Belly Sleep Pillow Review

We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. See our disclosures.

The folks at Belly Sleep are big advocates for — you guessed it — belly sleepers. The brand noticed that stomach sleepers’ specific needs are often ignored by the bedding market and decided to do something about it! And so, the Belly Sleeper pillow was born.

This soft, low-profile pillow was designed specifically for folks who sleep on their stomachs, and it does a lot to address this sleep position’s specific sleep needs. Read on to learn more about how this pillow feels, what it’s made of, and why it’s such a hit with those who sleep in the prone position.

Short on time? Skip down to my review summary.

See Latest Deals
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow

The perfect pillow for stomach sleepers is finally here! 

Is the Belly Sleeper a Good Pillow for You?

Before we get into all the details, let’s take a moment to discuss who this pillow will and will not work for. You have different pillow needs depending on your preferred sleeping position, and this pillow is tailored specifically to stomach sleepers, which means it won’t feel comfortable to just anyone.

The Belly Sleeper pillow.
The Belly Sleeper pillow.

Who should try the Belly Sleeper pillow

  • First and foremost, this pillow is a great pick for stomach sleepers, who do best on soft, low profile pillows like this one.
  • Budget shoppers should appreciate this pillow’s low price point.
  • Anyone looking for a foam pillow with a low loft should take a look at the Belly Sleeper. Most foam pillows are quite a bit taller (and firmer) than this one, so it’s a nice find for folks looking for a specific feel.

Who should not try the Belly Sleeper pillow

  • Side sleepers will need a much thicker pillow to get the neck support they need. One of our best pillows for side sleepers could be a better fit.
  • Sleepers looking for a moldable pillow won’t like the feel of the Belly Sleeper, which is made of a solid block of foam. These sleepers might want to check out a down pillow instead.
  • Hot sleepers should stick to the brand’s “cool gel” Belly Sleeper pillow, which will feel more cooling than the original pillow.

What Does the Belly Sleeper Pillow Feel Like?

Next, let’s talk a little bit about how it feels to sleep on this pillow. Overall pillow feel is a combination of both firmness and loft. I’ll describe both in detail below.

Remember, feel is subjective, and will vary a bit depending on your preferences.

Belly Sleeper Pillow Firmness

The best pillow firmness for you depends on your preferred sleeping position. Stomach sleepers in particular need a soft feel. Luckily for them, the Belly Sleeper pillow has a very soft foam feel. It’s made of soft polyfoam that really compresses under your head, allowing you to sink into it a bit for some great pressure relief.

Side sleeping on the belly sleeper pillow
The Belly Sleeper pillow compresses under your head when you lie down on it.

I thought this pillow felt similar to a memory foam pillow because it had a slow response to pressure. But, its poly foam build is slightly more responsive than traditional memory foam, which can be nice for sleepers who like to sink into their pillow a little more quickly.

See Latest Deals
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow

The perfect pillow for stomach sleepers is finally here! 

Belly Sleeper Pillow Loft

Loft and firmness work together to create a pillow’s overall feel. A soft pillow and firm pillow with the same initial loft will actually have different lofts when you lie down on each, because the softer pillow will compress more underneath your weight.

The Belly Sleeper pillow has an initial loft of 2.5 inches, which is quite low. It compresses when you lie down on it, so its loft is actually slightly lower. This ultra slim loft and soft feel make it a great choice for certain sleepers, and a poor choice for others. Take a look below to see how this pillow performs for a variety of different sleepers.

Side — Side sleepers do best on a firm pillow with a high loft, which is pretty much the opposite of what the Belly Sleeper pillow offers. This thin pillow won’t allow side sleepers to keep their spines neutrally aligned, and will drop their heads down below their shoulders. This can lead to neck pain over time, so I’d recommend these folks opt for an alternative pillow option.

Back — Back sleepers who like a very thin feel could potentially like this pillow. However, if you’re looking for ergonomic support I’d suggest one of our best pillows for back sleepers instead. Something a bit thicker is likely a better fit for your needs.

Stomach — Stomach sleepers fare best on a soft pillow with a thin profile. They need a pillow that doesn’t lift their head up too far, which can bend their neck in an uncomfortable position. This pillow is one of the best pillows for stomach sleepers available because it will help them maintain a neutral spinal alignment, which is the key to avoiding neck and back pain.

Stomach sleeping on the Belly sleeper pillow
This pillow felt really comfortable on my stomach!

Under the Arm — If you enjoy hugging a pillow at night, the Belly Sleeper may not be the best option for you. It’s not moldable or fluffable, so it doesn’t feel as cuddly under the arm as another option might. If you like a foam feel but want some moldability, I’d consider a shredded memory foam option, like the Coop Home Goods pillow, instead.

Between the Legs — As a side sleeper myself, I enjoy placing a thin pillow between my legs to reduce rubbing around my knees and keep my spine aligned. The Belly Sleeper pillow is a great between the legs option, and felt really comfortable between my knees. But keep in mind that this is subjective, and someone a bit heavier than me might prefer something a bit thicker that offers more cushioning around the knees.

See Latest Deals
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow

The perfect pillow for stomach sleepers is finally here! 

