Welcome to my eLuxurySupply vs Casper mattress comparison! In this review, we’re going to pit these two mattresses side by side to see how they’re built, how they sleep, and who they might be best for. By the end, you’ll know without a shadow of a doubt which of these beds is going to be the absolute best mattress for you.
Short on time? Not a problem. Click here to slide down to the review summary.
eLuxurySupply vs Casper: Which is Better for You?
Yes, that’s right, we’re going to kick things off with a few quick recommendations! That way, you can start to get a better sense of which of these mattresses is going to be the right one for you and your unique slumber needs. I’ll briefly outline these recs below, but would also recommend that you check out my full eLuxurySupply mattress review and Casper mattress review for even more information.
Who Should Buy eLuxurySupply
- If you sleep on your side, you may enjoy the deep pressure relief of this gel memory foam mattress.
- Folks shopping on a budget may enjoy the affordable price tag on this bed!
- I’d also recommend this mattress for anyone who sleeps hot. The top layer of memory foam is infused with soothing gel to keep temps nice and low in the night.
Who Should Buy Casper
- Combination sleepers might enjoy the buoyant lift of this mattress, which makes it easy to move around and change positions.
- If you struggle with back pain, you’ll likely benefit from the interior layer of zoned support, which brings some nice relief to the hips and lower back.
- The Casper has a medium-firm, balanced foam feel, so should work well for someone after a pressure-relieving yet supportive sleeping experience.
eLuxurySupply vs Casper: Similarities and Differences
Before we get into the nitty-gritty details, let’s go ahead and go through a few main similarities and differences. That way, we’ll be better able to contextualize our findings!
- Both the eLuxury mattress and the Casper mattress are foam beds. However, it’s worth noting that this does not mean they feel the same… like, at all.
- These beds also employ memory foam for deep pressure relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back.
- I’d also say that both of these models also sleep pretty cool thanks to cooling fabrications in their top layers (aerated foam for airflow in the Casper and a soothing gel infusion in the eLuxurySupply).
- The Casper has a more complex foam design than the eLuxurySupply, which is built with just two layers of foam. We’ll explore what this means for their respective feels in the next section.
- The eLuxurySupply mattress is more affordable than the Casper mattress. If you’re shopping on a budget, the eLuxurySupply bed-in-a-box model might be the better pick for you.
- And finally, I’d say that the Casper is a more supportive mattress whereas the eLuxurySupply is a more pressure-relieving one. But again, more on that below!
eLuxurySupply and Casper Mattress Feel Comparison
Now that we’ve got the similarities and differences sorted, let’s figure out how these foam beds feel! To do that, we’re going to test them out for a number of feel factors, including firmness, support, pressure relief, cooling, motion transfer, edge support, and more!
But before we get started, a quick note to say that feel is always going to be a subjective measure and could change a lot depending on your body size, shape, and weight. Therefore, how I feel these mattresses could very well differ from how you’d feel them.
After rolling around on the eLuxurySupply mattress, I decided to give it a 6/10 firmness rating on the firmness scale. When compared to the industry standard of 6.5 for medium firmness level, it’s clear this bed is on the softer side of things.
All in all, I’d say this is definitely a gentle gel memory foam mattress. The comfort layer is made up of a thick slab of memory foam, which has a super slow response to pressure. This means you’re likely to sink deeply into the mattress for intense pressure relief at pressure points like the shoulders, hips, and lower back. If you like feeling more “in” your bed than “on top” of it, this could be an excellent choice for you. Side sleepers might enjoy the cuddly pressure relief of this mattress, as well as those who struggle with aches at their joints. Back sleepers and stomach sleepers, however, may find the mattress to be a little too soft (but more on that below).
This mattress is built with only two layers — a top layer of memory foam and a bottom layer of high-density poly foam. Therefore, it’s not the most supportive mattress in the world. For that reason, I wouldn’t necessarily recommend it for heavier sleepers or those who need a firm lift from their mattress. But, because there’s such a thick layer of memory foam up top, this bed does have nice motion isolation, meaning you shouldn’t be too bothered by your bed mate’s movements in the night. I’d also say that the bed sleeps pretty cool, especially when compared to other memory foam mattresses on the market.
The Casper mattress got a 7/10 firmness rating on the firmness scale from me. Again, when compared to the industry standard of 6.5 for medium firmness, this bed is more on the firm side than the eLuxurySupply mattress.
I’d say the Casper mattress has a nice, classic medium firmness level. The combination of different foams here creates a balanced feel, providing sleepers with both gentle pressure relief and firm support. Though you’re likely to sink into the mattress a little bit for relief at the shoulders and hips, you shouldn’t ever feel too “stuck” in your mattress. On the contrary, you’re likely to feel lifted up and out of the bed, which could be a pleasant vibe for combination sleepers and back sleepers. This bed could also be great for folks struggling with back pain as the interior layer of zoned support does a lot to alleviate tension across the body. I’d say the Casper is particularly effective at setting the spine in a neutral alignment, which is key to long-lasting comfort.
