Waterproof Mattress Protector Reviews

We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

So you have found the perfect mattress, the next thing to do is make sure that you protect it with a high quality waterproof mattress protector. Adding a mattress protector is a critical step to maintaining the feel, support, and aesthetic of your new mattress.

A waterproof mattress protector, also sometimes referred to as a waterproof mattress pad or waterproof mattress cover, prevents accidental spills, stains or soiled areas from penetrating into the mattress. It only takes one small spill to be glad that you are using a protector! In some cases, an unfortunate spill can also void mattress warranties, making a waterproof mattress pad even more critical.

What’s a mattress protector?

Before we dive into the real meat of this guide it’s important to understand the differences between mattress protectors, mattress pads, and mattress covers.

  • Mattress protector – this is a material mattress covering that protects your mattress from damage, dirt, and spills (if waterproof). Example – Sleep Tite Protector
  • Mattress pad – this is a material mattress covering that changes the comfort of the mattress, usually it’s a quilted material that adds a bit more softness to the mattress. Example – eLuxury Bamboo Mattress Pad
  • Mattress cover – this is a material mattress covering that can either protect, add comfort, or do both. Varies based on manufacturer. Closely read the product description to determine if it’s a mattress pad or mattress protector.  Example – Grand Mattress Cover

All of the above choices can be either waterproof or not. Additionally, you can have combinations of the above. Some mattress pads also function as mattress protectors, or even waterproof mattress protectors. The most important distinction is to understand the difference between coverings that actually protect your mattress vs. those that just change the feel of the mattress / add comfort.

FAQ:  Do you need a mattress protector or a mattress pad?

Do I Need a Waterproof Mattress Protector?

There are many mattress protectors on the market today that are designed to protect your mattress. While many of these may protect against dust mites, dirt, and other allergens, it is important to invest in one that is also waterproof. Accidents happen. Spills happen. While you can’t be there to protect your mattress 24/7, a waterproof mattress protector can be.

Sleep Tite protector - one of my favorite protectors and an amazing value
Sleep Tite protector – one of my favorite protectors and an amazing value

Many waterproof mattress covers are designed to prevent and contain liquid penetration. This is great for stains that you might not catch immediately, like bed wetting or water spills. A low quality waterproof mattress protector will be noisy and have that iconic plastic feeling, like a cheap raincoat. A high quality waterproof mattress protector will feel soft to the touch. You may not even think that it is actually waterproof, but the proof is in the detailed construction of the product.

Beyond preventing catastrophic liquid spills, a waterproof mattress protector will also help prevent sweat and oils from your body from penetrating the mattress. This will help to further extend the life of your mattress.

Protector Materials & Designs

Many waterproof mattress pads are made from a two-part structure that balances comfort and durability. The top layer is typically a comfortable material that is soft to the touch, almost mimicking the feeling of an actual bed sheet. Sometimes that may mean a cotton terry cloth material. In other products, it could be a knit cotton fabric.

Although it may seem counter-intuitive, the main job of this soft top layer is to actually soak up the spill into the protector as soon as it happens. This prevents excessive spread across the protector and minimizes the risk of the spill penetrating into the mattress.

The second layer is the waterproof protective layer. This layer locks the spill into the core of the mattress protector without allowing it to seep through into the actual mattress. This can be a polyurethane, vinyl, or special patented technology, unique to each manufacturer. It is the combination of these two layers working together that provides a leak-proof seal between the protector and your mattress while still allowing air to circulate.

Naturepedic Spill test, this image was taken several hours into the test. At this point the liquid is fully absorbed.
Naturepedic Spill test, this image was taken several hours into the test. At this point the liquid is fully absorbed.

A quality waterproof mattress protector will be able to handle maximum moisture, while being virtually invisible to the sleeper. It should be able to maintain the original feel of the mattress, avoid heat build-up and refrain from loud noises that could disrupt sleepers throughout the night. It should also be able to provide relief from bed allergens or asthma symptoms without feeling like a scratchy plastic, common to many cheap waterproof mattress covers.

GUIDE:  Full list of the best mattress protectors

The mattress cover will be installed just above the mattress, but below the fitted sheet. This protector is the last line of defense against accidental spills on your mattress.

Protectors with Waterproof Edge Protection

When researching the perfect waterproof mattress pad, be sure to think about how you’ll be using it. What type of sleeper are you? Are you more prone to spills or accidents in certain areas of the bed? For example, do you eat or drink on the edge? Even for the best waterproof mattress protectors, the edge of the bed can be a danger zone. In many cases, the sides of the mattress protectors might use a different material than what is used for the top of the protector.

In many of our reviews of waterproof mattress protectors, the rate of leakage was greater once the spill reached the edge of the bed.

The Lucid mattress protector is a good example of a protector that has good top level coverage, but no protection along the sides. If you have kids, pets, or eat / drink in bed, avoid this. Otherwise, this could be an okay choice for you.

Lucid mattress protector - Queen size (waterproof)
Lucid mattress protector – Queen size (waterproof)

Malouf’s 5-sided protector offers protector along the top and bottom of the mattress.

Sleep Tite mattress protector - King size
Sleep Tite mattress protector – King size

Lastly, you might also consider a full waterproof encasement mattress protector. These zip along the bottom of the mattress, completely encapsulating the mattress from outside dirt, damage, and of course, spills.

Waterproof Mattress Protectors

Whether your mattress is top-of-the-line or at the end of its rope, it is important to invest in a waterproof mattress protector. These special covers can prolong the lifespan of your mattress by preventing the spread of liquid spills, sweat, body oils, dust mites, pet dander, or other bedroom allergens. Contrary to the typical plastic feel of a cheap waterproof mattress protector, a high quality one will feel almost like a fitted sheet and be virtually invisible to the sleeper. A good waterproof mattress pad will not retain excessive heat, allow the transfer of spills or change the original feel of the actual mattress.

For some of Sleepopolis’s top-rated waterproof mattress protectors please check out the reviews below:

Mattress ProtectorDescriptionPriceReview
lucidv2Waterproof, top protection only$20[button link="https://sleepopolis.com/mattress-protector-reviews/lucid-mattress-protector-review/" type="icon" icon="paper"] Read Review[/button]
maloufWaterproof, 5-sided protection$50[button link="https://sleepopolis.com/mattress-protector-reviews/malouf-sleep-tite-mattress-protector-review/" type="icon" icon="paper"] Read Review[/button]
naturepedicWaterproof, 100% organic, 5-sided protection$159[button link="https://sleepopolis.com/mattress-protector-reviews/naturepedic-organic-waterproof-mattress-protector-review/" type="icon" icon="paper"] Read Review[/button]
maloufWaterproof, encasement protection, bed bug prevention$75Coming Soon!
Waterproof, encasement protection, bed bug prevention$49Coming Soon!




Logan Block

Logan is the former content director of Sleepopolis. As content director, he reviewed new mattresses every week and curated the comparisons, best of pages, and video guides on the site. Logan perfected his method by personally testing over 200 different mattresses, so he’s not only able to discern the overall vibe of a specific bed, but to contextualize its feel within the bed-in-a-box market as a whole.