We have affiliate relationships where we are paid a commission on sales through some of our links. Also, Casper provided financial support to allow our company to acquire Sleepopolis. See our disclosures.

Mattress Pad Reviews

Mattress pads are a common addition to any mattress and are a great way to add a layer of comfort to an otherwise uncomfortable (or older) mattress. They are relatively inexpensive and can be a great short term solution for a better night’s rest.

Want to just see the full list of mattress pads? Click here to slide down to the bottom of the summary.

What is a mattress pad?

A mattress pad is a relatively thick piece of quilted material that sits on top of your mattress, but below your sheets. It is primarily used to add comfort, but some also can help protect your mattress from general wear and tear and provide an extra layer of defense against, spills, soils and stains.

Adding a mattress pad can slightly change the feel and firmness of your bed. If you find that you are happy with the current feel of your mattress, adding a mattress pad is really an unnecessary expense.

Mattress Protector vs. Mattress Topper vs. Mattress Pad

Mattress protectors, mattress pads and mattress toppers are all different a-la-carte options you can add to an existing mattress. While they sound extremely similar, there are a few key differences to note before you start the search. You may find that not all of these are necessary in your situation, which can save you hundreds of dollars in “bonus bedding”.

Mattress protectors are thin and usually waterproof- designed to sit directly on the surface of your mattress like a fitted sheet. Generally constructed from cotton or polyester, they are added below the fitted sheet and are the last hope to protect your mattress from unwanted stains. The main mission is to repel liquids and keep your mattress in like-new condition.

No matter if your mattress is old or new, I would highly recommend a mattress protector on every single bed. In addition to protecting from liquid stains, a good waterproof mattress protector will also protect against dust mites, bed bugs, pet dander or other allergens that may be floating around in the bedroom.

See our full list of mattress protector reviews here.

Sleep Tite protector - one of my favorite protectors and an amazing value
Sleep Tite protector – one of my favorite protectors and an amazing value

In comparison to mattress protectors, mattress toppers couldn’t be any more different. While a protector aims to protect, a topper aims to add comfort. A mattress topper can be made of memory foam, latex foam, quilted blends or many other materials. It is typically added atop a mattress that is no longer comfortable.

A thin mattress topper, 1-2” can slightly adjust the overall feel of your mattress (ex. eLuxurySupply memory foam topper) or a thicker topper, 3-4” can provide a complete overhaul! For more information on mattress toppers, be sure to check out our full list of mattress topper reviews.

Corner shot of the eLuxurySupply 2" memory foam mattress topper
Corner shot of the eLuxurySupply 2″ memory foam mattress topper

Mattress pads act as somewhat of a hybrid between mattress protectors and mattress toppers. They can provide protection from liquid spills and allergens as well as add an extra layer of comfort to your existing mattress. The thick quilted construction can provide a small amount of pressure relief that your current mattress may be lacking in.

FAQDo I need a mattress pad or a mattress protector?

eLuxurySupply bamboo mattress pad close up shot
eLuxurySupply bamboo mattress pad close up shot

Types of Mattress Pads

In the world of mattress pads, there are two main styles, fitted mattress pads and anchor mattress pads. Fitted mattress pads are thick and fit just like a fitted sheet would. The quilted top provides extra stability and the elastic side panels stretch over the sides of the mattress to hold it firmly in place.

Anchor Mattress Pads

Anchor mattress pads have a similar top to the fitted mattress pads, but the sides are treated a little different. In this installation, there are no side panels, but rather the top is secured to the mattress with a thick elastic band at the corners. While this is generally less secure, if you are a light sleeper and not notorious for kicking your bedding off of the bed, an anchor mattress pad may work just fine for you.

Cotton Mattress Pads

In addition to style, there is a variety of materials that a mattress pad can be made out of and each material will result in a mattress pad that’s distinctively different. Cotton mattress pads are the most common. They are typically thinner than the other styles as well as being machine washable. This feature alone may be a life saver for the stain-prone sleepers!

