Nolah Cooling Foam vs Nolah AirFiber vs Nolah Squishy: Which Is Best For You?
Depending on how you sleep, a pillow can feel different to you than it might to someone else. Let’s go over who I think should try each of these pillows and who they might not be best suited for. If you want to learn about any of these pillows more in-depth, be sure to check out my Nolah Cooling Foam pillow review, Nolah AirFiber pillow review, and Nolah Squishy pillow review.Who should try the Nolah Cooling Foam pillow
- If you are a side sleeper, I think you will like this pillow as it offers a cushioning, but supportive feel. It also has a high loft to offer neck support to maintain your spinal alignment.
- If you are a hot sleeper, the cool-to-the-touch feel of the Nolah Cooling Foam pillow should keep you sleeping comfortably.
- If you like a responsive, buoyant pillow, you will likely appreciate the latex-like feel of the AirFoam.
Who should not try the Nolah Cooling Foam pillow
- If you are a back, stomach, or combination sleeper, you might find this pillow too lofty to sleep comfortably in these positions.
- If you want a king size pillow, this won’t be a good option, as it is only available in a queen size.
- If you want an adjustable pillow, the Nolah Cooling Foam won’t work for you, as the loft cannot be customized.
Nolah’s Cooling Foam Pillow has a medium-firm feel and a quick response to pressure, so it conforms nicely to your head and neck.
Nolah Cooling Foam Pillow
Who should try the Nolah AirFiber pillow
- If you are a stomach sleeper, you should find the soft feel and low loft of the Nolah AirFiber pillow super comfortable.
- If you are a hot sleeper, the Phase Change Material cover used on this pillow should keep you nice and cool.
- If you like a fluffy, moldable pillow, then the feel of this pillow should work well for you.
Who should not try the Nolah AirFiber pillow
- If you are a side sleeper, this pillow is too soft and low lofted to provide enough support for you.
- If you want a king size pillow, this won’t be a good match for you, as it is only available in a queen size.
- If you want an adjustable pillow, the Nolah AirFiber isn’t a good choice for you, as it cannot be adjusted or customized.
The Nolah AirFiber is a down-alternative pillow with a cool-to-the-touch cover.
Nolah AirFiber Pillow
Who should try the Nolah Squishy pillow
- If you are a side sleeper, the Nolah Squishy is a great option for you. It is very supportive and comes with a high loft (which can be adjusted), which is great for providing neck support.
- If you are a back sleeper, the Nolah Squishy can also work well for you, as long as you adjust the loft to be lower.
- If you are a hot sleeper, the Nolah Squishy is a good option, as well. It features a cooling bamboo cover and shredded foam fill, which allows for some breathability in the pillow.
Who should not try the Nolah Squishy pillow
- If you are a stomach sleeper, this pillow isn’t the best option for you. It is likely too firm and would require removing most of the fill to achieve a low enough loft to sleep comfortably.
- If you like a pillow that you can sink into or that conforms around you, this won’t be a good option, as it has a much more supportive, elevating feel.
- If you want just one pillow or a king size pillow, the Nolah Squishy isn’t a good choice. Nolah sells this pillow in two-packs of queen sizes only.
The Nolah Squishy pillow definitely lives up to its squishy name! It’s squishy, but the shredded foam fill is very elevating and supportive—making it an especially great pillow for side sleepers, who need to keep their head and neck in alignment.
Nolah Squishy Pillow
What Do the Nolah Pillows Feel Like?
Now let’s talk about how these pillows feel. I personally tested all three of these pillows to get a good sense of how they feel, but keep in mind feel is subjective. You might have a different experience than I did. At Sleepopolis, we rate pillows’ firmness level as soft, medium, or firm. We recommend soft pillows for stomach sleepers, medium pillows for back sleepers, and firm pillows for side sleepers to best maintain spinal alignment.Nolah Cooling Foam Pillow Firmness
I thought the Nolah Cooling Foam pillow had a medium-firm feel. When I pressed into the pillow, it felt squishy and soft, but once I laid on it, the pillow felt much more buoyant, elevating, and firm. The feel reminded me of a latex pillow, because it was more responsive and bouncy than a traditional memory foam pillow. Still, the foam used in this pillow is slower-moving than real latex foam.
