We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

Allswell Supreme Mattress Review

Built with layers of copper gel-infused memory foam, springy pocketed coils, and sturdy edge support, the Allswell Supreme is designed with both pressure relief and support in mind. 

But, does this luxury hybrid actually pull off this ambitious feat? To find out, I tested the Supreme myself, in areas such as edge support, pressure relief, motion transfer and more. Now, I’m ready to give you the full lowdown on how it’s built and how it feels so you can decide whether or not it’s the mattress for you!

If you’re short on time, feel free to skip over to my review summary.

15% off with code BTS15
Allswell Supreme
Allswell Supreme
Allswell Supreme

The Allswell Supreme is a great choice for side sleepers and couples! 

Is Allswell Supreme a Good Mattress for You? 

Is the Allswell Supreme right for you? I’ve put together a few key thoughts on who I think this mattress would be the best for, and who it just may not measure up for. Take a peek down below to help you decide!

Who I recommend the Allswell Supreme mattress for

  • Given the soft feel of its euro-style pillow top, I’d definitely recommend this mattress for side sleepers who need pressure relief at the shoulders and hips.
  • If you’re a fan of memory foam, you should find a lot to love in this mattress, as it features a ton of the material up top.
  • Additionally, I think couples could benefit from the bed’s decent motion isolation and excellent edge support.

Who I don’t recommend the Allswell Supreme mattress for

  • Stomach sleepers will probably want to avoid this mattress, as it’s not likely to be firm enough for their needs.
  • I’d also say that the bed sleeps a little hot, so may not work for those who overheat at night.

How Firm is the Allswell Supreme Mattress?

Let’s get started with firmness. As with any feel factor, firmness is a subjective measure that can change a lot depending on one’s body size, shape, and weight. Therefore, my personal response to the Supreme may be different from your own. For reference, I’m 5’10” and 190 lbs.

Allswell Supreme Firmness
I found the Allswell Supreme to have a medium firmness

I was kind of surprised by the softness of the Supreme, so gave it a 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale. When compared to the industry standard of 6.5 for a medium-firm mattress, it’s clear this bed is on the gentler side.

I was surprised because hybrids are usually quite firm, thanks to their sturdy coils. But here, the supportive springs are tempered somewhat by the gentle pillow top layer. It’s not a cloud-like feel, but the pillow top does work to soften the bounce and create a more balanced vibe. The top memory foam layer could be especially beneficial for side sleepers as the material provides some pleasant, cushiony support to the shoulders and hips.

Allswell Supreme Feet
Testing out the Allswell Supreme

Allswell Supreme Mattress Performance 

Here at Sleepopolis, we use a variety of tests to figure out how a bed will work for  sleepers of all shapes and sizes. We’ll touch on a few of these categories below.

Testing the Allswell Supreme Mattress in Different Sleeping Positions

Every sleeper is different, and this includes their size and sleeping position. You’ll want to be confident that your new mattress is the best option for you, so I’ve compiled a list of various sleepers and how they might respond to the Supreme.

Allswell Supreme Side
I like the Allswell Supreme for side sleepers

Is the Allswell Supreme a Good Mattress for Light Sleepers (Under 130 lb)?

  • Light Back Sleepers – I think that the coiled-support paired with added layers of soft memory foam will provide a good mix of pressure relief and support for these sleepers.
  • Light Side Sleepers – With the numerous layers of foam, I can see this mattress providing these sleepers with the body-contouring relief they need.
  • Light Stomach Sleepers – This bed’s layers of foam may cause stomach sleepers’ hips to sink, throwing their spines out of alignment, so I would beware of that.

Is the Allswell Supreme a Good Mattress for Average Weight Sleepers (130 – 250 lb)? 