Latex Mattress Toppers

A natural latex mattress pad is made from natural rubber and is extremely durable. Depending on the thickness and type of latex, these mattress pads can be used to soften a firm mattress or firm up an overly soft one.  A latex mattress pad is also mold and mildew resistant which make it a great choice for the eco-friendly, hypo-allergenic sleeper. Check out our full list of latex mattress topper reviews here.

Response time on latex is very quick, note the fast bounce back
Response time on latex is very quick, note the fast bounce back

Wool Mattress Pads

Wool mattress pads may work well for sleepers who are looking for a durable mattress pad that can accommodate rapidly changing seasons. These types of mattress pads are typically cool and dry in the summer, but warm and cozy in the winter. It’s also important to add that this type of mattress pad is one of the most expensive mattress pads on the market.

Feather Mattress Pads

Feather mattress pads, also known as featherbeds or down mattress pads, are another option if you are looking to soften an existing mattress that is too firm. These mattress pads are more affordable than a wool mattress pad, but maintain many of the same benefits. Many of these mattress pads are made exclusively with goose or duck feathers.

One word of caution- when shopping for feather mattress pads, be sure to select one that has a quilted top. This will help to keep all of the feathers evenly distributed as you sleep and avoid a lumpy mattress pad.

Fiber Mattress Pads

Fiber mattress pads, sometimes referred to as fiberbeds or down alternative mattress pads (ex. eLuxurySupply bamboo mattress pad), are another affordable option if you’re looking to soften a firm mattress. These mattress pads are commonly compared to feather mattress pads, but instead of using traditional feathers, they are filled with a polyester fiber or down alternative material.

These are typically the most affordable between wool and traditional down mattress pads, but the lifespan may not be as long. In addition, some sleepers find that these types of mattress pads become lumpy and flatten out in a short period of time. Regular “fluffing” will help to prolong this as well as choosing one with a quilted top.

Our Favorite Mattress Pads

When it comes to a good night’s rest, there are many choices that you can make to help make sure you fall asleep and stay asleep longer. Adding a mattress pad is a great way to modify your existing mattress, without breaking the bank. Here are some of Sleepopolis’ favorite mattress pads to get you started:

Latex for Less Mattress Topper
Latex for Less Mattress Topper
Latex for Less Mattress Topper
Latex for Less Mattress Topper

Bouncy and 100% organic, the Latex for Less topper could be great for addition to your bed for a wide range of sleepers!

Slumber Cloud Nacreous Pad
Slumber Cloud Nacreous Mattress Pad
Slumber Cloud Nacreous Mattress Pad
Slumber Cloud Nacreous Mattress Pad
This super-cooling mattress pad is ideal for sleepers who run hot! Save $15 on your order by using the code "SLEEPOPOLIS"
eLuxurySupply Bamboo Mattress Pad
eLuxurySupply Bamboo Mattress Pad
eLuxurySupply Bamboo Mattress Pad
eLuxurySupply Bamboo Mattress Pad

Plush and gentle, the bamboo mattress pad from eLuxury makes any bed feel that much softer. Enjoy 30% off your purchase with code SleepopolisReview.

The following two tabs change content below.
Logan Block
Logan is the content director of Sleepopolis, which means he not only reviews new mattresses every week, but also curates all the comparisons, best of pages, and video guides on the site. He takes a straightforward, honest approach to his reviews and endeavors to give viewers an objective look at each new product he tries out. Logan has perfected his method by personally testing over 200 different mattresses, so he’s not only able to discern the overall vibe of a specific bed, but to contextualize its feel within the bed-in-a-box market as a whole. When he’s not hopping on a new bed or working with our editorial team to whip up an engaging sleep education guide, you can find him reading books on world history, walking his dog Pepper, or searching for the best cheeseburger in New York City.
Logan Block

Latest posts by Logan Block (see all)