Most Comfortable Mattress

Finding the most comfortable mattress for you depends on factors such as body weight, preferred sleeping position, and even body temperature. There are a lot of options out there, so we recognize that sifting through all the different mattress types on the market can get overwhelming. That’s why we put together a list of the most comfortable mattresses of the year.

And if you don’t want to take my word for it, you can skip down to my buying guide for a few tips on picking the most comfortable mattress for your needs all on your own!

Most Comfortable Mattresses of 2023

• The WinkBed – Most Comfortable Mattress for Seniors
• Saatva – Most Comfortable Mattress for Stomach Sleepers
• Helix Midnight Luxe – Most Comfortable Mattress for Back Pain
• DreamCloud Premier – Most Comfortable Soft Mattress
• Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe – Most Comfortable Hybrid Mattress
• Nolah Evolution – Most Comfortable Mattress for Hip Pain
• Birch Luxe – Most Comfortable Organic Mattress
• Nectar – Most Comfortable Mattress for Side Sleepers
• Layla Hybrid – Most Comfortable Memory Foam Mattress
• Bear – Most Comfortable Mattress for Athletes

Read on for more in-depth information about each mattress, or skip down to the bottom to find a handy chart that compares the mattress type, price, superlative, and review of each brand.

Our Methodology

Here at Sleepopolis, our team of Certified Sleep Science Coaches has reviewed more than 220 products in our mattress lab, running each one through tests such as pressure-mapping and measuring motion transfer with a seismometer. From there, we give every mattress an overall score based on materials, comfort, support, cooling, and edge support. We also factor in brand performance with categories such as value and warranty.

Because this is a roundup of the Most Comfortable Mattresses, we paid close attention to — what else? — comfort. All of the mattresses here scored at least a 4 out of 5 in this category, with a whopping seven beds earning an impressive 4.5. Click here to learn more about our methodology.

Most Comfortable Mattress 2023 – Our Video Review

The WinkBed – Most Comfortable Mattress for Seniors

Seniors tend to prefer more traditional feeling innerspring mattresses, so the WinkBed might be right up their alley, as it’s a Euro pillow-top hybrid mattress with a traditional innerspring feel. But, it’s still delivered in a box, which is a nice feature for seniors who don’t want to deal with a mattress store. (Though we recommend checking the weight of the box before trying to lift it).

The WinkBed’s classic, bouncy feel will help seniors and combination sleepers feel more “on top of” this bed than “in it,” which means it should be easy for them to move around and change positions at night. The WinkBed also sleeps really cool thanks to its pocketed coil layer, adding some nice airflow through the mattress — another great perk.

This mattress is offered in a variety of firmness options, so most people should be able to find a model that feels comfortable to them. Folks of any age looking for a long-lasting coil mattress should check out the WinkBed.

To learn more, check out our full review or click here for our best deal. Still not sure if the WinkBed is right for you? Browse our other top picks for best mattress for seniors!

Saatva – Most Comfortable Mattress for Stomach Sleepers

Stomach sleepers need a firm mattress to keep their hips lifted up in line with their shoulders. This will keep their spines neutrally aligned and help prevent back pain. The Saatva is a firm innerspring mattress that does just this and should work well for stomach sleepers of any weight!

In addition to offering the right amount of support for stomach sleepers, the Saatva’s firm innerspring support layer provides some nice bounce for combination sleepers. You’ll feel more “on top of” than “in” this bed, which means you’ll be able to change positions easily at night.

The Saatva Classic is a luxury mattress that’s offered in three different firmness levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. So you should be able to find a Saatva that works for you regardless of your preferred sleeping position. The Saatva also features great edge support, which means you can really spread out over its entire surface. This is a great perk for heavier people who want to avoid premature mattress sagging. If you’re looking for a high-quality innerspring mattress, I’d highly recommend a Saatva.

Get the full scoop in our comprehensive Saatva mattress review or click here for our best deal. Not sure if the Saatva will provide you with the support you need? Take a look at our other picks for best mattress for stomach sleepers!

Helix Midnight Luxe – Most Comfortable Mattress for Back Pain

If you struggle with back pain, but enjoy a gentle memory foam feel, the Helix Midnight Luxe mattress could be a good choice for you. This medium-firm hybrid mattress combines pressure relief and support to help alleviate pain. If you’re a back, side, or combination sleeper, this mattress could be a great choice for you.

The Midnight Luxe’s hybrid construction also makes it an excellent choice for anyone suffering from back pain because it offers the firm coil support most sleepers need to keep their spines straight at night. At the same time, its gentle memory foam layer contours to the lower back to offer some pressure relief in the lumbar region. If you’re interested in preventing or alleviating back pain, the Helix might be a big help.

Want to learn more about how the Helix Midnight Luxe can remedy your pains? Read our full review or click here for our best deal. Not sure it will be the perfect bed for your back? See more options for the best mattress for your back pain.

DreamCloud Premier – Most Comfortable Soft Mattress

If you’re looking for a soft to medium soft mattress that relieves pressure around the hips and shoulders the DreamCloud Premier could be for you. This soft mattress combines memory foam and pocketed coils foam to create a soft, pressure-relieving feel.