If you want even more support from your Casper, you could always opt for the Casper Hybrid over the original all-foam Casper that I’ve been reviewing here. The Casper Hybrid is just like the original all-foam Casper, except it swaps out its base layer of high-density poly foam for pocketed coils. This creates a firmer, bouncier, and more supportive vibe that could work exceptionally well for back sleepers and stomach sleepers!
Comparing What It’s Like to Sleep on eLuxurySupply and Casper
Up next, let’s discuss how it feels to sleep on the eLuxurySupply and Casper foam beds in different sleeping positions. We’ll do this by assessing how they feel on the back, side, and stomach. We’ll also chat about how folks of different sizes and body weights might experience these beds.
Back — This mattress felt pretty good on my back, though I could definitely feel my hips sinking out of alignment with my shoulders. Strict back sleepers may find that this mattress is too soft for their needs as they tend to prefer a little “lift” from their beds. If you switch between your back and side in the night, this mattress should be okay!
Side — Strict side sleepers should find a lot to love in the thick top layer of memory foam in this mattress! As you press into the bed, you’re likely to experience a ton of relief at pressure points all across the body, including the shoulders, hips, and lower back.
Stomach — Unfortunately, this bed is going to be way too soft for stomach sleepers. As I rolled onto my stomach, I could feel my hips sinking out of alignment with my shoulders, resulting in some uncomfortable bowing at my lower back. Those who doze in prone will definitely want to check out something firmer!
Body Weight — Since this bed is only built with two layers (one of memory foam and one of high-density poly foam), heavier sleepers may find that they sink right through the layers, resulting in discomfort along the spine. Conversely, lighter sleepers may find that they interact almost entirely with the top layer of memory foam.
Back — The Casper felt amazing on my back! As I pressed into the bed, I could feel the top layers of foam filling in the space at my lumbar region for some nice pressure relief. But I never felt “trapped” by the mattress; on the contrary, the interior layer of zoned support did a lot to lift my hips in line with my shoulders. In my opinion, this is a very comfortable mattress.
Side — Though the Casper was certainly cozy on my side, I think it’s a touch too firm for strict side sleepers. If you switch between your side and another position in the night, you should be okay, but I think strict side sleepers are going to be happier on a memory foam mattress like the eLuxurySupply.
Stomach — And finally, I found sleeping on my stomach to be pretty comfortable on the Casper! This bed does an excellent job of lifting the hips in alignment with the shoulders, which is a big plus for stomach sleepers.
Body Weight — The Casper has a balanced foam feel that should leave both lighter and heavier sleepers feeling well supported through the night.
Comparing eLuxurySupply and Casper Prices
Though feel is incredibly important when buying a new mattress, your decision may very well come down to pricing. Between these two options, the eLuxury mattress is going to be the more affordable option, though the Casper isn’t too far behind. For a full pricing breakdown, check out the table below!
Prices listed are before discount or offer for each size.
Comparing eLuxurySupply and Casper Mattress Materials
To expand our understanding of these two mattresses, let’s dive beneath the covers to figure out how they’re built! I’ll go over each bed’s unique design below, but would also encourage you to check out my full eLuxury mattress review and Casper mattress review for even more information.
Cover — The eLuxurySupply cover is made of 100% cotton. I found it to be soft, breathable, and comfortable.
Comfort Layer — The top layer is made of a 3” section of gel memory foam. Memory foam has a slow response to pressure, so should contour to the curves of your body as you sink into the mattress. Because this particular layer of memory foam is so thick, most folks will find that they experience a ton of body-contouring as they press into the mattress. If you prefer feeling more “on top” of your bed than in it, this may not be the bed for you. Worth noting too that the gel infusion here helps to mitigate memory foam’s tendency to absorb and trap body heat.
Base Layer — Beneath the top layer of memory foam lies a thick section of high-density poly foam. This material is much firmer than the memory foam above it, so works to bring some stability, durability, and shape to the structure.
Cover — The Original Casper cover is made of a knit polyester blend, which is soft and cozy.
Comfort Layer — The comfort layer is made of the brand’s Airscape™ foam. This material has a slow response to pressure, allowing folks to sink into the mattress for pressure relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back. Though this kind of contouring would normally lead to overheating, Casper has curbed this issue by perforating this layer with small holes. This helps to encourage some really nice airflow throughout the mattress!
Transition Layer — Underneath the top layer of perforated foam, you’ll land on a layer of high-quality zoned memory foam support. As we discussed earlier, Zoned Support really just means that the layer has been split into three different firmness “zones.” There’s softer foam at the shoulders for a little give and firmer foam at the hips for a little lift. This helps to bring extra comfort to sensitive pressure points across the body and also helps to set the spine in a neutral alignment.
Base Layer — In the all-foam Casper, the base of the mattress is made of high-density poly foam. This firm material brings some nice support to the bed and also helps to provide the mattress with its shape and stability. In the Casper Hybrid, this layer of high-density poly foam is replaced by one of pocketed coils, which makes things even more bouncy and supportive.
