Best Bed in a Box Mattresses (2025)

Given its long list of premium features, I gave the DreamCloud a 4.5 out of 5 for materials because its high-quality components are so central to its luxurious feel. The mattress features a blend of memory foam, polyfoam, and individually wrapped innerspring coils, all encased in a breathable cashmere-blend cover. The use of premium materials also increases the durability of the mattress. The foam layers provide a nice mix of cushioning and support, while the coils ensure long-term resilience.

Another one of the DreamCloud’s strongest points is its support, which I gave an impressive 4.5 out of 5. Thanks to its individually wrapped pocketed coils, the mattress gives excellent spinal support and promotes neutral alignment, especially for back sleepers. I noticed little to no sinkage while testing the mattress for myself; the foams on top provided just enough softness to relieve pressure points while still supporting my body. This makes the DreamCloud a great option for anyone dealing with back pain.

As for cooling, the DreamCloud is great at regulating temperature, scoring a solid 4 out of 5. Like many hybrid mattresses, the coils promote airflow, and the cooling gel in the memory foam layer helps dissipate heat.

“The DreamCloud is made with high-quality materials and has gel memory foam infusions, which help the bed sleep super cool,” says mattress tester Bridget Chapman. “Its wrapped coils encourage airflow because there’s so much space between the springs.”

During testing, I saw only a slight increase in temperature — just 7 degrees after 5 minutes — which indicates the mattress stays relatively cool throughout the night.

The one area the DreamCloud falls short in is motion isolation. I gave it a 3.5 out of 5 in this category because I did notice some movement when one of my colleagues tossed and turned on the opposite side of the bed. If you’re a light sleeper or share the bed with a partner who moves a lot at night, you might feel some of that motion.

Want to see if the DreamCloud is the right bed for you? Get the full scoop in our full DreamCloud mattress review or check out the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe mattress to compare it to a similar option.

I gave the Nectar a 5 out of 5 for support because I noticed excellent spinal alignment during testing, even with a colleague on the other side of the bed. The mattress features a combo of soft memory foam and firmer high-density foam, which provides just the right amount of give while still supporting the body’s natural contours. I could feel it reducing pressure around my lower back and on my joints. Whether you’re a back or stomach sleeper, this support system promotes restful sleep, and couples should appreciate the consistent, even support throughout the entire mattress.

Nichole Mondshein, one of my fellow mattress testers, said, “This bed is just a touch firmer than most all-foam beds. Most sleepers will still get a little contouring from the memory foam. However, you will likely feel more ‘on top”’ of this mattress than ‘inside’ of the foam.”

The Nectar Classic also earned a 4.5 out of 5 for edge support. The mattress holds up well around the perimeter, preventing excessive sinkage when sitting or sleeping near the sides. I found that even when lying close to the edge, I didn’t feel like I was going to roll off. This is particularly important for couples who share a bed and want to use the full surface area without sacrificing comfort or feeling unsupported near the edges.

As for cooling, the Nectar Classic earned another 4.5 out of 5 because it offers excellent temperature regulation, which is vital for couples who sleep hot. The memory foam mattress is designed with cooling gel and features a breathable top layer that helps dissipate heat. Throughout testing, I noticed that the bed didn’t retain excess warmth, keeping me comfortable the entire time. This means you and your partner can sleep without worrying about waking up too hot or sweaty.

That said, the Nectar Classic isn’t perfect for everyone. It scored a 3.5 out of 5 in motion isolation, meaning if one partner tends to toss and turn or get in and out of bed frequently, the other may feel some motion transfer. While it’s not a dealbreaker for most couples, it’s worth considering if you or your partner are sensitive to movement at night.

Want to learn more about the Nectar Classic? For a deeper dive into the Nectar mattress and the tests we performed, read our full Nectar mattress review or check out the Nolah Original mattress to compare it to another all-foam model.

The Helix Midnight is designed to alleviate pressure while keeping your spine in alignment, which is crucial for side sleepers who often experience discomfort around the hips and shoulders. During testing, I found that the comfort layer did a great job of contouring to my body, offering cushioning where I needed it most while still providing enough lift for a neutral spine. Thanks to its zoned pocketed coils, the Midnight promotes excellent spinal alignment, earning it a 4 out of 5 for support.