Because of its coils, the DreamCloud Premier is soft while still remaining supportive. I’d suggest it to back and side sleepers, who both tend to need a mixture of comfort and support.

Couples might also like the DreamCloud Premier. It has really strong edge support, which makes the bed feel larger since you’re able to take advantage of the mattress’ full surface area. It also isolates motion well, which means you’re unlikely to be disturbed by your partner tossing and turning. Lastly, its pocketed coils promote airflow, which help the mattress sleep cooler — a major plus when you have two people producing body heat.

Want to learn more about this super-soft, cloud-like mattress? Check out our full review of the DreamCloud Premier or click here for our best deal. Looking for other options? Check out some other great soft mattresses.

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe – Most Comfortable Hybrid Mattress

Don’t be fooled by the zoned coils in the support layer of the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe — this hybrid treats the sleeper to an exceptional amount of plush pressure relief (it scored a 5.5/10 on our mattress firmness scale). Side sleepers should feel the softness in a contouring layer of proprietary TitanFlex foam, a responsive material that also gives some extra cushioning around the body’s pressure points. This is balanced out by the supportive coils below.

The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe also sleeps very cool. The coils promote airflow, and both the cover and comfort layer contain Phase Change Material, a fabric that’s cool to the touch and adjusts its temperature with your body heat.

Click here for our best deal or read our full review to see if the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe is the hybrid mattress you’ve been looking for. Still looking for your perfect hybrid? Check out our other hybrid mattress picks!

Nolah Evolution – Most Comfortable Mattress for Hip Pain

The hybrid Nolah Evolution offers great pressure relief and body contouring, so it’s one of the best mattresses for hip pain on the market right now. The soft feel of the Evolution should work well for back and side sleepers. Couples might also enjoy the motion-isolating abilities of this mattress.

The right mattress for relieving hip pain will have a cushioning top layer that allows you to sink in a little. This sinkage will cushion the pressure points at your hips and shoulders, which will help relieve pain in those areas

Want to see if the Nolah Evolution is the perfect mattress for your hips pain? Read our full review or get our best deal here! Not sold yet? You might find what you’re looking for in our best mattress for hip pain round up!

Birch Luxe – Most Comfortable Organic Mattress

A crucial consideration for many is the materials that go into a mattress’s construction. With the organic Birch Luxe, you don’t have to worry. Organic cotton, organic wool, natural Talalay latex, and pocketed coils create this high-quality hybrid mattress.

Back sleepers and stomach sleepers should be the most comfortable on this mattress. A quilted Euro top cover accompanies cashmere and wool to create plush pressure relief. With a sturdy support made from coils, you should feel comfy yet still well-supported.

Still curious about the Birch Luxe? Head over to our full review or click here for our best deal. Still wondering if the Birch Luxe is the best match for you? Check out other picks for the best organic mattress.

Nectar – Most Comfortable Mattress for Side Sleepers

The Nectar is a memory foam mattress that should be comfortable for side sleepers, as its thick foam layers should offer plenty of pressure relief at the shoulders and hips. Lightweight and average-weight back sleepers who enjoy soft support and a plush feel could also like this mattress.

And although memory foam tends to sleep hot, the Nectar regulates temperature with a cooling cover and cooling foams, allowing it to sleep cooler than most memory foam beds.

You can find out more in our full review of the Nectar or click here for our best deal. Not sure if it’s the right mattress for you? Check out the other best mattresses for side sleepers.

Layla Hybrid – Most Comfortable Memory Foam Mattress

You probably guessed from the name alone that the Layla Hybrid is — surprise, surprise — a hybrid. But it also has a ton of the brand’s cushy memory foam in its design, which is flippable with both a soft and a firm side. Back sleepers should really like the firm side of the Layla, while side sleepers should get great pressure relief from the soft side.

If you like the sinkage and body-contouring of memory foam, either side of the Layla might work for you! This mattress offers plenty of plush sinkage, but its pocketed coil layer will keep you from feeling too “stuck-in” bed. This is an especially nice feature for back/side combination sleepers, who need to feel free to move throughout the night.

I gave the Layla the top spot for memory foam mattresses because all its foams are infused with copper. This means the Layla won’t trap body heat the way a traditional memory foam mattress does. That copper infusion and the addition of breathable pocketed coils mean this Layla sleeps nice and cool. So hot sleepers looking for some sinkage should really like this Layla.

Still curious about the Layla Hybrid? Mosey on over to our full review or click here for our best deal. Still shopping? Check out our other top-rated memory foam mattresses.

Bear – Most Comfortable Mattress for Athletes

If you’re an athlete or just someone who lives an active lifestyle, you’re going to need a mattress that offers a balance of comfort and support. You just might find what you’re looking for in the Bear, a firm all-foam bed that’s especially comfortable for back sleepers.

Bear actually caters to athletes by outfitting all of their mattresses with a cover made of something called Celliant. Many studies suggest that this material could help with athletic recovery by promoting blood flow while you sleep. Celliant is also extremely breathable, which helps the mattress sleep cool — an essential trait if your body temperature is up after a rigorous workout.

