Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets Review

We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

Have you been on the hunt for a new set of sheets? Let me introduce you to the Classic Core sheets from Brooklinen. These percale sheets are Brooklinen’s original sheet set and have received much acclaim, so I’m excited to put them to the test and find out if they live up to the hype.

I’ll go over how they feel and what they’re made of, as well as offer my own opinions on these sheets based on my personal experience testing them. If you just want the short version, you can skip to the end for a review summary.

Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets
Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets
Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets

Woven with long-staple cotton, these Brooklinen Classic Core sheets are both soft and comfortable with a crisp feel like a luxury brand and a more reasonable price. Enjoy 10 percent off your order with code SLEEPOPOLIS10!

What are the Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets Made Of? 

There are a lot of different sheet materials out there, from cotton to bamboo to linen. Each material comes with its own unique feel, as well its own pros and cons.

The Brooklinen Classic Core sheet set is made from 100 percent long-staple cotton in a percale weave. A percale weave uses a one over one under weave, which creates a lightweight, airy, and crisp feel. These sheets have a 270-thread count, which is a good thread count range for percale sheets

To learn more about percale sheets, see our best percale sheets roundup.

Additionally these sheets are OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 certified to be free from harmful chemicals.

Each Classic Core sheet set comes with one fitted sheet, one flat sheet, and two pillowcases. The fitted sheet features tags on the long and short sides to simplify the process of making your bed. Brooklinen also sells a few other bedding bundles for the Classic percale sheets, including:

  • The Starter Set (one fitted sheet and two pillowcases)
  • The Split King Set (two fitted sheets, one flat sheet, and two pillowcases)
  • The Hardcore Set (one fitted sheet, one flat sheet, four pillowcases, and one duvet cover)
  • The Move-In Set (one fitted sheet, one flat sheet, four pillowcases, one duvet cover, two pillows, and one comforter)

The Classic Core set is available in six different sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king. I tested the queen size set for this review.

What Do the Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets Feel Like? 

I thought the Brooklinen Classic Core percale sheets had a very… classic percale feel! Percale is known for its crisp and lightweight feel, and I thought these sheets fit that vibe exactly. They feel structured, but also still soft and buttery. They feel crisp, but not scratchy.

The percale weave gives these sheets a matte finish. I did notice them wrinkle fairly easily as I tested them, as well as being a bit crinkly.

Are the Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets Good for Hot Sleepers?

If you’re a hot sleeper, having sheets that keep you cool is essential. Fortunately, these cotton percale sheets are fantastic for hot sleepers. Being a percale weave, these sheets are lightweight and breathable, allowing for air to flow freely and preventing heat from being trapped. Cotton sheets are also a great pick for hot sleepers, as cotton is a naturally breathable material. 

For more cooling sheets options, check out our best cooling sheets for hot sleepers.

Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets
Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets
Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets

Woven with long-staple cotton, these Brooklinen Classic Core sheets are both soft and comfortable with a crisp feel like a luxury brand and a more reasonable price. Enjoy 10 percent off your order with code SLEEPOPOLIS10!

How Durable are Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets?

The Brooklinen Classic Core sheets feel like high-quality sheets to me. I feel especially confident in their durability, thanks to the use of long-staple cotton fibers. Long staples are less likely to pill and maintain a smooth texture in the sheet over time.

In order to maintain the best quality for your sheets over time, be sure to follow the proper care instructions provided by Brooklinen.

Do the Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets Stay on the Bed?

I had no issue with the Brooklinen Classic Core sheets staying on the bed. The pockets of the fitted sheet are 15 inches, which is a good size but not especially large. If you have a particularly tall mattress or a mattress topper, you may want a fitted sheet with extra deep pockets.

Are Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets Good for You? 

Now that we’ve covered the materials and feel of these sheets, let’s go over my recommendations for who should try them, as well as some complaints.

Who should try Brooklinen Classic Core sheets

  • If you are a hot sleeper,  I think you’ll love the light and breathable feel of the Classic Core sheets.
  • If you prefer a crisp feel from your sheets, the Classic Core should be right up your alley. They feel pleasantly crisp, but not at all scratchy.
  • If you like bold colors or prints for your bedding, you’ll appreciate the variety of colors and patterns Brooklinen offers these sheets in.

Brooklinen Classic Core sheets complaints

  • If you are bothered by crinkling sheets, you might not love the feel or sound of this crispy percale sheet set. For a smoother option, check out the Brooklinen Luxe Core sheets.
  • Similarly, if you like a wrinkle-free sheet, these may not be the best fit. I found they wrinkled easily, and while you can iron them, that may not be appealing to more low-maintenance folks.
  • If you want a moisture-wicking sheet, these may not be the best choice. While percale cotton is great for breathability, cotton absorbs moisture rather than wicking it away.

Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets Prices, Sizes, and Colors

Curious how much these sheets cost? Here’s a breakdown of the prices, by size.

Price listed will be before discount or offer for each size. To get our best deal, click one of the coupons throughout this article.