I also gave the Helix Midnight a solid 4 out of 5 for pressure relief. The memory foam layers provide just the right amount of adaptive contouring to relieve pressure points, especially around the hips and shoulders. I found that when I tested it in the side-sleeping position, the mattress cradled my body without feeling like I was sinking too deep, which is essential for side sleepers who need both softness and support. 

My fellow mattress tester, Nichole Mondshein, shared similar thoughts, saying “Immediately when I lay on this mattress for the first time, I felt it relieved a lot of stored pressure from my back and hips, which is a huge plus as someone who suffers from chronic pain in the lower lumbar region.”

The Helix Midnight also offers good edge support, scoring yet another 4 out of 5 in this category. I noticed that when sitting or lying near the edges, the mattress didn’t sag or collapse excessively. The individually wrapped coils help maintain its structure, allowing you to use the full surface of the bed without feeling like you’re going to roll off. Whether you’re getting in and out of bed or just sleeping near the edge, this mattress provides a stable, secure feel, which is ideal for anyone with mobility issues.

However, the Helix Midnight does have some room for improvement in the motion transfer category, where it earns a 3.5 out of 5. While the mattress performs adequately for most couples, I did notice my colleague’s movements as she rolled around on the opposite side of the bed. If you or your partner tend to move around a lot during the night, the other person might be disturbed by those movements.

Still not sold on the Helix Midnight mattress? Read our full Helix Midnight mattress review to see if it checks all your boxes. If you prefer something with a little more plushness, the Helix Midnight Luxe comes with a soft, pillowy topper.

After trying the WinkBed, I was immediately impressed by how easily I could shift positions on it. Its design combines coils with a plush Euro top, providing the perfect amount of give to keep your spine aligned (and earning it a 4.5 out of 5 for materials). Whether you’re a back sleeper, side sleeper, or stomach sleeper, the WinkBed offers the right balance of cushioning and lift, so you can sleep in any position comfortably.

Another standout feature of the WinkBed is its surprisingly strong motion isolation for a responsive hybrid mattress. I was impressed that, despite the bounciness of the innerspring coils, there was minimal motion transfer when my colleague moved around on the opposite side of the bed. This earned the WinkBed a solid 4 out of 5 for motion isolation.

“The WinkBed did a wonderful job isolating smaller disturbances, most likely due to its foam layer and cushy pillow top,” says mattress tester Nichole Mondshein. “That means you’re unlikely to feel disturbed by a partner tossing and turning at night on the WinkBed.”

For couples who sleep hot, the WinkBed comes equipped with a breathable coil system, moisture-wicking Tencel cooling cover, and a gel memory foam pillow top. I tested the cooling capabilities with a thermal gun and found that the temperature increased by just 7 degrees after 5 minutes of lying on the bed, a result that earned the mattress a 4.5 out of 5 for cooling.

When it comes to pressure relief, the WinkBed offers solid support for back sleepers, promoting even pressure distribution along the spine. However, side sleepers might experience some slight pressure buildup at the hips and shoulders, especially since the mattress leans a bit firmer, with a firmness rating of 7 out of 10. They may want something softer for better contouring.

Additionally, lightweight sleepers (under 130 pounds) may not feel enough cushioning, and those with joint pain may find that pressure points like the hips and shoulders are not fully relieved on this firmer, less adaptive surface.

Think the WinkBed could be a good fit for you? Head over to our full WinkBed mattress review to see how it performed on all our tests. If you prefer natural materials, the WinkBeds EcoCloud is the brand’s eco-conscious option.

Let’s start off with the Signature Hybrid’s highest high point: responsiveness. I gave it a perfect 5 out of 5 in this category, because I was able to move around without any struggle while testing this mattress. I was able to switch from my back to my side to my stomach without ever feeling like I was sinking too far into the bed’s memory foam.

During testing, I also found that the Signature Hybrid provided great support, especially for back sleeping. The mattress has a nice “on top” feel, so it keeps you lifted and prevents your hips from sinking in more than the rest of your body. This was particularly helpful when I transitioned from my back to my side, as the bed’s bounce made shifting positions feel seamless. That said, while the mattress did show a bit more pressure around the hips and shoulders while side sleeping, the overall pressure relief was still impressive and earned the bed a 4.5 out of 5 for pressure relief.

