Down comforters share a lot of similarities — and plenty of differences. Any down comforter worth its salt will be filled with down and/or feathers. It should be fluffy, cozy, and provide extra warmth for your bed. Beyond these similarities, down comforters can vary in terms of their materials, weight, and how much warmth they offer. They might also differ in size, fill power, and the ways they’re sewn.
So how the heck do you find the right down comforter for you? Start by considering your budget, climate, comfort preferences, and functional needs (such as whether you need a comforter with loops to attach to a duvet cover). Then consult our list of best down comforters to zero in on some high-quality options.
Editor’s Choice
BALICHUN Premium Goose Down Comforter
Pros:
- The materials are high-quality: The cover is made from 100% cotton, and the fill is 80% goose down and 20% fine feathers.
- The box stitch design helps hold the fill in place and prevent feather leakage.
- If you want to use a duvet cover with this comforter, it has eight side and corner loops to ensure a secure fit.
- This is a medium-weight comforter, so it shouldn’t sleep too hot.
Cons:
- This is not a budget-friendly comforter, and it’s not accessible for all price points.
- The comforter can’t be dry cleaned, and the manufacturers say it shouldn’t be washed more often than every five years. So this pretty much requires you to use a duvet cover.
High-quality materials and a thoughtful design earn the BALICHUN Premium Goose Down Comforter the title of Editor’s Choice. The medium-weight comforter should sleep comfortably year round.
Contender
Egyptian Bedding Luxurious Goose Down Comforter
Pros:
- The comforter is made from high-quality materials: The cover is 1,200 thread count, 100% Egyptian cotton, and it’s filled with 750+ fill power, 100% goose down.
- The baffle box design holds the filling in place while promoting a high loft.
- If you want to use a duvet cover, the comforter comes with loops to help secure it within the cover.
Cons:
- This is a pricey option. It’s definitely not a budget-friendly down comforter.
- This is a very warm comforter, so it might not be ideal for sleeping in warmer temps.
A baffle box design and 750+ fill power ensure a high loft from the Egyptian Bedding Luxurious Goose Down Comforter. Built-in loops make it easy to secure a duvet cover.
Best Siberian Goose Down
Egyptian Bedding Siberian Goose Down Comforter
Pros:
- The cover is 1,200 thread count, 100% Egyptian cotton, and it’s filled with 750+ fill power, 100% goose down.
- The box stitch helps hold the fill in place, while double-stitching helps prevent leaks.
- This is a medium-weight comforter that should be appropriate for all-season use.
- The comforter features corner tabs and loops to hold a duvet cover securely in place.
Cons:
- This is not a budget-friendly comforter. It’s definitely on the pricier side.
- The comforter makes some noise when you shift it around, which might annoy some people.
The all-season Egyptian Bedding Siberian Goose Down Comforter features box stitching and quality materials. Loops and tabs ensure that a duvet cover fits snugly.
Best Bargain
Decroom 100% Cotton Quilted Down Comforter
Pros:
- You’ll be hard-pressed to find a down comforter for a lower price.
- The comforter is light- to mid-weight, so it should keep you warm without overheating.
- The cover is made from 100% cotton, and it’s filled with a blend of down and feathers. Box stitching helps prevent this fill from shifting around.
- The comforter is available in several sizes, including California King and Oversize King. You should be able to find the perfect fit for your mattress.
Cons:
- This is a budget down comforter, so it’s a little light on fill. If you like your comforter ultra-fluffy, you’ll probably need to go up a bit in price.
- The fabric is on the stiff side, so it makes some sound when you move around. Some people might find this irritating.
The budget-friendly Decroom 100% Cotton Quilted Down Comforter offers the comfort of down at a bargain price. Box stitching helps prevent the fill from shifting around.
Bargain Contender
WhatsBedding 100% Cotton Down Comforter
Pros:
- This is a very budget-friendly down comforter.
- Corner loops help hold a duvet cover in place if you choose to cover the comforter.
- Box stitching helps prevent fill from shifting all over the place.
- The cover is 100% cotton, and the comforter is hypoallergenic.
Cons:
- This is a pretty lightweight comforter, so it might not be warm enough for extra chilly temps.
- Some users have reported that the comforter has a strong odor when it first arrives. This odor should dissipate over time.
Thoughtful design features belie the low cost of the WhatsBedding 100% Cotton Down Comforter. Box stitching, corner loops, and a 100% cotton cover are among its standout features.
How We Picked
There are a bunch of down alternative comforters masquerading as down comforters, so our first goal was to make sure we featured options that are truly made from real down. Once we weeded out the fakers, we focused on the following factors.
Comfort
Comforters are supposed to be comfortable and comforting, so this was front of mind as we vetted different options. The comforters on this list should be soft, cozy, and pleasant to sleep under.
Comfort can also refer to temperature. Because your climate and sleeping preferences may vary, we included both heavyweight and lightweight comforters on this list so you can tailor your choice to your needs.
Cost
Down comforters are generally pricier than down alternative options, but it’s still possible to find a good deal. The options on this list range from approximately $60 to approximately $150. Our goal was to source options that are accessible to a range of budgets.
Materials
We prioritized comforters made with high-quality materials, such as 100% cotton covers and 100% goose down fill. You’ll find very little polyester on this list!
Sleepopolis Buying Tips
Hunting for a down comforter? Ask yourself the following to find the best down comforter for your needs:
- What’s your climate? Do you need an extra-warm comforter to keep you cozy in freezing temperatures, or do you want a comforter that won’t make you hot in warmer temps? This will help you determine whether you want a lighter or heavier weight comforter.
- Will you be using a duvet cover? If so, then you’ll definitely want to look for a down comforter that features loops and/or tabs to help secure it to a duvet cover. If you know that you won’t use a duvet cover, this doesn’t need to factor into your buying decisions.
- What’s your budget? Clarifying your budget will help you filter out a lot of options. Expect to pay anywhere from around $60 to over $150 for a down comforter, and budget accordingly.
By considering your climate, budget, and functional needs, you’ll increase your odds of finding the right down comforter for you. And once you do, get ready to enjoy some seriously cozy comfort.
