We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

Best Pillow Stuffing

We’ve all been there: You order a pillow that you love, but a few months or years later it’s gone hopelessly flat. Or maybe you purchase a pillow that you’re really excited about, only to discover that it’s disappointingly thin. Rather than donating or throwing out your unsatisfactory pillow, why not salvage it instead?

That’s exactly what pillow stuffing allows you to do. It lets you fluff up or otherwise customize the shape of a pillow(s) to suit your personal preferences. In the process, it saves you the money that would otherwise be spent on purchasing new pillows. No matter whether you’re looking for polyester, cotton, buckwheat, down, or memory foam, there’s a stuffing for pretty much every kind of pillow. So check out our roundup of best pillow stuffing to get started on improving your comfort!

Best Pillow Stuffing

Editor’s Choice

Fairfield PF-10 Premium Poly-Fil

Pros: 

  • The stuffing is made from 100 percent recycled polyester fiber. 
  • It’s soft to the touch and hypoallergenic. 
  • The stuffing is designed to hold up in the wash, so you can wash the pillows you stuff (as long as the rest of the pillow is washable!). 
  • It’s made in the USA. 

Cons: 

  • The stuffing might flatten over time, so you might need to re-fluff it on a regular basis. 
  • Some people might find it to be on the lumpy side. 
Fairfield PF-10 Premium Poly-Fil
Fairfield PF-10 Premium Poly-Fil
Fairfield PF-10 Premium Poly-Fil

The Fairfield PF-10 Premium Poly-Fil is made in the USA from recycled polyester fiber. It’s soft, hypoallergenic, and holds up well in the wash. 

Contender

Revoloft Polyester Cluster Fiber Fill

Pros: 

  • The 100% polyester filling is made with “hollow conjugate siliconized fiber,” which is a fancy way of saying that it should create a high loft. 
  • The fibers are strong and durable. 
  • The stuffing arrives in a polyester casing, and you can use the case to store leftover stuffing. 
  • It’s made in the USA. 

Cons: 

  • The stuffing might not hold up super well in the wash. 
  • Some users have reported the filling might clump over time. 
Revoloft Polyester Cluster Fiber Fill
Revoloft Polyester Cluster Fiber Fill
Revoloft Polyester Cluster Fiber Fill

High loft polyester filling comprises the Revoloft Polyester Cluster Fiber Fill, which is strong and durable. The stuffing is made in the USA and comes in a convenient storage case. 

Best Buckwheat

Zen Chi Buckwheat Pillow Replacement Hulls

Pros: 

  • The hulls are produced from 100% organic buckwheat. 
  • Buckwheat hulls are known to sleep cool and conform to the shape of your head, which can create a comfortable pillow and sleeping experience. 
  • The manufacturer says the hulls are chemical-free.

Cons: 

  • Some users have reported the hulls might arrive with an unpleasant odor. 
  • Working with the hulls can be a little messy, so be prepared for some cleanup! 
Zen Chi Buckwheat Pillow Replacement Hulls
Zen Chi Buckwheat Pillow Replacement Hulls
Zen Chi Buckwheat Pillow Replacement Hulls

The Zen Chi Buckwheat Pillow Replacement Hulls are produced from 100% organic buckwheat. The chemical-free hulls sleep cool and conform to the shape of your head. 

Best Down

Rose Feather Bulk White Down and Feather Filling

Pros: 

  • The stuffing is made from 95% white goose down. 
  • It’s sourced from the food industry, and the manufacturer claims they do not use any live-plucked down or feathers. 
  • It’s 850+ fill power, so it creates decent loft. 
  • The down arrives in a little pillow that helps protect it during transport. 

Cons: 

  • Some users have reported there might be some feather shafts mixed into the down, which can lead to pokes. 
  • In addition to a few shafts, there might also be some grey feathers mixed in with the white down. 
Rose Feather Bulk White Down and Feather Filling
Rose Feather Bulk White Down and Feather Filling
Rose Feather Bulk White Down and Feather Filling

The 850+ fill power, 95% white goose down Rose Feather Bulk White Down and Feather Filling is sourced from the food industry and creates a decent loft. The stuffing comes in a storage “pillow” to protect it during transport. 

Best Memory Foam

Workingfish Shredded Memory Foam Filling

Pros: 

  • The shredded memory foam is CertiPUR-US certified, meaning it’s free of certain harmful chemicals. 
  • It’s soft, conforms to your head, and rebounds quickly to retain its shape. 
  • The stuffing comes packed in a vacuum bag that can be used to store leftover filling. 