Edge support is another strength of the Signature Hybrid, making it an excellent option for combination sleepers who like to spread out across the entire bed. Whether you’re shifting to the perimeter or need extra space to sleep comfortably, this mattress has you covered — it scored a 4.5 out of 5 in edge support, meaning you can roll right up to the edge without feeling like you’re going to roll off.

“Overall, the Signature Hybrid showed high-quality edge support,” says mattress tester Nichole Mondshein. “I felt very stable on the sides of this mattress, which tells me that couples and heavier people should be able to use the entire surface area of their mattress without it sagging.”

When it comes to motion isolation, the Signature Hybrid scored a 3.5 out of 5, which is average. While it does a decent job at reducing motion transfer, the bed’s bounciness means that if your partner is a restless sleeper, their movements could still be felt. Combination sleepers tend to toss and turn a lot, so if you share the bed with someone who moves frequently, you may notice some motion disturbances.

For a deeper breakdown of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid, see our full Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid review. If you want a responsive latex option, check out the Nolah Natural mattress.

Dr. Raj Dasgupta, Sleepopolis’ chief medical advisor, explains it well: “Hybrid mattresses can help with lower back pain, thanks to their blend of support and comfort from innerspring coils and foam layers. Hybrid mattresses help distribute body weight, align the spine, and reduce pressure points.”

For this reason (among other highlights), the Nolah Evolution Hybrid mattress is our pick for best bed-in-a-box for back sleepers. I felt wonderfully supported while testing this bed, thanks to its innerspring coils helping to lift and stabilize my body. I gave the mattress a 4.5 out of 5 for support because of its firm yet comfortable feel, making it ideal for back sleepers who need that crucial support without feeling too stiff.

Edge support is another area where the Nolah Evolution shines, earning top marks for its sturdy perimeter, thanks to an 8-inch coil system and supportive memory foam. While testing, I felt secure even when lying near the edge, which is a huge benefit for back sleepers who often find themselves near the sides of the mattress. This feature also makes it easier for them to get in and out of bed without feeling like they might roll off.

Fellow mattress tester Bridget Chapman echoed these sentiments: “The Nolah Evolution has really solid edge support. I felt just as supported on the sides of the bed as I did in the middle, so I could really stretch out and use the whole mattress.”

The Nolah Evolution also excels in pressure relief, with its medium-firm feel and zoned support providing optimal cushioning for the lower back. I gave it an almost-perfect 4.5 out of 5 for pressure relief, as the mattress kept my spine aligned and offered just the right amount of cushioning to reduce pressure around my lumbar region and help prevent back pain.

While the Nolah Evolution has a lot going for it, I wouldn’t recommend this to every sleeper. I think this bed is a great match for most back and side sleepers. Side sleepers should get enough cushioning around their hips and shoulders to wake up pain-free. Stomach sleepers, on the other hand, likely won’t get enough lift around their hips, which could cause lower back pain after frequent use.

Want to get to know the Nolah Evolution a little better? Read more in our full Nolah Evolution Hybrid Mattress review. For a supportive, all-foam option, check out the Nectar Premier.

Soft mattresses are fantastic at alleviating pressure, particularly in pressure-prone areas such as the hips, shoulders, and lower back. This Bear Elite Hybrid is no different, earning a 4.5 out of 5 for pressure relief. When I lay on my back, I didn’t feel any pressure building up in my lower back, hips, or shoulders, which made for a super comfortable experience.

“Back sleepers should enjoy the Bear Elite if they prefer a medium-soft feel,” says mattress tester Nichole Mondshein. “The Elite’s layers of foam and zoned sections should support their lumbar region to relieve tension at the lower back.”

When side sleeping, I did feel a slight bit of pressure around my shoulders and knees, but this is generally not an issue for most side sleepers. However, if you have particularly sensitive joints, I’d recommend opting for the Soft model for added cushioning.

The Bear Elite Hybrid excels in support as well, scoring a solid 4.5 out of 5. Its dual coil layers provide excellent spinal alignment, while the top foam layer is zoned for support, offering varying firmness levels to target different areas of your body. I felt well-supported and stable throughout my testing, with just the right amount of plushness to avoid any deep sinkage.

