dryable. 

Purchasing Your Mattress Protector

Average Cost

We don’t recommend spending less than $25 or spending more than $150 for a Queen-size mattress protector. The cheapest options may not provide sufficient durability and may not include or deliver special features like cooling or waterproofing. On the other hand, super-luxury protectors may not provide any more than a reasonably-priced mattress protector would.

Read: Best Cheap Mattresses

Exclusive Coupons

Our team at Sleepopolis displays top deals on our coupon page

When to Buy

For accessories and mattresses alike, the best times to buy typically lie around national holidays. To secure the best deals, we suggest checking out mattress protectors around President’s Day, Memorial Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving/Cyber 5, and Christmas.

Warranty and Sleep Trial

In this roundup, we included the lengths of company sleep trials and warranties. This information tells the customer a lot about 1) how much time they have to test out a company’s product and 2) how much confidence a company has about the quality of their mattress protector.

Warranties protect the customer from paying for a damaged or defective product. Keep in mind that every company’s policy is different, so it’s crucial to read the fine print on warranties. That way, you’ll know what conditions to expect.

Sleep trials are an allotment of time in which the customer can test out the product. Longer sleep trials are better, of course. They allow more time to determine whether or not the mattress truly fits their needs.

Read: Our Complete Mattress Guide

FAQ

Which type of mattress protector is best?

The best mattress protector is the one that most closely aligns with your needs and preferences. If we had to choose, however, we’d go with the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector. It provides comfort, cooling, and waterproofing for a value price.

Do mattress protectors make a difference?

Absolutely! Mattress protectors defend your mattress from contaminants and ultimately extend the mattress’s lifespan. This makes them an invaluable investment.

Can you still get bed bugs with a mattress protector?

Yes, you can, if it’s a five-sided protector. Encasement protectors, on the other hand, entirely cover the mattress. This makes them far more effective in starving bed bugs. That said, it’s still worth investing in a protector marketed specifically for eliminating bed bugs if you find yourself having serious bug bed issues.

Do waterproof mattress protectors make you hot?

The plastic waterproofing materials used in mattress protectors can trap heat and cause you to become sweaty. However, not all waterproofing mattresses are bad for hot sleepers. Many companies created waterproof constructions that are also breathable. Several of these can be found in this very roundup!

Do you put sheets on top of your mattress protector?

Yes! Sheets go over the mattress protector. Many put mattress toppers between mattress protectors and sheets for added comfort.

Avatar

Lauren Hapgood

Lauren is on the editorial team and is a Certified Sleep Coach at Sleepopolis, where she researches the best mattresses for all types of sleepers. She earned her bachelor’s degree in Creative Writing from the University of Washington. When Lauren isn’t keeping readers updated on the best sleep products, you can find her playing guitar, going for a run, or reading classic novels.