Cons: 

  • The memory foam chunks are different sizes, so you might need to arrange them thoughtfully to avoid getting large clumps. 
  • The stuffing might arrive with an unpleasant odor.
Workingfish Shredded Memory Foam Filling
Workingfish Shredded Memory Foam Filling
Workingfish Shredded Memory Foam Filling

The soft Workingfish Shredded Memory Foam Filling conforms to your head and then rebounds quickly to retain its shape. It’s CertiPUR-US certified, so it’s free of harmful chemicals. 

Best Cotton

Organic Cotton PLUS Raw Cotton Fiber

Pros: 

  • The stuffing is made from 100% certified organic raw cotton fiber. 
  • It’s soft to the touch and easy to work with. 
  • The cotton is fairly breathable and shouldn’t sleep too hot. 
  • It’s grown in Texas and made in the USA. 

One con? The manufacturer says the cotton fibers might contain seeds and small plant pieces, but some users have reported that this isn’t the case. So keep this in mind if you’re purchasing the product because you want something with seeds. 

Organic Cotton PLUS Raw Cotton Fiber
Organic Cotton PLUS Raw Cotton Fiber
Organic Cotton PLUS Raw Cotton Fiber

As the name suggests, the Organic Cotton PLUS Raw Cotton Fiber is made from 100% certified organic raw cotton fiber. The soft stuffing is grown in the USA and easy to work with. 

Best Bargain

VirtueValue Raw Polyester Cluster Fiber Filling

Pros: 

  • The stuffing is made from 100% polyester fiber and is hypoallergenic. 
  • It’s washable, so you can wash the pillows you’ve stuffed (so long as the rest of the pillow is machine-washable). 
  • The stuffing is soft to the touch and is designed to produce a high loft. 
  • It’s made in the USA. 

Cons: 

  • Some users have reported the fibers might arrive with a chemical odor. 
  • The filling might clump up a bit, so you might need to re-separate it every once in a while.
VirtueValue Raw Polyester Cluster Fiber Filling
VirtueValue Raw Polyester Cluster Fiber Filling
VirtueValue Raw Polyester Cluster Fiber Filling

The VirtueValue Raw Polyester Cluster Fiber Filling is soft to the touch and produces a high loft. The 100% polyester fiber is hypoallergenic, made in the USA, and washable.

How We Picked

Pillow stuffing might seem like a fairly straightforward purchase, but the sheer number of options can prove overwhelming. In order to zero in on this roundup of best pillow stuffing, we considered the following factors.

Cost

Because pillow stuffing is typically used to salvage existing decorative pillows or sleeping pillows, it wouldn’t make financial sense to spend as much or more on the stuffing as you spent on the pillow. So we prioritized options that provide a lot of value for the price. In many cases, you’ll probably end up purchasing more stuffing than you need, which means you’ll have more stuffing on hand for whenever you need to refill a pillow in the future.

Material

Just like pillows, pillow stuffing can take a variety of forms. This list includes stuffing made from a range of materials, including buckwheat, cotton, down, memory foam, and polyester. You can either match your choice of stuffing to your pillow’s existing filling or remove all of that filling and replace it entirely with a new material of your choice.

Manufacturing

When possible, we prioritized options that are made with eco-friendly, ethical (in the case of down), and/or safety-minded practices such as CertiPUR-US certification.

Sleepopolis Buying Tips

Still trying to settle on the best pillow stuffing for your needs? Consider the following:

  • What material do you want? This is probably the most significant choice you’ll make when it comes to pillow stuffing. Deciding whether you want cotton, down, buckwheat, memory foam, polyester, or another material will help you shrink your list of options.
  • How much stuffing do you need? Some stuffing is sold by the pound, while others are sold by the gram. Some is sold in 5-pound increments, while others can be purchased in bulk. Choose accordingly based on how many pillows you’re planning to fill.

Pillow stuffing can help you breathe new life into a favorite pillow or salvage a disappointing new purchase. No matter whether you’re looking to beef up a buckwheat, cotton, polyester, down, or memory foam pillow, there’s a stuffing to help you out. By considering your preferred material and how much stuffing is necessary to complete your project, you’ll zero in on the best pillow stuffing for your needs.

The following two tabs change content below.
Logan Block
Logan is the content director of Sleepopolis, which means he not only reviews new mattresses every week, but also curates all the comparisons, best of pages, and video guides on the site. He takes a straightforward, honest approach to his reviews and endeavors to give viewers an objective look at each new product he tries out. Logan has perfected his method by personally testing over 200 different mattresses, so he’s not only able to discern the overall vibe of a specific bed, but to contextualize its feel within the bed-in-a-box market as a whole. When he’s not hopping on a new bed or working with our editorial team to whip up an engaging sleep education guide, you can find him reading books on world history, walking his dog Pepper, or searching for the best cheeseburger in New York City.
Logan Block

Latest posts by Logan Block (see all)