Alright y’all, we’ve officially made it to the end of this comparison! After taking a peek at these two mattresses, it’s time to figure out which one is going to be the best mattress for you. Below, I’ll break down what I consider to be their respective best qualities and then wrap things up with a few expert recommendations.
The big selling point for the ELUX mattress from eLuxurySupply is that it’s a fantastic memory foam mattress at an affordable price. The 3” top layer of gel memory foam provides plenty of room to sink in for pressure relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back. This establishes a plus and slightly luxurious vibe, which could work great for side sleepers shopping on a budget. In general, I’d say that anyone who likes feeling more “in” their bed than “on top” of it could find a lot to love in this bed!
However, if you do want to feel positioned more on top of your bed than in it, the original Casper could be the bed for you! This mattress features a balanced foam feel of high-quality latex foam, memory foam, and high-density poly foam, establishing a pleasant combination of both pressure relief and support. The result is a little give where you may need extra comfort (like at the shoulders) and a little lift where you may need support (like at the hips). I’d also say that the Casper sleeps cooler than the ELUX mattress, so could be the better pick for hot sleepers.
eLuxurySupply Best Features
- If you’re looking for a no-frills construction, the ELUX mattress could be the one for you as it features just two layers: one of gel memory foam and one of high-density poly foam.
- Folks who enjoy sinking into their mattress for deep pressure relief and cushioning at the shoulders, hips, and lower back should enjoy the thick top layer of memory foam.
- Budget shoppers could also find a lot to love in the affordable price tag on this memory foam mattress!
Casper Best Features
- For me, the best feature of the Casper mattress is its balanced foam feel. It establishes a gentle sleeping experience that provides fantastic pressure relief and support.
- Speaking of support, the internal layer of Zoned Support is another standout design element as it provides specialized relief to pressure points across the body.
- I’d also say that the Casper sleeps very cool, thanks in large part to the top layer of breathable Airscape™ foam.
Comparing Company Policies
- Trial Period – 120-night sleep trial. If you don’t like, return within this window and get a full refund!
- Shipping – Ships free in the USA and arrives compressed in a box
- Warranty – 10-year warranty
- Trial Period – 100-night sleep trial. If you don’t like it, you can return within this window and get a full refund!
- Shipping – Ships free in the USA and arrives compressed in a box
- Mattress Warranty – 10-year limited warranty
Comparing eLuxurySupply and Casper Customer Service
At Sleepopolis, we rank a brand’s customer service rating based on our personal interactions with the brand’s customer service team. A brand can either be ranked as Stellar, Great, Satisfactory, or Poor.
eLuxurySupply Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating
Poor: There’s no customer chat option on the main eLuxurySupply page, which makes it difficult to reach support. It pops up once you navigate to another page, but it’s discreetly hidden in the bottom left corner. Overall, kind of a clunky user experience!
Casper Sleepopolis Customer Service Rating
Satisfactory: Though Casper’s customer service is good, I didn’t think it was quite as effective as what I’ve seen from other brands. It took a moment for an agent to get back to me, but when they did, they were super helpful and nice.
Comparing Other Models from eLuxurySupply and Casper
Though we’ve been focusing on the original ELUX and Casper mattresses in this comparison, it’s worth noting that both brands sell other models. So, let’s meet a few of them below!
- Unlike the original ELUX mattress, the ELUX Signature is a hybrid mattress that combines foam with pocketed coils for a bouncy yet pressure-relieving feel.
- If you like to feel more “on top” of your bed than in it, the Signature could be a great pick for you.
- It’s also more supportive than the all-foam ELUX model, so may work best for back sleepers, combination sleepers, and stomach sleepers.
In addition to the all-foam Casper mattress, the brand also sells a few different hybrid mattresses. These beds combine soft foam top layers with pocketed coils in order to strike a balance between pressure relief and support. Below, I’ll give a brief overview of each of these hybrid options!
- Casper Hybrid: The Casper Hybrid is exactly like the all-foam Casper, except its foundational layer is made of pocketed coils instead of high-density poly foam. This makes it bouncier and more supportive than the all-foam Casper. For that reason, I’d recommend it for back and combo sleepers.
- Casper Nova Hybrid: For me, the Casper Nova Hybrid is the softest Casper bed, so could work well for those in need of a little relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back. If you like the idea of a hybrid mattress, but aren’t sold on the firm support, this could be a nice pick for you. It also sleeps cooler than the other Casper models, which could be a bonus for hot sleepers.
- Casper Wave Hybrid: The Casper Wave Hybrid features multiple layers of zoned support, plush memory foam, and springy coils. This establishes a luxurious feel that could work wonders for those in need of deep pressure relief. If you struggle with joint pain, this could be the bed for you.
Other Common eLuxurySupply and Casper Comparisons
- Casper vs Leesa
- Casper vs Nectar
- Casper vs Endy
- Casper vs Yogabed
- Casper vs Purple
- Casper vs Tuft & Needle
- Casper vs GhostBed
- Casper vs Saatva
- Casper vs DreamCloud
- Casper vs Layla
- Casper vs Helix
- Casper vs Tempur-Pedic
- Casper vs WinkBed