  • Average Weight Back Sleepers – These sleepers should experience pressure relief and an increase of support in their lumbar regions as their bodies sink into the foam top layers.
  • Average Weight Side Sleepers – I think the Supreme will create a good amount of plushy pressure relief in the hips and shoulders for these sleepers.
  • Average Weight Stomach Sleepers – I would advise that these sleepers watch out for the foamy pillow top’s tendency to make your hips sink out of line with your shoulders.

Is the Allswell Supreme a Good Mattress for Heavy Sleepers (over 250 lb)? 

  • Heavy Back Sleepers – I believe this mattress will be far too plush for heavier sleepers, causing extreme sinkage and making it difficult to move around. I would recommend looking at our top picks for best mattresses for heavy people to better suit your needs.
  • Heavy Side Sleepers – See above.
  • Heavy Stomach Sleepers – See above.

Allswell Supreme Mattress Pain Relief Performance

When I talk about pressure relief, I’m referring to a bed’s capacity for alleviating tension in the shoulders, hips, and lower back. To demonstrate this, I like to use a pressure map.

It works like this: I roll out the map, hop aboard, and let the gadget do the rest! As I move around, my body presses into the device, which then records this force and translates it into an easy-to-read graphic. Areas of blue indicate low pressure points and areas of red indicate high pressure!

Allswell Supreme Pressure
Pressure map results for the Allswell Supreme

Back Pain – Sleepers with lower back pain who sleep on their sides or backs will appreciate the lumbar support this mattress offers. However, stomach sleepers with  back pain will not be supported on this bed. In this pain area especially, it’s important to keep your spine in a healthy, neutral alignment, and I think that the way stomach sleepers’ hips will sink into this bed’s foam layers will make back pain worse.

Shoulder Pain – Laying on my back and side, I felt pleasant pressure relief and body-contouring at my shoulders. On my stomach, I was still welcomed by the body-contouring layers of foam, but I think it’s ultimately too much foam to keep the hips and shoulders aligned in this position.

Hip Pain – Similarly to sleepers with shoulder pain, both back and side sleepers with hip pain will appreciate the foam layers in this bed, as they offer the soft contouring and pressure relief needed to relieve pain. 

Allswell Supreme Mattress Performance for Couples

Mattresses across the globe are used for partner sleeping, so it’s a no-brainer that we include an entire section dedicated to couples. Below, I’ll highlight some of the most important features for couples, such as motion transfer, sex, edge support, and cooling, to shed some light on why the Supreme may be a good, or not-so-good, choice for you and your partner.

Motion Transfer 

Motion transfer is the amount of movement detectable from one side of a bed to the other. An important measure for all sleepers, but especially so for couples, as it simulates how disturbing your bed mate’s tossing and turning might be in the night.

To illustrate this motion transfer, I dropped a 10-pound steel ball from heights of 4 inches, 8 inches and 12 inches and measured the disturbance it caused: the bigger the lines, the bigger the disturbance.

Allswell Supreme Motion Transfer
I thought the Allswell Supreme did a good job of isolating motion

These are pretty decent motion transfer results, which tells me you shouldn’t be too disturbed by your partner’s movements in the night. I’d attribute this mostly to the top layer of memory foam, which works to dampen and dissipate motion across the structure.

Sex

Couples need a good balance of motion transfer and responsiveness for sex, and yes this includes bounce! This mattress has a number of pro-sex features, like a pillow top layer of Energex foam, as well as its pocketed support coils, both creating a lovely mix of bounce and mobility. I think that this mattress would be a high-quality choice for sex.

Cooling 

Two people absolutely sleep hotter than one. This is why cooling is so important for couples. While the Supreme has a graphite and copper gel-infused layer that is supposed to dissipate heat and create airflow, I found it to sleep a bit hot. I’d recommend checking out Allswell’s Luxe model, which has a quilted top panel containing cooling SwirlFoam. Find more information on the Luxe in my comparison section down below.

Edge Support

Edge support is important for couples because it determines how much of your mattress’ surface you can actually utilize. If you roll around throughout the night, your partner sleeps by the edge, or vice versa, listen up! 