Still deciding whether or not you want to hibernate on the Bear? Dash over to our full review or click here for our best deal!

Things to Consider When Choosing a Comfortable Mattress

Finding the best comfortable mattress isn’t just about the bed itself. It’s also about taking your own traits as a sleeper into consideration, including sleep position, body type, whether you sleep hot, etc. From there, you can figure out what materials and construction are right for you. Let’s take a closer look at some of these factors.

Sleeping Position

Your sleeping position will help you determine which type of mattress might feel most comfortable to you. Take a look at the list below to see what mattress types are best for your sleeping position. And once you’ve found the right bed, peruse our Guide to Better Sleep Posture to get an even healthier night’s sleep.

• Side sleepers often do best on soft, pressure-relieving mattresses. These sleepers might want to opt for memory foam or pillow-top mattresses that offer some sinkage and body-contouring.
• Back sleepers can be happy on most different mattress types! If you’re not sure where to start, look into medium-firm hybrid mattresses, which often feel comfortable to a wide variety of sleepers.
• Stomach sleepers normally need firm support. Without firm support, their hips will sink into their mattresses, creating a bend in the spine that can lead to pain over time. Some good options for these sleepers could be innerspring, hybrid, or latex foam mattresses. Mattresses that feature firm polyurethane foam (aka polyfoam) could also work for these folks.
• Combination Sleepers usually prefer bouncy, responsive mattresses that make it easy to change positions throughout the night. If you’re a combination sleeper unsure where to start, check out latex or innerspring mattresses.

Body Type

Your body type and weight play a big role in determining what type of mattress will work for you. Depending on how your weight is distributed, you may need extra support around your hips. If you’re someone who carries most of their body weight in their hips, consider a mattress that offers zoned support, which essentially means that a mattress is firmer in certain areas and softer in others. As a brand, Casper has been a pioneer in this field, outfitting its flagship mattress with foams that are firmer in the center of the bed and softer at the shoulders and feet.

Similarly, heavier people (over 250 pounds) tend to need a mattress that features a strong support system. Innerspring, hybrid, and latex mattresses tend to work best for these sleepers. Some mattress brands also offer models made specifically with heavier folks in mind. I’d recommend checking our best mattress for heavy people roundup to explore some of these options.

Lighter people (under 130 pounds) should also consider their weight when purchasing a mattress. Some beds might feel firmer to these sleepers because they don’t sink into the top foams as far as an average weight person would. These sleepers might be most comfortable on pillow-top mattresses or softer beds. If you do purchase a bed that feels too firm, a mattress topper could help.

Mattress Materials

Which mattress material is going to feel most comfortable? It depends on what you like! If you’re someone who feels most comfortable on soft, pressure relieving mattresses, memory foam might be the way to go. But if you associate comfort with firm support, an innerspring mattress could work better for you.

I’ll also note here that if you feel more peace of mind on natural or organic beds, there are a few options you can check out. Natural latex mattresses or mattresses that use CertiPUR-US® Certified foams could fit the bill for you. Our best natural organic mattress guide can help you find a mattress that meets those criteria.

Firmness

Your preferred firmness level will depend a lot on your preferred sleeping position. But if you’re not sure where to start, most people find medium-firm mattresses universally comfortable. For more information on choosing a comfortable firmness level, you can head to our Mattress Firmness Guide.

Temperature

Temperature can play a huge role in the comfort of a mattress, and should definitely be taken into consideration when you’re choosing a new bed. Materials like memory foam tend to trap heat and can exacerbate hot sleepers’ problems. If you sleep hot, look for a mattress that features cooling gel infusions or pocketed coils to promote airflow. In general, hybrid and innerspring mattresses tend to sleep fairly cool.

When it comes to cooling, we’d also be remiss not to talk about latex mattresses. Even though they can be more expensive than other mattress types, latex is a naturally cooling material that’s often a great fit for hot sleepers. If you struggle with waking up sweaty, you could find a solution in our best latex mattress roundup. And if you want to learn more about how body temperature affects sleep, dive into our article on thermoregulation.

Couples

If you sleep with a partner you’ll want to consider things like motion transfer, edge support, and cooling technology when choosing a bed. You’ll also need to compromise on things like firmness level and feel to ensure both partners are happy. Check out our best mattress for couples article to learn more about choosing a mattress to share with a partner.

Most Comfortable Mattress: Details and Pricing

And that wraps up my list! You can review the chart below for one last look at all the coupons and information you need to choose between these beds.

 

FAQs

Bridget Chapman

Bridget is a Certified Sleep Science Coach and senior editor here at Sleepopolis. From testing mattresses to writing about various sleep health topics, her goal is to help you get a good night's sleep. You can also find her in videos on our YouTube channel. Bridget graduated magna cum laude from San Diego State University with a degree in journalism and a minor in English. Before joining the Sleepopolis team, she was a TV news reporter and worked in cities across the country. She loves spending time outdoors, checking out new restaurants, snuggling with her pets, and of course — getting some quality Zzz’s.