What is the Belly Sleeper Pillow Made Of?

Next up, let’s talk about what this pillow is made of!

I’ll start out with the pillow cover. The Belly Sleeper pillow uses a bamboo cover that feels incredibly soft and breathable. This cover is also moisture-wicking and odor resistant, which are both great perks. If you’re looking to add a little extra breathability to this pillow, I’d actually recommend using it without a pillow case! The removable cover is machine washable and so soft that it actually felt better on my skin than most pillowcases!

Belly sleeper pillow cover
A closer look at the Belly Sleeper’s soft cover.

This pillow’s internal fill is a solid block of polyurethane foam. It offers some nice contouring and a great soft feel, making it a great material for stomach sleeping. This fill is infused with cooling gel to help encourage airflow throughout the pillow. In my opinion, it feels similar to a responsive gel memory foam. This foam is also hypoallergenic, which is a great perk!

Is the Belly Sleeper Pillow Good for Hot Sleepers?

If you’re an especially hot sleeper the original Belly Sleeper pillow might not be the best option for you. Foam pillows tend to be less cooling than other pillow types, even if they’re infused with cooling technology. If cooling is a priority for you, I’d recommend checking out Belly Sleep’s Cooling Gel Belly Sleeper pillow or taking a look at some of our best cooling pillows.

You could also try pairing your new Belly Sleeper pillow with some of the best cooling sheets to make it work for you!

Belly Sleeper Pillow Sizes and Prices

Take a look at the Belly Sleeper’s sizing and pricing info below. Keep in mind that this pillow is offered in standard size and has a fairly standard shape (though it features gently curved edges), which means you can pair it with any pillowcase you like. Belly Sleep actually offers some of their own pillowcases that fit on this low-profile pillow a little more snugly. Personally, I found this pillow’s machine washable cover so soft that I preferred using it without a pillowcase!

Price listed will be before discount or offer for each size. Be sure to click on our coupon buttons to snag a deal on this pillow.

Standard28" x 16" x 2.5"$79.99
See Latest Deals
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow

The perfect pillow for stomach sleepers is finally here! 

My Final Thoughts About the Belly Sleeper Pillow

Well folks, we’ve reached the end of my review! By now, you should know that stomach sleepers thrive on soft, low-profile pillows that offer a little cushioning, but don’t force them to crane their necks into an uncomfortable position as they sleep. This means that the Belly Sleeper pillow is one of the best pillows out there for them!

Sleepers who spend the majority of the night in other positions might want to be wary of this pillow, since features that feel great to stomach sleepers can feel uncomfortable to others. But, if you know you enjoy soft, slim pillows, the Belly Sleeper should be right up your alley.

Belly Sleeper Pillow Policies and FAQs

Does the Belly Sleeper pillow come with a sleep trial?

Yes, this pillow comes with a 30-night trial period.

Does the Belly Sleeper pillow come with a warranty?

Yes, this pillow comes with a forever warranty.

How does the Belly Sleeper pillow ship?

The Belly Sleeper pillow will ship for free and arrives slightly compressed in a box. I’d recommend giving it at least 24 hours to decompress before you sleep on it. As an additional perk, Belly Sleeper occasionally offers free 2-day delivery during sales.

How do I clean the Belly Sleeper pillow?

The Belly Sleeper pillow’s outer cover is removable and machine washable. The inner polyfoam fill is spot clean only.

Belly Sleeper Pillow Vs

It’s always a good idea to compare a pillow you’re considering to a few other brands before making a final decision. Below, I’ll compare the Belly Sleeper pillow to two other popular pillows for stomach sleepers, the Saatva pillow and the I AM Stomach Sleeper pillow from eLuxury.

Belly Sleeper Pillow vs Saatva Pillow

The Saatva latex pillow.
The Saatva pillow.
  • The Saatva pillow is made of a combination of down alternative and latex.
  • It has a very moldable feel, which is nice for stomach sleepers.
  • The Saatva’s inner pillow is removable, which is great for stomach sleepers looking for a flatter pillow.
  • Learn more in my full Saatva pillow review.

Belly Sleeper Pillow vs I AM Stomach Sleeper Pillow

I AM A Stomach Sleeper Side
The I AM Stomach Sleeper pillow.
  • The I AM Stomach Sleeper pillow is filled with soft polyester cluster fiber which gives it a soft, moldable feel.
  • This pillow sleeps cooler than the Belly Sleeper pillow because its fill is more breathable.
  • The I AM Stomach Sleeper pillow is completely machine washable.
  • Learn more in my full I AM Stomach Sleeper pillow review.

Still not sure if this is the right pillow for you? Check out how we rated it below to make a final decision. And if you’re a stomach sleeper looking to get an even better night’s sleep, check out some of the best mattresses for stomach sleepers too.

See Latest Deals
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow
Belly Sleeper Pillow

The perfect pillow for stomach sleepers is finally here! 

  • Materials
  • Comfort
  • Value
  • Cooling
  • Trial
  • Warranty
  • Durability
Madison Schaper

Madison Schaper

Madison is a former Staff Writer at Sleepopolis who covered mattresses, bedding, and sleep accessories.