This mattress has an edge system of individually wrapped coils, which luckily for you, expands the usable surface area of the Supreme, and actually makes it feel bigger! This bed’s combination of mobility, support, and bounce will be a huge plus for couples everywhere.

What is the Allswell Supreme Mattress Made Of? 

The Supreme stands at an impressive 14 inches tall, and is billed as the brand’s most luxurious hybrid mattress. Not only does it have the same pocketed-coil durability and cushiony foam as the Original and Luxe models, it also has a quilted, Euro top for ultimate softness, added edge support, a layer of bouncy Energex foam, and a bevy of advanced cooling properties.

I know you’re thinking, wow, that’s a lot of features! To make sense of all that’s going on, let’s go through the layers one by one.

Allswell Supreme
The Allswell Supreme

Cover – The cover is quilted for a soft and cozy handfeel. You’ll likely experience some nice comfort as soon as you stretch out on it.

Pillow top – Up first, you’ll land on a thick euro-style pillow top. This section is meant to provide some immediate pressure relief to the shoulders and hips as you slowly sink into the structure. It’s built with two different foams: a top comfort layer of copper-infused memory foam for gentle contouring and a layer of Energex foam for bounce and mobility.

Allswell Supreme Back
You will feel like you’re sinking into the pillow top of the Allswell Supreme

This combination of foam materials creates an interesting interplay between lift and give, which could really work for side/back combo sleepers. Another interesting characteristic to note is the copper and graphite infusions in the memory foam top layer, both of which help to mitigate the heat trapping tendencies of the material.

Support Layer – These soft top layers of foam are bolstered by a tall system of individually wrapped coils. Bouncy, supportive, and firm, these springs help to lift the sleeper up and out of the structure, ensuring a high level of mobility that could do wonders for combo sleepers. There’s also a section of edge support wrapped around these coils, which helps to expand the usable surface area of the mattress. While a lot of folks could benefit from this feature, couples could be especially grateful for the extra wiggle room.

Allswell Supreme Materials
Showing the materials used in the construction of the Allswell Supreme

Allswell Supreme Mattress Unboxing and Off-Gassing

Your new bed-in-a-box can be unboxed solo, but Allswell recommends having a second helper. Allswell does offer a white glove delivery service, but it is currently unavailable until further notice, due to safety issues surrounding COVID-19.

It’s very common for a compressed mattress, like this one, to have a smell to it upon opening. However, do not fear, if you leave the mattress to sit and breathe for a couple days, any initial scents should dissipate. 

My Final Thoughts about the Allswell Supreme Mattress

Before we finish up this review, let’s take a look at the final takeaways for the Supreme, both good and bad. 

My favorite things about the Allswell Supreme mattress

First off, I love this luxury mattress for all of my memory foam fans, since there’s so much of it here to enjoy. Another great feature of this mattress is its quilted, Euro-style pillow top. I think that this plush top layer will be a hit for pressure relief with side sleepers who suffer from discomfort in the shoulders and hips. Finally, I think couples should really take note of this bed’s motion isolation and edge support capabilities. This mattress offers motion isolation throughout the night, gives you the freedom to roll to the very edge without any sagging, and and has enough bounce to help out with sex.

My Allswell Supreme mattress complaints 

As far as my complaints, this mattress is so plushy up top, that a stomach sleeper will likely have to look for firmer options. I also found that despite some of its cooling capabilities, it sleeps a bit hot, so hot sleepers may want to take a peek at our best cooling mattress picks instead.

How Much Does the Allswell Supreme Cost? 

Below, you’ll find each of the Supreme’s available sizes, dimensions, and price points to further assist you in your Supreme deep dive. Be sure to click on our coupon below to get a good deal on this bed!

Price listed is before offer or discount on each size.

15% off with code BTS15
Allswell Supreme
Allswell Supreme
Allswell Supreme

The Allswell Supreme is a great choice for side sleepers and couples! 