Nolah AirFiber Pillow Firmness
I found the Nolah AirFiber pillow to have a soft feel. My head and neck sank right into this pillow, not propping me up much. I also thought it was quite fluffy and moldable — similar to a real down pillow.
Nolah Squishy Pillow Firmness
I thought the Nolah Squishy also had a medium-firm feel. This pillow has a super supportive feel that kept my head and neck elevated. Additionally, the foam doesn’t allow you to sink in too deeply, nor does it contour around your head much. It provides a much more buoyant feeling.
Nolah Cooling Foam, Nolah AirFiber, and Nolah Squishy Pillow Lofts
Another factor to consider aside from firmness is a pillow’s loft, or height. Like firmness, different lofts work best for different sleeping positions. We recommend a low loft for stomach sleepers, a medium loft for back sleepers, and a high loft for side sleepers. The Nolah Cooling Foam pillow has a high loft and the Nolah AirFiber pillow has a low loft. The Nolah Squishy has a high loft initially, but it also has an adjustable loft, meaning you can remove some of the fill to lower the height to suit your preferences. Now let’s go over how I felt sleeping with these pillows in different sleeping positions. Side — I found the Nolah Cooling Foam pillow very comfortable for sleeping on my side, as it provided great support for my head and neck. The Nolah AirFiber pillow was far too soft and low lofted — I felt my head and neck sink straight through the pillow. I also thought the Nolah Squishy was great for side sleeping — it’s firm and high enough to provide nice neck support.
Back — The Nolah Cooling Foam pillow felt too tall and too firm for me to sleep comfortably on my back. The Nolah AirFiber is a little softer than I would normally choose for a back sleeper, but I think it can still work for back sleepers who like that softer feel. I also thought the Nolah Squishy could work for back sleepers, but I had to lower the loft in order to sleep comfortably in this position.
Stomach — I found the Nolah Cooling Foam pillow to be too lofty and too firm to sleep comfortably on my stomach — I felt my neck craning upwards, which can cause neck strain. The Nolah AirFiber was super comfortable for me sleeping on my stomach, because it is so soft and low lofted. It didn’t put any strain on my neck. The Nolah Squishy is too firm for stomach sleeping to me and I think you would have to remove a considerable amount of fill to make it low enough, so it may be more worthwhile to purchase a different pillow.
Comparing Nolah Cooling Foam, Nolah AirFiber, and Nolah Squishy Pillow Constructions
Let’s take a look at what these three pillows are made of.Nolah Cooling Foam Pillow Materials
Cover: The Nolah Cooling Foam pillow’s cover is made from 100 percent cotton coated in phase-changing Outlast® cooling material, which is made of paraffin wax. This material gives the cover a cool-to-the-touch feel.
Fill: This pillow’s fill is a block of Nolah AirFoam, the brand’s proprietary foam, which is made from 100 percent polyurethane foam, or poly foam.
Nolah AirFiber Pillow Materials
Cover: The Nolah AirFiber’s cover is also 100 percent cotton coated in Outlast® cooling material.
Fill: The Nolah AirFiber pillow is filled with 100 percent polyester fiber, which Nolah says is ultra-thin and light spun to achieve a high loft and provide support. This is a down-alternative — a synthetic material meant to mimic the feeling of down.
Nolah Squishy Pillow Materials
Cover: The Nolah Squishy’s cover is made from a blend of polyester and bamboo viscose.
Inner Chamber: The inner chamber is what folds the fill of the pillow. It is made from polyurethane foam pads to give the pillow an extra squish.