Edge support is equally impressive, with the Bear Elite Hybrid earning another 4.5 out of 5. I felt secure lying and sitting along the edges, with only a slight sinkage when I applied my full weight. Despite that, it didn’t feel unstable, and I never felt like I was about to roll off. This solid edge support is ideal for couples, those with mobility concerns, or anyone who enjoys spreading out across the bed.

Though the Bear Elite Hybrid shines in most categories, its responsiveness comes in a bit lower with a 4 out of 5. While many combination sleepers should still find it relatively easy to move around, heavier sleepers (over 250 pounds) might feel a little more stuck in the layers when changing positions.

Think the Bear Elite Hybrid is the bed for you? Learn more about it in our full Bear Elite Hybrid mattress review. If you want to compare it to another soft mattress, check out the Helix Sunset.

I also gave the Titan Plus a 7.5 out of 10 on our firmness scale, which is perfect for heavier sleepers who need more firmness and structure. There’s just enough sinkage to provide comfort, but overall, the mattress keeps your body well-supported. Lighter individuals, however, may find it to feel firmer than expected.

To better understand how this mattress performs for heavier individuals, I had my powerlifter friend, Paulie, join me in testing it. He found the initial sinkage comfortable, but the mattress still offered ample lift and support to keep his spine aligned during our tests.

Support is where the Titan Plus really stands out, earning a perfect 5 out of 5. Built to support up to 1,000 pounds, the mattress features a 6-inch layer of heavy-duty innerspring coils that provides excellent lift and prevents deep sinking. There’s also a layer of dense memory foam on top, which adds extra comfort while keeping your spine properly aligned.

Cooling performance is another highlight, with the Titan Plus earning a solid 4.5 out of 5. The robust coil system promotes airflow and prevents overheating. After testing with a thermal gun, I found the temperature increase was just 6 degrees after 5 minutes of lying on the bed, making it the best cooling mattress for heavier sleepers who tend to overheat at night.

The mattress offers decent pressure relief, particularly for back and stomach sleepers, scoring 4 out of 5. Its firmer feel is ideal for stomach sleepers who need extra lift to keep their hips aligned with their shoulders to prevent back pain.

“I’d recommend the Titan Plus to stomach sleepers,” says mattress tester Nichole Mondshein. “It provides the firm support needed to keep the hips in line with the shoulders, promoting proper spinal alignment.” However, strict side sleepers may find the firmness a bit too much, as there was some pressure buildup around the shoulder when I tested it on my side. For those who prefer side sleeping, a softer option may be more suitable.

Interested in the Titan Plus? Read our full Titan Plus mattress review for more details. Want to explore other another option for heavy people? Check out the Helix Plus.

“Not only does the Birch Luxe look and feel luxurious, but it also features some truly premium materials,” said mattress tester Bridget Chapman. “The latex provided excellent pressure relief, while the individually wrapped coils offered great support.”

This mattress is on the firmer side, which makes it a perfect fit for back and stomach sleepers who need a balance of plush comfort and robust support. Support is one of the Birch Luxe’s strongest features, and it earns a solid 4 out of 5 in this category. The individually wrapped coils provide zoned support with firmer coils around the center to bolster the lumbar region. The natural latex mattress layer adds extra lift, helping to keep the spine aligned. When I tested the mattress on my back and stomach, I felt well-supported, with the coils lifting my hips in line with my shoulders to promote neutral spinal alignment.

The pressure relief offered by the Birch Luxe is especially great for back sleepers, earning a 4 out of 5. The pressure map showed mostly blue and green in the back-sleeping position, indicating a good balance of support and comfort. Side sleepers, however, may feel some pressure around the hips and shoulders, so I’d recommend a softer mattress for those who need more contouring and cushioning around their joints.

Edge support on the Birch Luxe is decent but not exceptional, scoring a 3.5 out of 5. While I felt myself slipping a bit while sitting on the edge of the bed, I did feel more supported when lying closer to the edges. It’s still a solid choice for couples or those who like to spread out, but if you have mobility concerns, you may want a mattress with stronger edge support.

Is the Birch Luxe the organic option for you? Dive deeper into its features in our full Birch Luxe Natural mattress review or check out the Avocado Green for another organic option.