SizeDimensionsPrice
Twin39" x 75" x 14"$725
Twin XL39" x 80" x 14"$775
Full54" x 75" x 14"$885
Queen60" x 80" x 14"$985
King76" x 80" x 14"$1,245
California King72" x 84" x 14"$1,245

Allswell Supreme Mattress Policies and FAQs

How much does it cost to ship the Allswell Supreme?

Ground shipping (within 3 to 7 business days) is free. Allswell also offers expedited shipping and a ground shipping plus mattress haul away option.

Does the Allswell Supreme come with a trial period?

Yes, this bed comes with a 100-night sleep trial.

Does the Allswell Supreme come with a mattress warranty?

Yes, Allswell offers a limited, 10-year warranty.

Do I need to use a box spring with the Allswell Supreme mattress?

No, Allswell’s mattresses don’t require a particular platform, but if you desire one, Allswell recommends using a box spring or slatted bed frame.

Allswell Supreme Mattress Vs  

If you’re considering the Allswell Supreme for your latest mattress buy, it’s safe to say you’re probably keeping an eye on its competition too. Weighing your options is an important part of the process and helps you make a sound, informed decision. Let’s match up the Supreme against the Casper Hybrid and Layla Hybrid, to see how it performs.

Allswell Supreme Mattress vs Casper Hybrid Mattress

Allswell Supreme Mattress vs Layla Hybrid Mattress

Other Models from Allswell Supreme

We’ve met the Allswell Supreme, but did you know it has three sister models? Let’s take a look at the Allswell (original), the Luxe, and the Brick.

Allswell Supreme Mattress vs Allswell Original Mattress

  • Like the Supreme, the Original is also a bed-in-a-box hybrid, though it’s got fewer layers and a more straightforward” vibe, making it the bounciest and most supportive of the Allswell beds.
  • I’d recommend the Original for back or stomach sleepers in need of firm support.
  • The Original is the least expensive Allswell bed
  • For more information, check out my full Allswell mattress review.

Allswell Supreme Mattress vs Allswell Luxe Mattress

  • The Luxe is also a bed-in-a-box hybrid, but elevates the feel of the Original with advanced cooling, edge support, and a slightly taller 12-inch profile.
  • However, the Luxe is still quite bouncy and offers plenty of firm support.
  • Back and combo sleepers will likely benefit most from the Luxe’s sturdy and buoyant feel.
  • Learn more about the Luxe in my full Allswell Luxe Hybrid mattress review.

Allswell Supreme Mattress vs Allswell Brick Mattress

  • The Supreme has a 2-inch Energex layer that relieves pressure, while the Brick has a high density foam layer of the same thickness, but for support.
  • Both mattresses have coils to reduce motion transfer and increase edge support.
  • If you’re looking for a firmer option, the Brick is a better mattress for you.

Take a look at how the Allswell Supreme shines in our performance ratings chart down below.

15% off with code BTS15
Allswell Supreme
Allswell Supreme
Allswell Supreme

The Allswell Supreme is a great choice for side sleepers and couples! 

Allswell Supreme Mattress
  • Materials
  • Comfort
  • Support
  • Value
  • Cooling
  • Edge Support
  • Trial
  • Warranty
3.9
Logan Block
Logan is the content director of Sleepopolis, which means he not only reviews new mattresses every week, but also curates all the comparisons, best of pages, and video guides on the site. He takes a straightforward, honest approach to his reviews and endeavors to give viewers an objective look at each new product he tries out. Logan has perfected his method by personally testing over 200 different mattresses, so he’s not only able to discern the overall vibe of a specific bed, but to contextualize its feel within the bed-in-a-box market as a whole. When he’s not hopping on a new bed or working with our editorial team to whip up an engaging sleep education guide, you can find him reading books on world history, walking his dog Pepper, or searching for the best cheeseburger in New York City.