Fill: The fill of the Squishy pillow is shredded foam.
Are the Nolah Pillows Good for Hot Sleepers?
Yes, I think all three Nolah pillows are good for hot sleepers. The Nolah Squishy isn’t quite as cooling as the other two, since it doesn’t have the Outlast® cooling material on the cover. However, the bamboo in the cover of the Squishy helps to maintain a cooler temperature while the shredded fill allows for some airflow, preventing body heat from being trapped. The Nolah Cooling Foam and AirFiber both sleep extremely cool, thanks to the Outlast® cooling material. It makes the covers of these pillows cool to the touch. For more options, check out our best cooling pillows. And while you’re at it, round out your bedding with some of our best cooling sheets.Nolah Pillows Sizes and Prices
Wondering how much these pillows cost? Here’s a breakdown of prices. Price listed will be before discount or offer for each size. To get our best deal, click one of the coupons throughout this article.Nolah Cooling Foam Pillow Price
| Size | Dimensions | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Queen | 17″ x 23″ | $99 |
Nolah Cooling Foam Pillow
Nolah’s Cooling Foam Pillow has a medium-firm feel and a quick response to pressure, so it conforms nicely to your head and neck.
Read Full ReviewNolah AirFiber Pillow Price
| Size | Dimensions | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Queen | 20″ x 30″ | $79 |
Nolah AirFiber Pillow
The Nolah AirFiber is a down-alternative pillow with a cool-to-the-touch cover.
Read Full ReviewNolah Squishy Pillow Price
| Size | Dimensions | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Queen (x2) | 18″ x 24″ | $198 |
Nolah Squishy Pillow
The Nolah Squishy pillow definitely lives up to its squishy name! It’s squishy, but the shredded foam fill is very elevating and supportive—making it an especially great pillow for side sleepers, who need to keep their head and neck in alignment.
Read Full ReviewMy Final Thoughts About the Nolah Pillows
Overall, the Nolah pillows are great quality and offer a variety of options to different sleepers. The Nolah Cooling Foam pillow is a great option for side sleepers, as well as hot sleepers. It has a supportive, latex-like feel that’s beneficial for supporting side sleepers’ necks to prevent neck pain. And the Outlast® cooling material coated cotton cover maintains a cool-to-the-touch feel. However, I think this pillow is too firm and lofty for back and stomach sleepers.
The Nolah AirFiber pillow is also a great choice for hot sleepers, as it has the same cotton cover coated with Phase Change Material that the Cooling Foam pillow has. However, its softer, plusher, and more compressive feel makes the Nolah AirFiber pillow more comfortable to stomach sleepers. It can work for some back sleepers as well, but I wouldn’t recommend it to side sleepers, as it isn’t supportive enough.
The Nolah Squishy offers a supportive, medium-firm feel that works great for side and back sleepers, as well as back/side combo sleepers. It is also adjustable, so you can alter the loft to be lower — which I would recommend for back sleepers. It also sleeps fairly cool, but more temperature-neutral than the other two pillows’ cool-to-the-touch covers. However, I think it is far too firm for stomach sleepers.
Nolah Pillows Policies and FAQs
How do the Nolah pillows ship?
Nolah ships for free within the contiguous United States. You can expect your pillow to ship within one to two business days.
Do the Nolah pillows come with a sleep trial?
Yes, Nolah offers a 30-day trial period for their pillows. If you decide to return your pillow, you will receive a full refund but you will also have to pay the return shipping fees.
Do the Nolah pillows come with a warranty?
Yes, Nolah’s pillows come with a 2-year warranty.
Are the Nolah pillows machine washable?
Only the Nolah AirFiber is completely machine washable. For the Cooling Foam and Squishy pillows, only the covers are machine washable.
What other products does Nolah offer?
Nolah offers a variety of mattresses and sleep accessories, including sheets, a weighted blanket, a mattress topper, mattress protectors, a duvet cover, a comforter, and more.