Size Flat Sheet (Inches) Fitted Sheet (Inches) Pillowcase (Inches) Price
Twin 71” x 98” 39” x 75” x 15” 20” x 27” $139
Twin XL 71” x 104” 39” x 80” x 15” 20” x 27” $139
Full 86” x 98” 54” x 75” x 15” 20” x 27” $149
Queen 92” x 104” 60” x 80” x 15” 20” x 27” $169
King 110” x 104” 76” x 80” x 15” 20” x 37” $189
California King 110” x 104” 72” x 84” x 15” 20” x 37” $209
Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets
Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets
Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets

Woven with long-staple cotton, these Brooklinen Classic Core sheets are both soft and comfortable with a crisp feel like a luxury brand and a more reasonable price. Enjoy 10 percent off your order with code SLEEPOPOLIS10!

Color can be an important factor when choosing a bedding set. Fortunately, Brooklinen offers their sheets in a wide variety of colors and patterns. The Classic Core sheets are always available in some key neutrals, called “Essentials,” including:

  • Solid white
  • Graphite
  • Cream
  • Window pane
  • Graphite and steel oxford stripe

However, they also offer limited edition colors and prints. As of the writing of this article, the “Limited Edition” colors and patterns include:

  • Dusk blue
  • Macadamia tan
  • Sienna
  • Musical spheres
  • Warm gray
  • Toffee

Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets Policies and FAQs

How do the Brooklinen Classic Core sheets ship?

Brooklinen ships for free within the United States. They also ship internationally to a number of countries for an additional fee.

Do the Brooklinen Classic Core sheets come with a sleep trial?

Yes, Brooklinen’s return policy states that you can return these sheets within 365 days of purchase. Brooklinen covers shipping fees for domestic returns and they will provide a full refund.

Do the Brooklinen Classic Core sheets come with a warranty?

Yes, the Brooklinen Classic Core sheets come with a 1-year warranty.

How do I clean the Brooklinen Classic Core sheets?

Brooklinen recommends machine washing these sheets in cold water with like colors. Tumble dry on low. You can iron on warm if needed.

What other products does Brooklinen sell?

Brooklinen sells a variety of bedding, bath, and loungewear products.

Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets Vs

To help you make your final decision, let’s compare the Classic Core sheets to some other Brooklinen sheets, as well as to a competitor.

Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets vs Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheets

  • The Brooklinen Luxe Core sheets are made from 100 percent long-staple cotton in a sateen weave. They have a 480-thread count.
  • The Luxe Core sheet set has a more smooth and satiny feel than the Classic Core. They also have a heavier, thicker feel and a more lustrous finish.
  • These sateen sheets are somewhat breathable, but not as airy as the percale.
  • Want to learn more? Read my full Brooklinen Luxe Core sheets review, or check out my Brooklinen sheets review where I compare the Classic, Luxe, and Linen core sheets.
Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheets
Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheets
Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheets

The Brooklinen Luxe Core sheets are made from cotton in a sateen weave, with a luxuriously smooth and satiny feel.

Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets vs Brooklinen Linen Core Sheets

  • The Brooklinen Linen Core sheets are 100 percent linen made from European flax.
  • They have a more textured and coarse feel than the Classic Core sheets.
  • The linen sheets are super airy, thanks to their loose weave and lower thread count. Linen is also a naturally breathable fabric, thanks to the hollowness of flax fibers.
  • Want to keep learning about these sheets? Read my full Brooklinen Linen Core sheets review, or take a look at my Brooklinen sheets review where I compare the Classic, Luxe, and Linen core sheets.
Brooklinen Linen Core Sheet Set
Brooklinen Linen Core Sheet Set
Brooklinen Linen Core Sheet Set

Brooklinen's Linen Core sheet set is a breathable, 100 percent European flax sheet set.

Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets vs Brooklyn Bedding Bamboo Cotton Sheets

  • The Brooklyn Bedding Bamboo Cotton sheets are made from a blend of cotton and bamboo viscose. Cotton is a breathable material, while bamboo is thermoregulating and moisture-wicking, so this is a great combo for hot sleepers.
  • These sheets have a smooth, crisp feel.
  • Additionally, they have deep pockets that can accommodate a mattress up to 17 inches tall.
  • Curious to know more? Check out my full Brooklyn Bedding Bamboo Cotton sheets review.
Brooklyn Bedding Bamboo Cotton Sheets
Brooklyn Bedding Bamboo Cotton Sheets
Brooklyn Bedding Bamboo Cotton Sheets

The Brooklyn Bedding Bamboo Cotton sheets are light, crisp, and airy sheets with deep pockets that can accommodate a mattress up to 17 inches tall.

Other Products from Brooklinen

Finally, here are the star ratings for the Brooklinen Classic Core sheets.

  • Materials
  • Comfort
  • Value
  • Cooling
  • Durability
  • Trial
  • Warranty
4.6
Amelia Jerden

Amelia Jerden

Amelia is a Staff Writer for Sleepopolis. She primarily covers bedding and sleep accessory products in reviews, how-to guides, and more. You can also find her over on the Sleepopolis YouTube channel. Amelia is a graduate of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, with double majors in media and journalism and in dramatic art. Outside of work, Amelia can usually be found on a hike, traveling to a new city, or at her local thrift store.